Vinaya Texts, Part III

Vinaya Texts, Part III · Various (Pāli canon)

Kullavagga, Seventh Khandhaka, Chapter 5

Translated by T.W. Rhys Davids & Hermann Oldenberg (SBE 20, 1885) · 77 of 121

5.

1. Now the venerable Upâli went up to the Blessed One, and bowed down before him, and took his seat on one side. And when he was so seated, the venerable Upâli said to the Blessed One: 'The expressions, Lord, "disunion in the Samgha," and "schism in the Samgha," are used. How much, Lord, goes to make disunion and not schism in the Samgha, and how much goes to make both disunion and schism in the Samgha?'

'If one is on one side, Upâli, and two on the other side, and a fourth makes a formal proposition, and gives them voting-tickets, saying, "This is according to the Dhamma, and according to the Vinaya, and according to the teaching of the Master. Take this (ticket) and give your sanction to this (opinion)"--then this, Upâli, is disunion in the Samgha, and not schism.

If, Upâli, two are on one side, and other two are on the other side, and a fifth . . . . (and so on up to) and an eighth tell them something (&c., as before)--then this, Upâli, is disunion in the Samgha, and not schism.

'If, Upâli, four are on one side, and other four are on the other side, and a ninth tell them (&c., as before)--then this, Upâli, is both disunion in the Samgha, and it is schism.

(A separation) of nine, Upâli, or of more than nine, is both disunion in the Samgha, and it is schism.

'A Bhikkhunî, Upâli, cannot make (one of the requisite number to cause) a schism, though she may help to produce a schism--nor a woman novice, nor a Sâmanera, male or female, nor a layman, nor a laywoman. It is only a Bhikkhu who is in full possession of all his privileges, and belongs to the same communion, and is domiciled in the same district who can make (one of the number requisite to form) a schism.'

2. 'There is the expression, Lord, "schism in the Samgha." How much, Lord, does it require to constitute a schism in the Samgha?'

'They put forth, Upâli, what is not Dhamma as Dhamma (1), or what is Dhamma as not Dhamma (2), or what is not Vinaya as Vinaya (3), or what is Vinaya as not Vinaya (4), or what has not been taught and spoken by the Tathâgata as taught and spoken by him (5), or what has been taught and spoken by the Tathâgata as not taught and spoken by him (6), or what has not been practised by the Tathâgata as practised by him (7), or what has been practised by the Tathâgata as not practised by him (8), or what has not been ordained by the Tathâgata as ordained by him (9), or what has been ordained by the Tathâgata as not ordained by him (10), or what is no offence as an offence (11), or what is an offence as no offence (12), or what is a slight offence to be a grievous offence (13), or what is a grievous offence to be a slight offence (14), or what is (a rule regarding) an offence to which there is an atonement as without atonement (15), or what is (a rule regarding) an offence to which there is no atonement as admitting of atonement (16), or what is a grave offence as not a grave offence (17), or what is not a grave offence as a grave offence (18). In these Eighteen Points they hinder and mislead (their followers), and perform independently Uposatha, and Pavâranâ, and (official) acts of the Samgha. So much, Upâli, does it require to constitute a schism in the Samgha.'

How disagreement crosses into schismMembership note · Open in the app

3. 'There is the expression, Lord, "concord in the Samgha." What, Lord, does it require to constitute concord in the Samgha?'

'They put forth, Upâli, what is not Dhamma as not Dhamma (and so on through the Eighteen Points down to the end).

4. 'To what (result of Karma), Lord, does that man give rise who brings about a schism in the Samgha when it is in concord?'

'He gives rise, Upâli, to a fault (the result of which) endures for a Kalpa, and for a Kalpa is he boiled in Niraya.'

"He who breaks up the Samgha is (doomed) to remain for a Kalpa in states of suffering and woe.

He who delights in party (strife), and adheres not to the Dhamma, is cut off from Arahatship:

Having broken up the Samgha when it was at peace he is boiled for a Kalpa in Niraya."

'To what (result of Karma), Lord, does that man give rise who brings about reconciliation in the Samgha when it has been split up?'

'He gives rise, Upâli, to the highest merit, and for a Kalpa is he happy in heaven.

"Blessed is concord in the Samgha, and the support of those who are at peace! He who delights in peace, adhering to the Dhamma, is not cut off from Arahatship: On reconciling the Samgha, when it was at strife, he is happy for a Kalpa in heaven."'

5. 'Can it be, Lord, that one who breaks up the Samgha is irretrievably (doomed) to remain for a Kalpa in states of suffering and woe?'

'Yes, Upâli, that can be.'

'Can it be, Lord, that one who breaks up the Samgha is not doomed to be reborn in states either of suffering or of woe; that he is not doomed to remain so in such states for a Kalpa; and that he (his position) is not irretrievable?'

'Yes, Upâli, that can be.'

'Who then, Lord, [comes under the first head?]'

'In case, Upâli, a Bhikkhu gives out what is not Dhamma as Dhamma, directing his opinion and his approval and his pleasure and his intention (to what he says and does); and in belief that the doctrine (he propounds) is against the Dhamma, and that the schism resulting therefrom would be against the Dhamma; and makes publication thereof, giving out tickets, and saying, "Take this (voting-ticket): approve this (opinion) . This is Dhamma; this is Vinaya; this is the teaching of the Master,"--a man, Upâli, who thus divides the Samgha, is irretrievably doomed to remain for a K al pa in states of suffering and woe.'

[The above paragraph is then repeated in full, reading successively for 'in belief that the doctrine (he propounds) is against the Dhamma, and the schism resulting therefrom would be against the Dhamma,' each of the following clauses:--

(b) . . . in belief that the doctrine is against the Dhamma, but that the schism resulting therefrom would be in accordance with the Dhamma . . .

(c) . . . in belief that the doctrine is against the Dhamma, but in uncertainty whether the schism resulting therefrom would be against the Dhamma or not . . .

(d) . . . in belief that the doctrine is in accordance with the Dhamma, but that the schism resulting therefrom would be against the Dhamma . . .

(e) . . . in belief that the doctrine is in accordance with the Dhamma, but in uncertainty whether the schism resulting therefrom would be against the Dhamma or not . . .

(f) . . . in uncertainty whether the doctrine is against the Dhamma or not, but in the belief that the schism resulting therefrom would be against the Dhamma . . .

(g) . . . in uncertainty whether the doctrine is against the Dhamma or not, and in the belief that the schism resulting therefrom would be against the Dhamma . . .

(h) . . . in uncertainty whether the doctrine would be against the Dhamma, and in uncertainty whether the schism resulting therefrom would be against the Dhamma or not . . .]

[The whole paragraph is then again repeated, reading successively for 'gives out that which is not Dhamma as Dhamma' each of the Eighteen Points given in full in VII, 5, 2.]

6. 'Who then, Lord, is one who breaks up the Samgha, and yet is not doomed to be reborn in states either of suffering or of woe; is not doomed to remain in such states for a Kalpa; and is not so doomed that his position is irretrievable?'

'In case, Upâli, a Bhikkhu gives out what is not Dhamma as Dhamma [and so on successively through the whole Eighteen Points] without directing his opinion and his approval and his pleasure and his intention thereto, and in the belief that the doctrine he propounds is in accordance with the Dhamma, and that the schism resulting therefrom would be so too.'

Here ends the Third Portion for Recitation.

=====================

Here ends the Seventh Khandhaka, on Divisions in the Samgha.

Footnotes

265:1 Samgha-râgi and samgha-bhedo. See Mahâvagga X. 1, 6, where other expressions, not here referred to, are also used.

266:1 That is, stated shortly, it requires the breaking up of a body of at the least nine Bhikkhus to make a schism.

266:2 Pakatatto samâna-samvâsako samâna-sîmâya thito. On the two last of these expressions, see our notes on Mahâvagga IX, 4, 8. The first is there wrongly rendered, and should be translated as it is here; see the frequent passages in which the word occurs (eg. Kullavagga I, 5, 1; I, 6, 1; I, 27, 1; II, 1, &c., where we have rendered it shortly 'a regular Bhikkhu').

266:3 The first ten of the following list recur word for word in the Aṅguttara Nikâya I, 11, 1-20 (Adhammâdi-vagga), and the whole eighteen above in the Mahâvagga X, 5, 4, 5.

267:1 Both the exact Pâli form and the interpretation of these terms are uncertain. Buddhaghosa's notes will be found at of H.O.'s edition of the text, and most probably we should there read parisam in both cases.

267:2 On the whole of the following section, compare above, VII, 3, 16, where much of the phraseology recurs.

268:1 On this line see our note above on VII; 4, 7.

269:1 Vinidhâya ditthim, vinidhâya khantim, vinidhâya rukim, vinidhâya bhâvam. These expressions all recur in the Sutta-vibhaṅga, Pâkittiya I, 2, 2 and following sections, where the question at issue is whether an erroneous statement is, or is not, a conscious lie. The meaning of the whole is clear, though each of the words is used in a rather uncommon sense. On khanti, compare ditthe sute khantim akubbamâno (of the Arahat) at Sutta Nipâta IV, 13, 3, and the standing use of the verb khamati, at the end of the Kammavâkâs.

269:2 Bhede adhamma-ditthi; literally, 'in the schism (there will be) doctrine that is against the Dhamma.'

269:3 Anussâveti, which is here equivalent to the technical 'publication' required in the English law of libel and slander.

269:4 See the note above on VII, 4, 1.

271:1 The sum of the last two sections seems to come to this, that practically such a schism as would have the awful effects set out above in § 4 would be impossible in Buddhism. For not only is a formal putting forward and voting on the false doctrine essential to schism as distinct from mere disagreement, but the offending Bhikkhu must also be quite aware that the doctrine so put forth is wrong, or at least doubtful, and also that the schism resulting from his action will be, or will probably be, disastrous to the Dhamma. In other words, the schism must be brought about by deliberately putting forward a doctrine known to be false, or at least doubtful, or with the express intention or hope of thereby injuring the cause of the Dhamma (that is, of the Truth).

Up next

Kullavagga, Eighth Khandhaka, Chapter 1

1. Now at that time the Blessed One was staying at Sâvatthi, in Anâtha Pindika's Ârâma.

About 13 min to read

Take your library with you

Continue to the next chapter

Open the next chapter in the app. Reading is free.

Scan to open the next chapter

Every book is free to read. Downloading the app may not keep this chapter link; return here to open it after installing.

Contents

Vinaya Texts, Part III · Various (Pāli canon)

121 chapters

  1. 01Kullavagga, Fourth Khandhaka, Chapter 11 min
  2. 02Kullavagga, Fourth Khandhaka, Chapter 22 min
  3. 03Kullavagga, Fourth Khandhaka, Chapter 31 min
  4. 04Kullavagga, Fourth Khandhaka, Chapter 418 min
  5. 05Kullavagga, Fourth Khandhaka, Chapter 52 min
  6. 06Kullavagga, Fourth Khandhaka, Chapter 63 min
  7. 07Kullavagga, Fourth Khandhaka, Chapter 71 min
  8. 08Kullavagga, Fourth Khandhaka, Chapter 82 min
  9. 09Kullavagga, Fourth Khandhaka, Chapter 92 min
  10. 10Kullavagga, Fourth Khandhaka, Chapter 102 min
  11. 11Kullavagga, Fourth Khandhaka, Chapter 113 min
  12. 12Kullavagga, Fourth Khandhaka, Chapter 122 min
  13. 13Kullavagga, Fourth Khandhaka, Chapter 135 min
  14. 14Kullavagga, Fourth Khandhaka, Chapter 1439 min
  15. 15Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 14 min
  16. 16Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 24 min
  17. 17Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 32 min
  18. 18Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 41 min
  19. 19Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 53 min
  20. 20Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 63 min
  21. 21Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 71 min
  22. 22Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 85 min
  23. 23Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 910 min
  24. 24Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 102 min
  25. 25Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 1111 min
  26. 26Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 122 min
  27. 27Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 134 min
  28. 28Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 1411 min
  29. 29Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 151 min
  30. 30Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 164 min
  31. 31Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 172 min
  32. 32Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 181 min
  33. 33Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 192 min
  34. 34Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 2010 min
  35. 35Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 217 min
  36. 36Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 222 min
  37. 37Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 234 min
  38. 38Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 242 min
  39. 39Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 251 min
  40. 40Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 261 min
  41. 41Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 275 min
  42. 42Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 283 min
  43. 43Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 296 min
  44. 44Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 301 min
  45. 45Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 312 min
  46. 46Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 322 min
  47. 47Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 335 min
  48. 48Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 341 min
  49. 49Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 351 min
  50. 50Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 361 min
  51. 51Kullavagga, Fifth Khandhaka, Chapter 372 min
  52. 52Kullavagga, Sixth Khandhaka, Chapter 14 min
  53. 53Kullavagga, Sixth Khandhaka, Chapter 212 min
  54. 54Kullavagga, Sixth Khandhaka, Chapter 312 min
  55. 55Kullavagga, Sixth Khandhaka, Chapter 413 min
  56. 56Kullavagga, Sixth Khandhaka, Chapter 53 min
  57. 57Kullavagga, Sixth Khandhaka, Chapter 66 min
  58. 58Kullavagga, Sixth Khandhaka, Chapter 71 min
  59. 59Kullavagga, Sixth Khandhaka, Chapter 81 min
  60. 60Kullavagga, Sixth Khandhaka, Chapter 91 min