Upanishads Part I

Upanishads Part I · Various

Eighth Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: TENTH KHANDA.

Translated by Max Müller (1879) · 164 of 237

TENTH KHANDA. 1. 'He who moves about happy in dreams, he is the Self, this is the immortal, the fearless, this is Brahman.'

Then Indra went away satisfied in his heart. But before he had returned to the Devas, he saw this difficulty. Although it is true that that self is not blind, even if the body is blind, nor lame, if the body is lame, though it is true that that self is not rendered faulty by the faults of it (the body),

2. Nor struck when it (the body) is struck, nor lamed when it is lamed, yet it is as if they struck him (the self) in dreams, as if they chased him 1.

He becomes even conscious, as it were, of pain, and sheds tears. Therefore I see no good in this.

3. Taking fuel in his hands, he went again as a pupil to Pragâpati. Pragâpati said to him: 'Maghavat, as you went away satisfied in your heart, for what purpose did you come back?'

He said: 'Sir, although it is true that that self is not blind even if the body is blind, nor lame, if the body is lame, though it is true that that self is not rendered faulty by the faults of it (the body),

4. Nor struck when it (the body) is struck, nor lamed when it is lamed, yet it is as if they struck him (the self) in dreams, as if they chased him. He becomes even conscious, as it were, of pain, and sheds tears. Therefore I see no good in this.'

'So it is indeed, Maghavat,' replied Pragâpati; 'but I shall explain him (the true Self) further to you. Live with me another thirty-two years.'

He lived with him another thirty-two years. Then Pragâpati said:

Footnotes 138:1 I have adopted the reading vikkhâyayanti, because it is the most difficult, and therefore explains most easily the various corruptions, or it may be emendations, that have crept into the text. Saṅkara explains vikkhâdayanti by vidrâvayanti, and this shows that he too must have read vikkhâyayanti, for he could not have explained vikkhâdayanti, which means they uncover or they deprive of their clothing, by vidrâvayanti, they drive away. It is true that vikkhâyayanti may be explained in two ways; it may be the causative of khâ, to cut, but this meaning is not very appropriate here, and quite inadmissible in another passage where vikkhâyayanti occurs, whereas, if derived from vikh (ὀίχομαι) in a causative sense, Saṅkara could hardly have chosen a better explanation than vidrâvayanti, they make run away. The root vikh, vikkhâyayati is recognised in Pânini III, 1, 28, and in the Dhâtupâtha 28, 129, but it has hitherto been met with in this passage only, and in Brihadâranyaka, Up. IV, 3, 20. Here also the author speaks of a man who imagines that people kill him or do him violence, or that an elephant chases him or that he falls into a pit. Here we have hastîva vikkhâyayati, and Saṅkara, at least as printed by Dr. Roer, explains this by vikkhâpayati, vikkhâdayati, vidrâvayati; dhâvatîty arthah. Much better is Dvivedaganga's commentary, as published by Dr.

Weber, Satap. Brâhm. p. 1145, Kadâkid enam hastî vikkhâyayatîva vidrâvayatîva; vikha gatau, gupûdhûpavikhipanipanibhya âya iti (Pân. III, 1, 28) svârtha âyapratyayah. In the Dictionary of Boehtlingk and Roth the derivation from khâ, to cut, is preferred; see Nachträge, s. v. khâ.

Up next

Eighth Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: ELEVENTH KHANDA.

ELEVENTH KHANDA. 1. 'When a man being asleep, reposing, and at perfect rest 1, sees no dreams, that is the Self, this is the immortal, the fearless, this is Brahman.'

About 2 min to read

Take your library with you

Continue to the next chapter

Open the next chapter in the app. Reading is free.

Scan to open the next chapter

Every book is free to read. Downloading the app may not keep this chapter link; return here to open it after installing.

Contents

Upanishads Part I · Various

237 chapters

  1. 01PREFACE38 min
  2. 02PROGRAM OF A TRANSLATION13 min
  3. 03TRANSLITERATION OF ORIENTAL ALPHABETS.4 min
  4. 04INTRODUCTION9 min
  5. 05RAMMOHUN ROY.5 min
  6. 06POSITION OF THE UPANISHADS IN VEDIC LITERATURE.4 min
  7. 07DIFFERENT CLASSES OF UPANISHADS.6 min
  8. 08CRITICAL TREATMENT OF THE TEXT OF THE UPANISHADS.14 min
  9. 09MEANING OF THE WORD UPANISHAD.7 min
  10. 10WORKS ON THE UPANISHADS.2 min
  11. 11THE KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD.6 min
  12. 12II.4 min
  13. 13THE AITAREYA-ÂRANYAKA.11 min
  14. 14IV.3 min
  15. 15V.2 min
  16. 16KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD.5 min
  17. 17KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: SECOND KHANDA 1.5 min
  18. 18First Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: THIRD KHANDA.7 min
  19. 19First Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: FOURTH KHANDA.1 min
  20. 20First Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: FIFTH KHANDA.2 min
  21. 21First Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: SIXTH KHANDA.2 min
  22. 22First Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: SEVENTH KHANDA.2 min
  23. 23First Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: EIGHTH KHANDA.2 min
  24. 24First Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: NINTH KHANDA.1 min
  25. 25First Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: TENTH KHANDA.3 min
  26. 26First Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: ELEVENTH KHANDA.2 min
  27. 27First Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: TWELFTH KHANDA.2 min
  28. 28First Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: THIRTEENTH KHANDA 1.2 min
  29. 29SECOND PRAPÂTHAKA.1 min
  30. 30Second Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: SECOND KHANDA.1 min
  31. 31Second Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: THIRD KHANDA.1 min
  32. 32Second Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: FOURTH KHANDA.1 min
  33. 33Second Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: FIFTH KHANDA.1 min
  34. 34Second Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: SIXTH KHANDA.1 min
  35. 35Second Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: SEVENTH KHANDA.1 min
  36. 36Second Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: EIGHTH KHANDA.1 min
  37. 37Second Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: NINTH KHANDA.2 min
  38. 38Second Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: TENTH KHANDA.2 min
  39. 39KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: ELEVENTH KHANDA 3.1 min
  40. 40Second Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: TWELFTH KHANDA.1 min
  41. 41Second Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: THIRTEENTH KHANDA.1 min
  42. 42Second Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: FOURTEENTH KHANDA.1 min
  43. 43Second Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: FIFTEENTH KHANDA.1 min
  44. 44Second Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: SIXTEENTH KHANDA.1 min
  45. 45Second Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: SEVENTEENTH KHANDA.1 min
  46. 46Second Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: EIGHTEENTH KHANDA.1 min
  47. 47Second Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: NINETEENTH KHANDA.1 min
  48. 48Second Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: TWENTIETH KHANDA.1 min
  49. 49Second Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: TWENTY-FIRST KHANDA.1 min
  50. 50KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: TWENTY-SECOND KHANDA 2.3 min
  51. 51Second Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: TWENTY-THIRD KHANDA.2 min
  52. 52Second Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: TWENTY-FOURTH KHANDA.3 min
  53. 53THIRD PRAPÂTHAKA.2 min
  54. 54Third Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: SECOND KHANDA.1 min
  55. 55Third Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: THIRD KHANDA.1 min
  56. 56Third Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: FOURTH KHANDA.1 min
  57. 57Third Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: FIFTH KHANDA.1 min
  58. 58Third Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: SIXTH KHANDA.1 min
  59. 59Third Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: SEVENTH KHANDA.1 min
  60. 60Third Prapāthaka: KHÂNDOGYA-UPANISHAD: EIGHTH KHANDA.1 min