Essays in Zen Buddhism

Essays in Zen Buddhism · D.T. Suzuki

Practical Methods of Zen Instruction, Part 5

48 of 66

We now come to the third class I have styled, “Contradiction,” by which I mean the Zen master’s negation, implicitly or expressly, of what he himself has stated or what has been stated by another. To one and the same question his answer is sometimes “No,” sometimes “Yes.” Or to a well-known and fully-established fact he gives an unqualified denial. From an ordinary point of view he is altogether unreliable, yet he seems to think that the truth of Zen requires such contradictions and denials; for Zen has a standard of its own, which, to our common-sense minds, consists just in negating everything we properly hold true and real. In spite of these apparent confusions, the philosophy of Zen is guided by a thorough-going principle which, when once grasped, its topsy-turviness becomes the plainest truth.

A monk asked the sixth patriarch of the Zen sect in China, who flourished late in the seventh and early in the eighth century, “Who has attained to the secrets of Wobai (Huang-mei)?” Wobai is the name of the mountain where the fifth patriarch, Hung-jên used to reside, and, it was a well-known fact that Hui-nêng, the sixth patriarch, studied Zen under him and succeeded in the orthodox line of transmission. The question was therefore really not a plain regular one, seeking an information about facts. It had quite an ulterior object. The reply of the sixth patriarch was, “One who understands Buddhism has attained to the secrets of Wobai.”

“Have you then attained them?”

“No, I have not.”

“How is it,” asked the monk, “that you have not?”

The answer was, “I do not understand Buddhism.”

Did he not really understand Buddhism? Or is it that not to understand is to understand? This is also the philosophy of the Kena-Upanishad.

The self-contradiction of the sixth patriarch is somewhat mild and indirect when compared with that of Dōgo (Tao-wu). He succeeded to Yakusan (Yüeh-shan Wei-yen, 751–834), but when he was asked by Gohō (Wu-fêng) whether he knew the old master of Yakusan, he flatly denied it, saying, “No, I do not.” Gohō was however persistent, “Why do you not know him?” “I do not, I do not,” was the emphatic statement of Dōgo. The latter thus singularly enough refused to give any reason except simply and forcibly denying the fact which was apparent to our common-sense knowledge.

Another emphatic and unequivocal contradiction by Tesshikaku (T‘ieh-tsui Chiao) is better known to students of Zen than the case just cited. He was a disciple of Jōshu (Chao-chou). When he visited Hōgen (Fa-yen Wên-i, died 958), another great Zen master, the latter asked him, what was the last place he came from. Tesshikaku replied that he came from Jōshu. Said Hōgen,

“I understand that a cypress tree once became the subject of his talk; was that really so?”

Tesshikaku was positive in his denial, saying, “He had no such talk.”

Hōgen protested, “All the monks coming from Jōshu lately speak of his reference to a cypress tree in answer to a monk’s question, ‘What was the real object of the coming east of Bodhi-dharma?’ How do you say that Jōshu made no such reference to a cypress tree?”

Whereupon Tesshikaku roared, “My late master never made such a talk; no slighting allusion to him, if you please!”

Hōgen greatly admired this attitude on the part of the disciple of the famous Jōshu, and said, “Truly, you are a lion’s child!”

In Zen literature, Dharma’s coming from the west, that is, from India, is quite frequently made the subject of the discourse. When a question is asked as to the real object of his coming over to China, it refers to the ultimate principle of Buddhism, and has nothing to do with his personal motive which made him cross the ocean, landing him at some point along the southern coast of China. The historical fact is not the issue here. And to this all-important question numerous answers are given, but so varied and so unexpectedly odd, yet according to Zen masters all expressive of the truth of their teaching.

This contradiction, negation, or paradoxical statement is the inevitable result of the Zen way of looking at life. The whole emphasis of its discipline is placed on the intuitive grasping of the inner truth deeply hidden in our consciousness. And this truth thus revealed or awakened within oneself defies intellectual manipulation, or at least cannot be imparted to others through any of dialectical formulas. It must come out of oneself, grow within oneself, and become one with one’s own being. What others, that is, ideas or images can do, is to indicate the way where lies the truth. This is what Zen masters do. And the indicators given by them are naturally unconventionally free and refreshingly original. As their eyes are always fixed on the ultimate truth itself, anything and everything they can command is utilised to accomplish the end, regardless of its logical conditions and consequences. This indifference to logic is sometimes asserted purposely, just to let us know that the truth of Zen is independent of the intellect. Hence the statement in the Prañā-pāramitā Sūtra, that “Not to have any Dharma to discourse about—this is discoursing about the Dharma.” (Dharmadeśanā dharmadeśaneti subhūte nāsti sa kaścid dharmo yo dharmadeśanā nāmotpalabhyate.)

Haikyu (P‘ei Hsiu), a state minister of the T‘ang dynasty, was a devoted follower of Zen under Ōbaku. One day he showed him a manuscript in which his understanding of Zen was stated. The master took it, and setting it down beside him, made no movement to read it, but remained silent for some little while. He then said, “Do you understand?” “Not quite,” answered the minister. “If you have an understanding here,” said the master, “there is something of Zen. But if it is committed to paper and ink, nowhere is our religion to be found.” Something analogous to this we have already noticed in Hakuin’s interview with Shōju Rōnin. Being a living fact, Zen is only where living facts are handled. Appeal to the intellect is real and living as long as it issues directly from life. Otherwise, no amount of literary accomplishment or of intellectual analysis avails in the study of Zen.

A manuscript the master won't even readMembership note · Open in the app

Up next

Practical Methods of Zen Instruction, Part 6

So far Zen appears to be nothing but a philosophy of negation and contradiction, whereas in fact it has its affirmative side, and in this consists the uniqueness of Zen.

About 7 min to read

Take your library with you

Listen to this chapter

Opens this chapter in the app. Tap Listen to begin. Narration requires membership.

Scan to open this chapter
Continue to the next chapter

Open the next chapter in the app. Reading is free.

Scan to open the next chapter

Every book is free to read. Downloading the app may not keep this chapter link; return here to open it after installing.

Contents

Essays in Zen Buddhism · D.T. Suzuki

66 chapters

  1. 01Preface4 min
  2. 02Introduction: The Art of Seeing Into One's Nature, Part 114 min
  3. 03Introduction: The Art of Seeing Into One's Nature, Part 214 min
  4. 04Introduction: The Art of Seeing Into One's Nature, Part 312 min
  5. 05Zen and Enlightenment4 min
  6. 06Zen and Enlightenment: Life and Spirit of Buddhism, Part 114 min
  7. 07Zen and Enlightenment: Life and Spirit of Buddhism, Part 25 min
  8. 08Zen and Enlightenment: Vital Problems of Buddhism8 min
  9. 09Zen and Enlightenment: Zen and Enlightenment, Part 113 min
  10. 10Zen and Enlightenment: Zen and Enlightenment, Part 27 min
  11. 11Zen and Enlightenment: Enlightenment and Spiritual Freedom9 min
  12. 12Zen and Enlightenment: Zen and Dhyana9 min
  13. 13Zen and Enlightenment: Zen and the Laṅkāvatāra14 min
  14. 14Zen and Enlightenment: Enlightenment as Zen in China, Part 113 min
  15. 15Zen and Enlightenment: Enlightenment as Zen in China, Part 213 min
  16. 16Zen and Enlightenment: Enlightenment as Zen in China, Part 37 min
  17. 17Enlightenment and Ignorance, Part 113 min
  18. 18Enlightenment and Ignorance, Part 22 min
  19. 19Enlightenment and Ignorance, Part 310 min
  20. 20Enlightenment and Ignorance, Part 45 min
  21. 21Enlightenment and Ignorance, Part 510 min
  22. 22Enlightenment and Ignorance, Part 69 min
  23. 23Enlightenment and Ignorance, Part 77 min
  24. 24Enlightenment and Ignorance, Part 87 min
  25. 25History of Zen: Bodhi-dharma to Hui-neng, Part 17 min
  26. 26History of Zen: Bodhi-dharma to Hui-neng, Part 212 min
  27. 27History of Zen: Bodhi-dharma to Hui-neng, Part 313 min
  28. 28History of Zen: Bodhi-dharma to Hui-neng, Part 410 min
  29. 29History of Zen: Bodhi-dharma to Hui-neng, Part 514 min
  30. 30History of Zen: Bodhi-dharma to Hui-neng, Part 64 min
  31. 31History of Zen: Bodhi-dharma to Hui-neng, Part 79 min
  32. 32History of Zen: Bodhi-dharma to Hui-neng, Part 810 min
  33. 33History of Zen: Bodhi-dharma to Hui-neng, Part 913 min
  34. 34History of Zen: Bodhi-dharma to Hui-neng, Part 102 min
  35. 35Satori: The Revelation of a New Truth, Part 15 min
  36. 36Satori: The Revelation of a New Truth, Part 28 min
  37. 37Satori: The Revelation of a New Truth, Part 39 min
  38. 38Satori: The Revelation of a New Truth, Part 45 min
  39. 39Satori: The Revelation of a New Truth, Part 53 min
  40. 40Satori: The Revelation of a New Truth, Part 64 min
  41. 41Satori: The Revelation of a New Truth, Part 710 min
  42. 42Satori: The Revelation of a New Truth, Part 83 min
  43. 43Satori: The Revelation of a New Truth, Part 911 min
  44. 44Practical Methods of Zen Instruction, Part 12 min
  45. 45Practical Methods of Zen Instruction, Part 26 min
  46. 46Practical Methods of Zen Instruction, Part 34 min
  47. 47Practical Methods of Zen Instruction, Part 47 min
  48. 48Practical Methods of Zen Instruction, Part 55 min left
  49. 49Practical Methods of Zen Instruction, Part 67 min
  50. 50Practical Methods of Zen Instruction, Part 79 min
  51. 51Practical Methods of Zen Instruction, Part 811 min
  52. 52Practical Methods of Zen Instruction, Part 915 min
  53. 53Practical Methods of Zen Instruction, Part 109 min
  54. 54The Meditation Hall and Monastic Life, Part 19 min
  55. 55The Meditation Hall and Monastic Life, Part 26 min
  56. 56The Meditation Hall and Monastic Life, Part 33 min
  57. 57The Meditation Hall and Monastic Life, Part 45 min
  58. 58The Meditation Hall and Monastic Life, Part 58 min
  59. 59The Meditation Hall and Monastic Life, Part 66 min
  60. 60The Meditation Hall and Monastic Life, Part 75 min