Buddhism in Translations

Buddhism in Translations · Henry Clarke Warren

II. Sentient Existence: Attachment

Translated by Henry Clarke Warren · 39 of 111

§ 34. ATTACHMENT.

§ 34 a.--Translated from the Visuddhi-Magga (chap. xiv.).

In looking upon Form and the other Groups as having a nature resembling bubbles of foam and the like, the meditative priest ceases to look upon the unsubstantial as substantiality. To particularize:--

In looking upon subjective Form as impure, he comes thoroughly to understand material food, abandons the perverse mistaking of the impure for the pure, crosses the torrent of sensual pleasure, breaks loose from the yoke of sensual pleasure, is freed from the depravity of sensual pleasure,

[Vis.xiv] severs the myriad bonds of covetousness, and does not attach himself by the Attachment of Sensual Pleasure;

In looking upon Sensation as misery, he comes thoroughly to understand the nutriment called contact, abandons the perverse mistaking of misery for happiness, crosses the torrent of existence, breaks loose from the yoke of existence, is freed from the depravity of passion for existence, severs the myriad bonds of malevolence, and does not attach himself by the Attachment of Fanatical Conduct;

In looking upon Perception and the Predispositions as not an Ego, he comes thoroughly to understand the nutriment called karma, abandons the perverse mistaking of what is no Ego for an Ego, crosses the torrent of heresy, breaks loose from the yoke of heresy, is freed from the depravity of heresy, severs the myriad bonds of dogmatism, and does not attach himself by the Attachment of the Assertion of an Ego;

In looking upon Consciousness as transitory, he comes thoroughly to understand the nutriment called consciousness, abandons the perverse mistaking of the transitory for the permanent, crosses the torrent of ignorance, breaks loose from the yoke of ignorance, is freed from the depravity of ignorance, severs the myriad bonds of an affectation of fanatical conduct, and does not attach himself by the Attachment of Heresy.

§ 34 b.--Translated from the Visuddhi-Magga (chap. xvii.).

In the proposition, On desire depends attachment,

Attachments are in number four: Whose definition various, Their short description, and their long, And sequence must one seek to show.

The following is the showing:--

The following are the four attachments; the attachment of sensual pleasure, the attachment of heresy, the attachment of fanatical conduct, the attachment of the assertion of an Ego.

Four things a person clings toMembership note · Open in the app

[Vis.xvii]

The following is the definition various.

The attachment of sensual pleasure is attachment with some form of sensual pleasure as its object. Or, again, it is the attachment of sensual pleasure because it is at the same time attachment and sensual pleasure. The word attachment1 means a tenacious grasp. The syllables u-pa strengthen the word, just as in upâyâsa, upakkuttha, etc.

In like manner the attachment of heresy is heresy and attachment; or it is attachment to some form of heresy, whether concerning the past or the future, as when one says, "The Ego and the world are persistent," etc.

In like manner the attachment of fanatical conduct is attachment to some mode of fanatical conduct; or it is attachment and fanatical conduct. Cattle-conduct, cattle-behavior, and the like are attachments because they involve the belief that thus purity can be obtained.

In like manner assertion is what people assert; attachment is that by which they attach themselves. What do they assert? and to what do they attach themselves? The Ego. The attachment of the assertion of an Ego is the attachment to the assertion of an Ego, or it is the simple assertion of an Ego. The attachment of the assertion of an Ego is when people attach themselves by the assertion of an Ego.

The above, then, is the definition various.

Their short description, and their long.

First in regard to the attachment of sensual pleasure.

"What is the attachment of sensual pleasure? Sensual craving, sensual passion, sensual delight, sensual desire, sensual affection, sensual torment, sensual infatuation, sensual cleaving, this is called the attachment of sensual pleasure." In short, in this quotation, attachment is described as tenacity of desire. Tenacious desire is when an earlier desire has become tenacious by the proximate dependence. Some, however, say, "Desire is the quest of an object before it is obtained, as when a robber gropes about in the dark; attachment is the seizing hold of an object within reach, as when the robber gets

[Vis.xvii] hold of his booty. And both are inimical to moderation and contentment and are the roots out of which grow seeking and guarding.

The short description of the other three attachments is that they are heresy.

In their long description, however, the attachment of sensual pleasure is tenacity of the aforesaid one-hundred-and-eight-fold desire for forms and other objects of sense.

The attachment of heresy consists of heretical views regarding ten different subjects.

"What is the attachment of heresy? 'There is no such thing as a gift, a sacrifice, an offering, a fruition or result of good or evil deeds, a present life, a future life, a mother, a father, apparitional existence, or any monk or Brahman having found the right road and correct line of conduct who can proclaim of his own knowledge and perception either this world or the next!' any such heresy, heretical belief, heretical jungle, heretical wilderness, heretical puppet-show, heretical writhing, heretical fetter, figment, notion, persuasion, affectation, byway, false way, falsity, schismatic doctrine, or error is called the attachment of heresy."

The heresy that denied any afterlifeMembership note · Open in the app

The heresy of fanatical conduct is the affectation of the belief that purity is by fanatical conduct. As it is said:

"What is the attachment of fanatical conduct? Purity is by conduct; purity is by fanaticism; purity is by fanatical conduct,--any such heresy, heretical belief, heretical jungle, heretical wilderness, heretical puppet-show, heretical writhing, heretical fetter, figment, notion, persuasion, affectation, byway, false way, falsity, schismatic doctrine, or error is called the attachment of fanatical conduct."

The attachment of the assertion of an Ego is the twenty-fold heresy of individuality. As it is said:

"What is the heresy of the assertion of an Ego? Here an ignorant, unconverted man, who is not a follower of noble disciples, not conversant with the Noble Doctrine, not disciplined in the Noble Doctrine, not a follower of good people, not conversant with the doctrine held by good people, not disciplined in the doctrine of good people, considers form in

[Vis.xvii] the light of an Ego--either the Ego as possessing form, or form as comprised in the Ego, or the Ego as comprised in form; considers sensation . . . perception . . . the predispositions . . . consciousness as the Ego, or the Ego as possessing consciousness, or consciousness as comprised in the Ego, or the Ego as comprised in consciousness,--any such heresy, heretical belief, heretical jungle, heretical wilderness, heretical puppet-show, heretical writhing, heretical fetter, figment, notion, persuasion, affectation, byway, false way, falsity, schismatic doctrine, or error is called the attachment of the assertion of the Ego."1

The above is their short description, and their long.

And sequence:--That sequence is threefold; sequence in originating, sequence in abandoning, sequence in teaching.

Now, as the round of rebirth is without known beginning and it is impossible to say which corruption first arises, no absolute order of sequence can be laid down; but in any particular existence the order most commonly followed is for the heresy of the assertion of an Ego to come first and be followed by a heretical belief either in the persistence of existences or in their annihilation. Then he who believes that the Ego is persistent adopts the attachment of the heresy of fanatical conduct to purify his Ego, and he who believes that the Ego is annihilated, being reckless of a future life, adopts the attachment of sensual pleasure. Thus the sequence of originating in any particular existence is for the attachment of the heresy of the assertion of an Ego to come first, and after it the attachments of heresy, fanatical conduct, and sensual pleasure.

The attachment of heresy, the attachment of fanatical conduct, and the attachment of the assertion of an Ego are first abandoned, as they are destroyed by the Path of Conversion; the attachment of sensual pleasure afterwards by the Path of Arhatship. This is the sequence in abandonment.

The attachment of sensual pleasure is first taught both on account of its extent and of its conspicuousness. For as it

[Vis.xvii] occurs in conjunction with eight of the consciousnesses it has a large extent; the others have but little, being conjoined with only four. And as mankind is for the most part given over to its lusts, the attachment of sensual pleasure is conspicuous; not so the others. Or, the attachment of sensual pleasure is for the purpose of obtaining objects of lust, and the attachment of heresy in the form of belief in the persistence of the Ego comes next as being more a question of speculative curiosity and the like. This has two divisions, the attachment of fanatical conduct, and the attachment of the assertion of an Ego. Of these two, the attachment of fanatical conduct is first taught from its grossness as one can see cattle-practices and dog-practices with one's own eyes; the attachment of the assertion of an Ego comes last on account of its subtileness. This is the sequence in teaching.

Footnotes

1 In Pâli upâdâna, i.e. upa + âdâna.

1 See Dhammasangani, §§ 1214 to 1217.

Up next

II. Sentient Existence: Existence

The sense, the different elements, The use, divisions, summings up, And which the dependence makes of which, Must now be understood in full.

About 11 min to read

Take your library with you

Listen to this chapter

Opens this chapter in the app. Tap Listen to begin. Narration requires membership.

Scan to open this chapter
Continue to the next chapter

Open the next chapter in the app. Reading is free.

Scan to open the next chapter

Every book is free to read. Downloading the app may not keep this chapter link; return here to open it after installing.

Contents

Buddhism in Translations · Henry Clarke Warren

111 chapters

  1. 01Abbreviations2 min
  2. 02The Three Characteristics1 min
  3. 03General Introduction7 min
  4. 04I. The Buddha: Introductory Discourse5 min
  5. 05I. The Buddha: The Story of Sumedha31 min
  6. 06I. The Buddha: A List of former Buddhas1 min
  7. 07I. The Buddha: The Characteristics of a Future Buddha7 min
  8. 08I. The Buddha: The Birth of the Buddha16 min
  9. 09I. The Buddha: The young Gotamid Prince12 min
  10. 10I. The Buddha: The Great Retirement18 min
  11. 11I. The Buddha: The Great Struggle6 min
  12. 12I. The Buddha: The Attainment of Buddhaship19 min
  13. 13I. The Buddha: First Events after the Attainment of Buddhaship5 min
  14. 14I. The Buddha: The Conversion of Sâriputta and Moggallâna6 min
  15. 15I. The Buddha: The Buddha's daily Habits7 min
  16. 16I. The Buddha: The Death of the Buddha24 min
  17. 17II. Sentient Existence: Introductory Discourse9 min
  18. 18II. Sentient Existence: Questions which tend not to Edification19 min
  19. 19II. Sentient Existence: King Milinda and Nâgasena come to an Understanding1 min
  20. 20II. Sentient Existence: There is no Ego25 min
  21. 21II. Sentient Existence: All Signs of an Ego are Absent3 min
  22. 22II. Sentient Existence: No continuous Personal Identity4 min
  23. 23II. Sentient Existence: The Mind less permanent than the Body4 min
  24. 24II. Sentient Existence: What is Unity or One?4 min
  25. 25II. Sentient Existence: Analyis of the Human Being4 min
  26. 26II. Sentient Existence: The Composition of the Body2 min
  27. 27II. Sentient Existence: On getting Angry1 min
  28. 28II. Sentient Existence: The Origin and Cessation of the Human Being7 min
  29. 29II. Sentient Existence: Inanimate Nature2 min
  30. 30II. Sentient Existence: The Middle Doctrine7 min
  31. 31II. Sentient Existence: Ignorance14 min
  32. 32II. Sentient Existence: Karma4 min
  33. 33II. Sentient Existence: Consciousness4 min
  34. 34II. Sentient Existence: Name and Form3 min
  35. 35II. Sentient Existence: The Six Organs of Sense1 min
  36. 36II. Sentient Existence: Contact1 min
  37. 37II. Sentient Existence: Sensation1 min
  38. 38II. Sentient Existence: Desire3 min
  39. 39II. Sentient Existence: Attachment7 min left
  40. 40II. Sentient Existence: Existence11 min
  41. 41II. Sentient Existence: Birth etc.2 min
  42. 42II. Sentient Existence: Discussion of Dependent Origination8 min
  43. 43III. Karma and Rebirth: Introductory Discourse6 min
  44. 44III. Karma and Rebirth: Be a Friend to Yourself3 min
  45. 45III. Karma and Rebirth: The cause of Inequality in the World1 min
  46. 46III. Karma and Rebirth: Fruitful and barren Karma9 min
  47. 47III. Karma and Rebirth: The Death of Moggallâna7 min
  48. 48III. Karma and Rebirth: Good and bad Karma3 min
  49. 49III. Karma and Rebirth: How to obtain Wealth, Beauty, and Social Position6 min
  50. 50III. Karma and Rebirth: The Round of Existence1 min
  51. 51III. Karma and Rebirth: Cause of Rebirth1 min
  52. 52III. Karma and Rebirth: Is this to be my Last Existence?1 min
  53. 53III. Karma and Rebirth: Rebirth is not Transmigration12 min
  54. 54III. Karma and Rebirth: Reflections on Existence14 min
  55. 55III. Karma and Rebirth: Different kinds of Death2 min
  56. 56III. Karma and Rebirth: How Existence in Hell is Possible3 min
  57. 57III. Karma and Rebirth: Death's Messengers10 min
  58. 58III. Karma and Rebirth: The Ass in the Lion's Skin2 min
  59. 59III. Karma and Rebirth: The devoted Wife5 min
  60. 60III. Karma and Rebirth: Friendship3 min