Buddhism in Translations

Buddhism in Translations · Henry Clarke Warren

V. The Order: The Value of Training in Religion

Translated by Henry Clarke Warren · 95 of 111

§ 87. THE VALUE OF TRAINING IN RELIGION.

Translated from the Milindapañha (26429).

"Bhante Nâgasena, you priests say, 'If a layman reach saintship, there are two courses open to him, and none other: on the self-same day he either retires from the world or passes into Nirvana; he cannot wait until the morrow.' Now if, bhante Nâgasena, he should not succeed in obtaining either professor or preceptor, or bowl and robes on that day, would that man who had reached saintship retire from the world without any assistance? or would he wait until another day? or would some other saint come by magical power and receive him into the Order? or would he pass into Nirvana?"

"Your majesty, this layman who had attained to saintship, would not retire from the world without assistance, or if he did so, he would be guilty of theft, nor could he wait for another day; and whether anyone who had attained to saintship came or not, he would pass into Nirvana that self-same day."

"In that case, bhante Nâgasena, saintship has forfeited all claim to be a quiet haven, if it slaughters its possessor."

"Your majesty, inferiority is characteristic of a layman; and it is through this characteristic inferiority and weakness that a householder, when he has attained to saintship, on the self-same day either retires from the world or passes into Nirvana; and this weakness, your majesty, is not a fault of saintship, it is a fault belonging to the lay state. Just as food, your majesty, sustains the vital force, and preserves the life of all beings, but kills, through its indigestibility, anyone who has a poor stomach and a slow and weak digestion, yet this weakness of digestion is not the fault of the food, but the fault of the stomach; in exactly the same way, your majesty, it is through his characteristic weakness and inferiority that a householder, when he has attained to saintship, on the self-same day either retires from the world or passes into Nirvana; and this characteristic weakness, your majesty, is not a fault

[Mil.26522]

of saintship, it is a fault belonging to the lay state. Or, again, your majesty, as a small stalk of grass will break and double over if a heavy stone be placed upon it; in exactly the same way, your majesty, a layman who has attained to saintship, cannot, so long as he remains a layman, sustain saintship, but on the self-same day he either retires from the world or passes into Nirvana. Or, again, your majesty, just as a man who is weak, feeble, of low extraction, and of few meritorious works, if he succeeds to a large kingdom, falls at once, perishes, and breaks down, and proves unable to sustain princely power; in exactly the same way, your majesty, a layman who has attained to saintship, cannot, so long as he stays a layman, sustain saintship. For this reason, then, on the self-same day he either retires from the world or passes into Nirvana."

"Well done, bhante Nâgasena! Thus it is, and you have my assent."

Up next

V. The Order: The colorless Life

Said the king, "Bhante Nâgasena, what is the difference between one who has passion and one who is free from passion?"

About 1 min to read

Take your library with you

Listen to this chapter

Opens this chapter in the app. Tap Listen to begin. Narration requires membership.

Scan to open this chapter
Continue to the next chapter

Open the next chapter in the app. Reading is free.

Scan to open the next chapter

Every book is free to read. Downloading the app may not keep this chapter link; return here to open it after installing.

Contents

Buddhism in Translations · Henry Clarke Warren

111 chapters

  1. 01Abbreviations2 min
  2. 02The Three Characteristics1 min
  3. 03General Introduction7 min
  4. 04I. The Buddha: Introductory Discourse5 min
  5. 05I. The Buddha: The Story of Sumedha31 min
  6. 06I. The Buddha: A List of former Buddhas1 min
  7. 07I. The Buddha: The Characteristics of a Future Buddha7 min
  8. 08I. The Buddha: The Birth of the Buddha16 min
  9. 09I. The Buddha: The young Gotamid Prince12 min
  10. 10I. The Buddha: The Great Retirement18 min
  11. 11I. The Buddha: The Great Struggle6 min
  12. 12I. The Buddha: The Attainment of Buddhaship19 min
  13. 13I. The Buddha: First Events after the Attainment of Buddhaship5 min
  14. 14I. The Buddha: The Conversion of Sâriputta and Moggallâna6 min
  15. 15I. The Buddha: The Buddha's daily Habits7 min
  16. 16I. The Buddha: The Death of the Buddha24 min
  17. 17II. Sentient Existence: Introductory Discourse9 min
  18. 18II. Sentient Existence: Questions which tend not to Edification19 min
  19. 19II. Sentient Existence: King Milinda and Nâgasena come to an Understanding1 min
  20. 20II. Sentient Existence: There is no Ego25 min
  21. 21II. Sentient Existence: All Signs of an Ego are Absent3 min
  22. 22II. Sentient Existence: No continuous Personal Identity4 min
  23. 23II. Sentient Existence: The Mind less permanent than the Body4 min
  24. 24II. Sentient Existence: What is Unity or One?4 min
  25. 25II. Sentient Existence: Analyis of the Human Being4 min
  26. 26II. Sentient Existence: The Composition of the Body2 min
  27. 27II. Sentient Existence: On getting Angry1 min
  28. 28II. Sentient Existence: The Origin and Cessation of the Human Being7 min
  29. 29II. Sentient Existence: Inanimate Nature2 min
  30. 30II. Sentient Existence: The Middle Doctrine7 min
  31. 31II. Sentient Existence: Ignorance14 min
  32. 32II. Sentient Existence: Karma4 min
  33. 33II. Sentient Existence: Consciousness4 min
  34. 34II. Sentient Existence: Name and Form3 min
  35. 35II. Sentient Existence: The Six Organs of Sense1 min
  36. 36II. Sentient Existence: Contact1 min
  37. 37II. Sentient Existence: Sensation1 min
  38. 38II. Sentient Existence: Desire3 min
  39. 39II. Sentient Existence: Attachment7 min
  40. 40II. Sentient Existence: Existence11 min
  41. 41II. Sentient Existence: Birth etc.2 min
  42. 42II. Sentient Existence: Discussion of Dependent Origination8 min
  43. 43III. Karma and Rebirth: Introductory Discourse6 min
  44. 44III. Karma and Rebirth: Be a Friend to Yourself3 min
  45. 45III. Karma and Rebirth: The cause of Inequality in the World1 min
  46. 46III. Karma and Rebirth: Fruitful and barren Karma9 min
  47. 47III. Karma and Rebirth: The Death of Moggallâna7 min
  48. 48III. Karma and Rebirth: Good and bad Karma3 min
  49. 49III. Karma and Rebirth: How to obtain Wealth, Beauty, and Social Position6 min
  50. 50III. Karma and Rebirth: The Round of Existence1 min
  51. 51III. Karma and Rebirth: Cause of Rebirth1 min
  52. 52III. Karma and Rebirth: Is this to be my Last Existence?1 min
  53. 53III. Karma and Rebirth: Rebirth is not Transmigration12 min
  54. 54III. Karma and Rebirth: Reflections on Existence14 min
  55. 55III. Karma and Rebirth: Different kinds of Death2 min
  56. 56III. Karma and Rebirth: How Existence in Hell is Possible3 min
  57. 57III. Karma and Rebirth: Death's Messengers10 min
  58. 58III. Karma and Rebirth: The Ass in the Lion's Skin2 min
  59. 59III. Karma and Rebirth: The devoted Wife5 min
  60. 60III. Karma and Rebirth: Friendship3 min