The Dance of Shiva · Ananda K. Coomaraswamy
Buddhist Primitives
5 of 14The Early Buddhist view of art is strictly hedonistic. Just as little as Early Buddhism dreamed of an expression of its char- acteristic ideas through poetry, drama, or music, so little was it imagined that the arts of sculpture and painting could be anything but worldly in their purpose and effect. The arts were looked upon as physical luxuries, and loveliness as a snare. "Beauty is nothing to me/' says the Dasa Dhamma Sutta, "neither the beauty of the body nor that that comes of dress." The Brethren were forbidden to allow the figures of men and women to be painted on monastery walls, and were permitted only representa- tions of wreaths and creepers. 1 The psychological foundation of this attitude is nowhere more clearly revealed than in a passage of the Visuddhi Magga, where we find that painters, musicians, perfumers, cooks, and elixir-prescribing physicians are all classed together as purveyors of sensuous luxuries, whom others honour "on account of love and devotion to the sensations excited by forms and other objects of sense." This is the characteristic Hlnayana position throughout, and it is, of course, conspicuous also in the Jaina system, and in certain phases of Brahmanical thought, particularly in the period contemporary with early Buddhism. It is only in the third and second centuries b. c. that we find the Buddhists patronizing craftsmen and employing art for edifying ends. From what has just been said, however, it will be well understood that there had not at this time come into being any truly Buddhist or Brahmanical idealistic art; and thus "Early Buddist" art was necessarily the popular Brahmanical art and animistic art of the day, adapted to Buddhist requirements. The only exception to this rule is that special phase of Early Buddhist art which is represented by the capital of the Asoka columns, of which the forms are not merely non-Buddhist, but of extra-Indian origin.
2 The Indian non-Buddhist art that we have evidence of in the age 1 Cullavagga, vi, 3, 2. 2 Visvakarma, SO, 81. of Asoka and in the period immediately following Asoka, is chiefly concerned with the cult of nature-spirits — the Earth God- dess, the Nagas or Serpent kings of the waters, and the Yaksha kings who rule the Four Quarters. The Maurya types are rep- resented by the well-known free-standing female figure at Besna- gar, 1 and the Parkham figure 2 now in the Mathura Museum. The early Buddhist art of SanchI and Bharhut, probably slightly later, reflects the prevalence of the animistic cults in placing low- relief figures of the Yaksha, guardians of the Four Quarters, as protectors of the entrance gateways. 3 That the nature-spirits should thus act as guardians of Buddhist shrines reflects the essential victory of Buddhism, precisely as the story of the Naga Muchalinda, who, in the literary tradition, shelters the Buddha during the week of storms. Besides the Guardians of the Quarters we find at Sanchi figures of beautiful Yakshinls or dryads, whose function may be partly protective, but is also in large degree honorary and decorative. The Yakshini figure here reproduced [Plate VI, b] is typical of all that is best in the art of SanchI; but in what different world this happy dryad moves from that of the Pali Suttas, where orthodox Buddhism tries to prove that "as the body when dead is repulsive, so also is it when alive" ! Buddhist monasticism — to use the language of Blake — sought consistently to bolt and bar the "Western Gates" : but our SanchI dryad rather seems to say "the soul of sweet delight can never be defiled." The art of SanchI is essentially pagan, and this appears not only in its fearless happiness, untinged by puritan misgiving or by mystic intuition, but also in the purely representative and real- istic technique.
It was in the main a later Mahayana and Vaish- nava achievement of the Indian lyric spirit to discover that the two worlds of spiritual purity and sensuous delight need not, and perhaps ultimately cannot, be divided. In any case the SanchI art is plainly not an expression of Early Buddhist feeling: and so also it is not primitive, but, on the con- trary, it is the classic achievement of an old popular art already long practised in less permanent materials. If there is at this 1 Visvakarmd, 6\. 2 Visvakarma, 26. 3 A much later example of the same arrangement is illustrated in Visvakannd, 75. time any Buddhist art that can be fairly called primitive, it is only to be recognized in architecture, where the simple forms of the early stiipas, and their undecorated railings, and the severe design of the early excavated chaitya-hatts truly reflect the intellectual and austere enthusiasm of Early Buddhism. Another part of the art of the Bharhut railing and the Sanchi gateways is devoted to the illustration of edifying legends, partic- ularly stories of the former lives of the Buddha, and of the last incarnation. The work is delicately executed in low relief — we know from a contemporary inscription that amongst the crafts- men who contributed to the decoration of the Sanchi toranas were the "ivory-workers of Bhilsa" — and affords us a remarkable record of Indian life, with its characteristic environment, manners and cults set out with evident realism and a wealth of circum- stantial detail. But for all their interest these reliefs, too, are essentially illustrations of edifying anecdotes, and only to a limited extent — less, for example, than the similar, but, of course, very much later, illustrations at Borobodur — directly express the Early Buddhist view of life and death. There is, however, one respect in which that view is perfectly reflected; in the fact that the figure of the Master himself is nowhere represented.
Even in the group of episodes which illustrate the Great Renunciation — Prince Siddhattha's departure from home, riding upon the back of the horse Kanthaka, and attended by the groom Channa — Kanthaka's back is bare, and we see only the figures of the Devas who lift up the feet of the horse lest men should be roused by the sound of his hoofs, while the presence of the Prince is only indicated by the parasol of dominion borne beside the horse. In other compositions the Buddha is represented by symbols such as the Wisdom Tree or the conventionally represented footprints, the "Feet of the Lord" [Plate VI, c]. It will be realized at once that the absence of the Buddha figure from the world of living men — where, however, there yet remain the traces of his ministry, literally footprints on the sands of time — is a true artistic rendering of the Master's guarded silence respecting the after-death state of those who have attained Nirvana: "the Perfect One is released from this, that his being should be gauged by the measure of the corporeal world/ 1 he is released from "name and form." In the omission of the figure of the Buddha, the Early Buddhist art is truly Budd- dhist: for the rest, it is an art about Buddhism, rather than Bud- dhist art. Changes were meanwhile proceeding in the material of Bud- dhist belief. This belief is no longer merely intellectual, but has undergone an emotional development akin to that which finds expression in the bhakti doctrine of the Bhagavad Gitd: Even they that be born of sin. even women, traffickers, and serfs, if they turn to Me, come to the Supreme Path: be assured, O son of KuntI, that none who is devoted to Me is lost. Similarly we find, even in so early a text as the Majjhima Nik ay a that those who have not yet even entered the Paths, "are sure of heaven if they have love and faith towards Me."
Gradu- ally the idea of Buddhahood replaces that of Arahatta: the orig- inal agnosticism is ignored, and the Buddha is endowed with all the qualities of transcendental godhead as well as with the physical peculiarities or perfections of the Superman (maha-purusha) . The Buddha thus conceived, together with the Bodhisattvas or Buddhas-to-be, presently engaged in the active work of salvation, , became the object of a cult and was regarded as approachable by worship. In all this we see not merely an internal develop- ment of metaphysics and theology, but also the influence of the lay community: for a majority of men, and still more the majority of women, have always been more ready to worship than to know. At Amaravati we still find that the Buddha is represented by symbols, but it may be clearly seen from the passionate devotion of those who worship at the symbol-shrines — and many of these are women, as in the case of the fragment here reproduced in Plate VI, c — that the One adored must have been conceived in others terms than those of a purely intellectual psychological analysis. Even before the Buddha figure is represented in official Buddhist art, the Buddha had become an object of adoration, a very personal god: and it cannot surprise us that the Master's figure should soon appear wherever Buddhist piety erected shrines and monuments. We know that images of Hindu gods were already in use in the second century, b. c, and it is highly probable that Buddha figures were in similar private use long before they took their place in a public cult. Before, however, we speak of the Buddha images, we must refer to a second phase of religious experience, which plays a great part alike in the development of Buddhism and Hinduism. This is the practice of Yoga, whereby enlightenment and emanci- pation are sought to be attained by meditation calculated to release the individual from empirical consciousness.
Even in the earliest Buddhist praxis it would be difficult to exaggerate the part which these contemplative exercises play in the spiritual history of the Brethren, and to a lesser extent of laymen, for while the most abstract meditations lead to the attainment of Nirvana and the station of "No-return," the lesser no less certainly led to rebirth in the higher heavens. It is just for purposes of medita- tion that lonely places and roots of trees are so highly praised in the Buddhist literature, and of this the classic example is that of the Buddha himself, who reached the final enlightenment while seated in yogi-fashion at the foot of the Wisdom-tree. The essence of the method lies in the concentration of thought upon a single point, carried so far that the duality of subject and object is resolved into a perfect unity — "when," in the words of Schelling, "the perceiving self merges in the self -perceived. At that moment we annihilate time and the duration of time; we are no longer in time, but time, or rather eternity itself, is in us." A very beautiful description of the yogi is given as follows in the Bhagavad Gtta, 1 and as quoted here in a condensed form applies almost equally to Buddhist and Brahmanical practice, for the yoga is a praxis rather than a form of sectarian belief: — Abiding alone in a secret place, without craving and without pos- sessions, he shall take his seat upon a firm seat, neither over-high nor over-low, and with the working of the mind and of the senses held in check, with body, head and neck maintained in perfect equi- poise, looking not round about him, so let him meditate, and thereby reach the peace of the Abyss: and the likeness of one such, who knows the boundless joy that lies beyond the senses and is grasped by intuition, and who swerves not from the truth, is that of a lamp in a windless place that does not flicker.
Long before the Buddha image became a cult object, the familiar form of the seated yogi must have presented itself to the Indian mind in inseparable association with the idea of a mental discipline and of the attainment of the highest station of 1 Bhagavad Glta. vi, 10-21 — omitting the theistic elements. Standing Bodhisattva. Stone sculpture, Ceylon, 2nd century, A.D. self-oblivion; and when the development of imagery followed there was no other form which could have been made a uni- versally recognized symbol of Him-who-had- thus-attained. This figure of the seated Buddha-yogi, with a far deeper content, is as purely monumental art as that of the Egyptian pyramids; and since it represents the greatest ideal which Indian sculpture ever attempted to express, it is well that we find pre- served even a few magnificent examples of comparatively early date. Amongst these the colossal figure at Anuradhapura is almost certainly the best [Plate VII]. The same ancient Bud- dhist site affords examples of a Bodhisattva, here reproduced on Plate VIII, and of two standing Buddhas, illustrated in Plates IX and X, while nearly related to these are the standing figures of Buddhas lately excavated at Amaravati, reproduced on Plate XI. To all these works we may fairly assign the honoured name of primitives, since their massive forms and austere outline are immediately determined by the moral grandeur of the thesis and the suppressed emotion of its realiza- tion, without any intrusion of individuality or parade of skill. The fulness of the modelling expresses a high degree of vitality, but does not yet show the conscious elegance and suavity of Gupta types. Wc are not in position to precisely date these Buddhist primi- tives of Anuradhapura and Amaravati, but they may not be earlier than the first or second century a. d. and can hardly be later than the third or fourth.
In describing these works as primitive, it is not, of course, suggested that they are the earliest or nearly the earliest of Buddha figures extant, nor that all of them are absolutely free from any element of western formulation, but merely that in them the primitive inspiration is better pre- served than anywhere else. I have already suggested that the figures of the seated Buddha, if not the standing types, probably came into use as cult objects a good deal earlier, perhaps in the second century b. c. ; and if. these were generally made in wood or other impermanent materials, this would be in accord with all that we know of the general development of Indian plastic art and architecture. In any case, as M. Foucher points out, 1 the 1 Foucher (A.), L'Origine grecque de VImage du Bouddha, Paris, 1913. conventional character of the Buddha figure of the Kanishka reliquary denote un art deja stereotype, et . . suffit pour reporter d'au moins cent ans en arriere et faire par suite remonter au I er siecle avant notre ere la creation du type plastique du Bienheureux. The same may be said of the Bodhisattvas. Indra and Brahma were perhaps the types from which the sculptural representations of Avalokitesvara and Maitreya were evolved, and Mr. Spooner has recorded his view that this evolution "was an accomplished fact prior to any form of the Gandhara school with which we are yet familiar," pointing out here too that "the forms of both are stereotyped" already in the earliest examples from Gandhara.* We have so far left out of account the abundant and well- known Grseco-Buddhist art of Gandhara, dating from the 1st to the 4th century a. d., as well as the school of Mathura, which in part derives from the older art of Sanchi and Bharhut, and is partly dependent upon Gandhara. This omission is not, as M.
Foucher would suggest, "par engouement d'estheticien ou ran- cune de nationaliste," 2 but because we are here concerned to discover the sources of inspiration of Buddhist imagery and to learn how this inspiration was first and most fully expressed. That many western formulae were absorbed into Indian art through Gandhara does not touch the question of feeling; we must avoid the common error of confusing "Formensprache" with "Geist." It is even easy to exaggerate the importance of the western formulae, as such, for whatever else in Buddhist art is borrowed, the cross-legged figure seated upon a lotus throne is entirely Indian in form as well as in idea; and besides this seated figure, the standing Buddha and the images of all the Buddhist gods are but of secondary importance. For several reasons, it seems probable that the actual Gand- hara sculptures are mainly the work of western craftsmen em- ployed by the Gandhara kings to interpret Buddhist ideas, rather than Indian workmen under western guidance; and if some of the workmen were Indian by birth, they nevertheless did not give expression to Indian feeling. We have the parallel modern 1 Spooner, D. B. Archaeological Survey of India, Ann. Rep., 1907-8 (1911), . 2 Foucher (A.), loc. ck. s . STANDING BUDDHA. Stone sculpture, Ceylon, 2nd century, A.D. Standing Buddha. Stone sculpture, Ceylon, 2nd century, A.D. example of the late Raja Ravi Varma, who, despite the nominally Indian subject matter of his paintings, entirely fails to reflect the Indian spirit.
The manner in which the western formulae have been gradually Indianized, alike in the northwest and in the school of Mathura, and thus, as Professor Oskar Miinsterberg remarks, "first de- veloped under national and Buddhist inspiration into a new and genuine art," 1 has been studied in considerable detail by many scholars; but what is equally or more significant for our enquiry is the manner in which certain Indian formulae and Indian ideas are misrepresented at Gandhara, for misrepresentation necessarily implies the pre-existence of a type to be misinterpreted. The plainest case is afforded by the Buddha figure seated on a "lotus throne" (padmasana). In Gandhara sculpture the seated figure is uncomfortably and unstably balanced on a lotus flower that is far too small, and with its pointed petals, like an artichoke, 2 sug- gests a seat of penance rather than of ease (Plate VI, a). The true sense of the padmasana is, of course, to indicate spiritual purity or divinity, and the symbol is only appropriately combined with that of the seated yogi, when this function is fulfilled with- out detracting from the one essential quality of repose. It is specially emphasized in yoga texts that the seat of the yogi is to be firm and easy, "sthira-sukha" and where this condition is overlooked, it is impossible to recognize an immediate expression of the original thesis. The foregoing argument supports the view already men- tioned, that the seated Buddha image in the age of Kanishka was "deja stereotype." It takes us, however, somewhat further, for in connection with the far stronger, though to archaeologists less convincing, aesthetic evidence, it shows plainly that Gandhara sculpture is not primitive Buddhist art. When, then, are we to look for the proto- type of the seated figure thus "deja stereotype?'
Can we postulate a Roman yogi, seated on a lotus throne, and with hands in the dhyani mudra, to set beside the Lateran Sophocles of which the influence is evident in standing images? The sug- gestion is sufficiently absurd to need no refutation. The seated 1 A characteristic example may be studied in Vincent Smith, History of Fine Art in India and Ceylon, Plate xxiv. 2 Miinsterberg (0.)» Chinesische Kunsigeschichie, , n. Buddha, as we have already suggested on d priori grounds, can only be of Indian origin; and this being so, it will be seen how great an exaggeration is involved in speaking of the "Greek Origin of the Image of Buddha." It has been sufficient for our purpose to explain in what senses Gandhara sculpture cannot be regarded as primitive and autoch- thonous Buddhist art; it has not been necessary to emphasize also how little the smug and complacent features of the Gandhara Buddhas and Bodhisattvas, and their listless and effeminate ges- tures, reflect the intellectual vigour or the devotional passion of Buddhist thought. For the benefit of M. Foucher, however, and of other scholars who may suppose, with him, that Mr. Havell, Professor Miinsterberg, and I, have cared more for Indian art than for art, I may point out that our estimate of Gandhara sculpture as of small aesthetic significance must not be taken as evidence of any prejudice against the art of Europe; it simply indicates concurrence in the view that "in the long sands and flats of Roman realism the stream of Greek inspiration is lost for ever." To admire Gandhara art, as art, is not a compliment to the greatness of the Greeks, but only shows how far that great- ness has been misunderstood.
If it is possible for a European critic to write of the mosaics of the Galla Placidia at Ravenna that they are "still coarsely classical," and that "there is a nasty, woolly realism about the sheep, and about the good shepherd more than a suspicion of the stodgy, Graeco-Roman Apollo," 1 then surely we may criticize the sculptures of Gandhara in the same terms without incurring charges of bad faith. To resume: Early Buddhist art is popular, sensuous and ani- mistic Indian art adapted to the purposes of the illustration of Buddhist anecdote and the decoration of Buddhist monuments; Gandhara art is mixed, and misinterpreted equally both eastern and western formulae, which must be older than itself, while it is not Buddhist in expression; the earliest Indian primitives of Buddhist art properly so-called are probably lost. In northern India the absence of primitives is partly to be accounted for by the fact that Buddhist inspiration was there absorbed, not in direct creation, but in adapting Graeco-Roman motifs to its own spiritual ends. In southern India and Ceylon the same energy iBell (dive), ^ . BUDDHIST PRIMITIVES 55 working in greater isolation found a more direct expression; and though the earliest masterpieces may be lost, there are still pre- served at Anuradhapura and AmaravatI magnificent works, which we may fairly speak of as Buddhist primitives. 1 1 Early Buddhist art in China and Japan is also "primitive" in the aesthetic sense, precisely as Christian art in Europe preserved its primi- tive inspiration for six hundred years, because "some new race was always catching the inspiration and feeling and expressing it with primitive sensibility and passion."
Up next
The Dance of Siva
"The Lord of Tillai's Court a mystic dance performs; what's that, my dear?"
About 17 min to read
Take your library with you
Open the next chapter in the app. Reading is free.
Every book is free to read. Downloading the app may not keep this chapter link; return here to open it after installing.