Symbolical Masonry

Symbolical Masonry · H. L. Haywood

Chapter XLVII. The Hiramic Legend

50 of 58

The Hiramic Legend

"In all my research and study, in all my close analysis of the masterpieces of Shakespeare, in my earnest determination to make those plays appear real on the mimetic stage, I have never, and nowhere, met tragedy so real, so sublime, so magnificent as the legend of Hiram. It is substance without shadow—the manifest destiny of life which requires no picture and scarcely a word to make a lasting impression upon all who can understand. To be a Worshipful Master and to throw my whole soul into that work, with the candidate for my audience and the lodge for my stage, would be a greater personal distinction than to receive the plaudits of people in the theatre of the world."

When so accomplished a judge and critic as Edwin Booth could speak like this of the Hiram Abiff tragedy we humbler students may be forgiven for approaching such a theme in awe if not in silence; in truth, I may confess that I should not dare to write a line on the subject were it not absolutely necessary to the scope of these studies. The majesty of the drama is not the only deterrent; its origin and its interpretation have engaged our best scholars for many years but they have not yet reached an agreement; many of them remain as wide apart as the poles nor is there any hope for an early uniformity of opinion. Therefore I shall be compelled to lay out for reviews such varying hypotheses as seem most reasonable, leaving to you, reader, the privilege of forming your own conclusions.

II

It is generally agreed, however, whatever may be our theory of the origin of the drama, that it was first introduced into the Ritual, in its modern form not more than two hundred years ago. Pike describes it as "a modern invention." Vibert calls it "a comparatively late addition" to the Ritual, and Gould went so far as to fix on 1725 as the most probable date of its introduction into its ceremonies. But while, as I have already said, there is general agreement on this, some scholars, and they not the least considerable, contend that the drama could not have been invented outright in 1725 even if it was amplified or improved, and they believe that the story of the great martyrdom must have existed in some form long before the Eighteenth Century. MacBride believes that "there are traces of the Hiramic Legend in connection with the British Craft Lodges prior to 1717." Newton holds that it was in the possession of the French Compagnonage long before that date and that they "almost certainly learned it from the Freemasons." Even Gould, who is so conservative in his opinions, writes that "the traditions which are gathered round Hiram's name" have "come down to us from ancient times."

III

Eighteenth century writers usually accepted the legend as having been based on actual history, even in details; from this position the pendulum swung to the opposite position, one writer going so far as to say that "nowhere in history, sacred or profane, in no document, upon no monument, is there a single shred of authentic historical evidence to support the Masonic Legend;" while another affirms that "in spite of diligent search no reference on the Hiramic Legend has hitherto been found in Jewish writings." We are now in process of reaction from this extreme negative position as is proved by Max Montesole's brilliant article published in the Transactions of the Arthur's Lodge (vol. i, p. 28) in which he shows that the name of Hiram Abiff in Hebrew literally means "Hiram, his father" or "Hiram, his master," and that the term as such is found in II Chronicles 4: 16. This means that the record tells first of Hiram of Tyre, Solomon's architect, and then of a second Hiram, the former's son or pupil which leaves us to infer that the first Hiram may have died or have been killed.

A title mistaken for a second HiramMembership note · Open in the app

That this latter supposition is not a modern one is proved by a sentence in one of the oldest Jewish writings in which we read that "all workmen were killed that they should not build another Temple devoted to idolatry, Hiram himself being translated to heaven like Enoch." This is doubtless only a Rabbinic legend but it proves that, even to the Jews of ancient times, there had descended a tradition of the Grand Master's death.

Other writers, however, have not agreed with this historical theory but prefer to believe that the drama was devised during Mediæval times. If so it must have come into existence some time before the fourteenth century, for Speth asserts that there are references to it (veiled) in certain of the Old Charges, and Dr. Marks, a learned Hebrew scholar, declares that he found an Arabic manuscript of that date which contains the sentence, "We have found our Lord Hiram."

IV

Some scholars have argued that the drama was brought to Europe by the Knight Templar. Others have seen in it a literary result of popular interest in the Temple which was so frequently the theme of books and speeches in seventeenth century England; but a diligent search among this literature has failed to unearth a single reference to Hiram Abiff. (A.Q.C., vol. xii, p. 142.) Nor has an equally diligent search been able to discover any such references in the Mystery Plays which were once so common in Europe, though some scholars have hoped for light from that quarter. (A.Q.C., vol. xiv, p. 60.) Speth considered that the legend may have originated among early builders as a parabolical story suggested by the old customs of sacrificing a human being under the cornerstone of a building. Pike was of the opinion that it was invented by seventeenth century occultists for the purpose of concealing their teachings. Carr traces it back to a legend still found in Operative Lodges while others hold that it was made out of the whole cloth by Anderson or Desaguliers, while others have seen in it a kind of political allegory devised by Oliver Cromwell (of all men!) or some other republican as a blast against royalty.

To me it seems reasonable to believe that the core of the drama came down from Solomon's day; that it was preserved until mediæval times by Jewish, and especially Kabbalistic, literature; that it found a place among the traditions of the old builders because it was so intimately related to the story of the Temple, around which so much of their symbolism revolved; that it was inherited by seventeenth century Masons, in crude form, and along with the mass of other traditions; that it was elaborated and given its literary form by the early framers of the Ritual; and that it was adopted by them because it embodied so wonderfully the idea at the centre of the Third Degree. As I said above, this theory can not be proved by documentary evidence, but it is the opinion toward which the drift of all our data seems to lead one.

A reconstruction without documentary proofMembership note · Open in the app

The confusion which may have been occasioned by this review of the theories of origin will not be lessened, I fear, when we turn to interpretation, for in this also we find a multitude of counsellors, and few agreeing. To make this diversity as plain as possible I shall set down a table of the theories, with their authors’ names in parentheses, when known; there are fourteen of them (I borrowed the list from Brother Hextall), but even more could be added by a little search.

1. Real and actual death of Hiram Abiff. (Oliver.)

2. Legend of Isis and Osiris. (Oliver.)

3. Allegory of setting sun. (Oliver.)

4. Death of Abel at hand of Cain.

5. Expulsion of Adam from Paradise. (Oliver.)

6. Entry of Noah into Ark. (Freemason's Magazine.)

7. Mourning of Joseph for Jacob. (Oliver.)

8. An astronomical problem. (Yarker.)

9. Death and Resurrection of Jesus. (Oliver; also Pike, in part.)

10. Violent death of King Charles I. (Oliver.)

11. Persecution of the Templars. (De Quincey.)

12. Political invention by Cromwell. (Oliver.)

13. A parable of old age and death. (Oliver.)

14. A drama of regeneration. (Hutchinson.)

It is highly significant that the majority of these theories were born in Bro. Oliver's learned brain; he devoted a life-time almost exclusively to the study of Masonry, and he was a man of unusual intellect. Yet see how bewildered he became in the presence of the drama! how impotent he was to discover any one fact or event to which it might refer! Is not this in itself a solution of the problem? For why should we persist in thinking that the legend as we now have it derives its meaning from any event whatsoever? Why may we not believe that it is simply a dramatic parable of a great experience of the soul in its struggle against adversaries, in its apparent defeat, and its ultimate moral victory? Whatever it may have originally meant, this, surely must be its meaning now.

When fourteen theories point nowhereMembership note · Open in the app

Hiram Abiff is the type of every Christ-like man who lives as an apostle of light and liberty, and his experiences as set forth in the drama are just those experiences, in one degree or another, which attend every such man who stands true to his principles. Adversaries, whether men or circumstances, seek to undermine his courage and betray his soul; they may even encompass his death and apparent defeat, but he lives while they die, for the man who stands true to his loyalties, whatsoever betide, has that within him which contumacy cannot kill, nor death destroy. Such a man is inconquerable even in mortality, and on his lips we might place, without any incongruity whatsoever, the magnificent exclamation of the heroic Fichte:

"I raise my hand to the threatening rock, the raging flood, and the fiery tempest, and cry, 'I am eternal and defy your might; break all upon me; and thou Earth, and thou Heaven, mingle in the wild tumult; and all ye elements, foam and fret yourselves, and crush in your conflict the last atom of the body I call mine,' my WILL, in its own firm purpose, shall soar unwavering and hold over the wreck of the universe!"

Up next

Chapter XLVIII. Eternal Life

That which I believe to be the central idea in the whole Hiram Abiff drama, and consequently the profoundest interpretation of it, is that embodied in the term used as the title of this section.

About 6 min to read

Take your library with you

Listen to this chapter

Opens this chapter in the app. Tap Listen to begin. Narration requires membership.

Scan to open this chapter
Continue to the next chapter

Open the next chapter in the app. Reading is free.

Scan to open the next chapter

Every book is free to read. Downloading the app may not keep this chapter link; return here to open it after installing.

Contents

Symbolical Masonry · H. L. Haywood

58 chapters

  1. 01The M. S.A. National Masonic Library1 min
  2. 02Preface3 min
  3. 03Introduction32 min
  4. 04Chapter I. An Introduction to the First Step8 min
  5. 05Chapter II. The Petition for Membership10 min
  6. 06Chapter III. The Ballot7 min
  7. 07Chapter IV. Worthy and Well-Qualified10 min
  8. 08Chapter V. The Hoodwink8 min
  9. 09Chapter VI. The Cable Tow8 min
  10. 10Chapter VII. The Lodge5 min
  11. 11Chapter VIII. The Entrance8 min
  12. 12Chapter IX. The Sharp Instrument3 min
  13. 13Chapter X. Invoking the Blessing of Deity4 min
  14. 14Chapter XI. Circumambulation5 min
  15. 15Chapter XII. Approaching the East7 min
  16. 16Chapter XIII. The Altar4 min
  17. 17Chapter XIV. The Obligation9 min
  18. 18Chapter XV. The Three Great Lights9 min
  19. 19Chapter XVI. The Lesser Lights4 min
  20. 20Chapter XVII. Lux e Tenebris5 min
  21. 21Chapter XVIII. Words, Grips and Tokens7 min
  22. 22Chapter XIX. The Rite of Salutation4 min
  23. 23Chapter XX. The Apron11 min
  24. 24Chapter XXI. Destitution5 min
  25. 25Chapter XXII. The Northeast Corner5 min
  26. 26Chapter XXIII. Working Tools of an Entered Apprentice8 min
  27. 27Chapter XXIV. An Introduction to the Second Step7 min
  28. 28Chapter XXV. Passing5 min
  29. 29Chapter XXVI. Square on the Breast3 min
  30. 30Chapter XXVII. The Scripture Reading From Amos3 min
  31. 31Chapter XXVIII. The Oblong Square4 min
  32. 32Chapter XXIX. Due Form2 min
  33. 33Chapter XXX. Working Tools of a Fellow Craft12 min
  34. 34Chapter XXXI. The Ashlars4 min
  35. 35Chapter XXXII. The Middle Chamber4 min
  36. 36Chapter XXXIII. Operative and Speculative6 min
  37. 37Chapter XXXIV. The Two Great Pillars9 min
  38. 38Chapter XXXV. The Globes3 min
  39. 39Chapter XXXVI. The Ascent12 min
  40. 40Chapter XXXVII. The Builders7 min
  41. 41Chapter XXXVIII. The Five Senses6 min
  42. 42Chapter XXXIX. The Liberal Arts and Sciences5 min
  43. 43Chapter XL. The Ephraimitish War, and Corn, Wine and Oil3 min
  44. 44Chapter XLI. The Letter G6 min
  45. 45Chapter XLII. An Introduction to the Third Step5 min
  46. 46Chapter XLIII. The Vital Parts of the Breast4 min
  47. 47Chapter XLIV. The Golden Bowl and the Silver Cord4 min
  48. 48Chapter XLV. That Which Was Lost6 min
  49. 49Chapter XLVI. The Trowel6 min
  50. 50Chapter XLVII. The Hiramic Legend8 min left
  51. 51Chapter XLVIII. Eternal Life6 min
  52. 52Chapter XLIX. The Lion's Paw5 min
  53. 53Chapter L. The Emblems9 min
  54. 54Chapter LI. The Emblems (Continued)7 min
  55. 55Chapter LII. The Emblems (Continued)3 min
  56. 56Chapter LIII. The Emblems (Continued)5 min
  57. 57Chapter LIV. Conclusion7 min
  58. 58Appendix: Questions for Discussion63 min