Discourses of Epictetus

Discourses of Epictetus · Epictetus

Book III, Chapter XXIII: To Those Who Read and Discourse for Display

Translated by P.E. Matheson (1916) · 82 of 102

CHAPTER XXIII TO THOSE WHO READ AND DISCOURSE FOR DISPLAY First say to yourself, what manner of man you want to be; when you have settled this, act upon it in all you do; for in pretty nearly all pursuits we see that done. Athletes first decide what they want to be, and then they act accordingly. If a man is to be a long-distance runner, he takes the diet, the walking, the rubbing, and the gymnastic suited to that; if he is going in for the short course, he alters all this to suit his aim, if for the pentathlon he alters his training still more. You will find the same done in the arts. If you are a carpenter you will have this kind of work; if a smith, you will have that kind. For in everything we do, if we have no standard to go by, we shall do it ineffectively; if we use the wrong standard, we shall fail completely.

Now we have two standards to go by, one general and one special. The first is that we must act as human beings. What does this include? We must not act like a sheep, at random, nor like a brute, destructively. The special standard is relative to each man's occupation and purpose. The lyre-player must act as a lyre-player, the carpenter as a carpenter, the philosopher as a philosopher, the orator as an orator. When therefore you say, 'Come and hear me lecturing to you', see to it first that you are not acting without aim. Then if you find you have a standard, see to it that it is the right one.

Do you wish to do men good or to receive compliments?

What remains after the credit is goneMembership note · Open in the app

At once you have the answer, 'What account do I take of the praise of the multitude?'

An excellent answer. Nor does the musician heed the multitude, so far as he is a true musician, nor the geometrician. Do you wish then to do good? What are you aiming at? Tell us, that we too may run to your lecture-room. Now can any one do good to others unless he has received good himself? No, no more than the man who is no carpenter can help others in carpentry, or he who is no shoemaker in shoemaking.

Would you really know then whether you have received any good? Produce your judgements, my philosopher. What does the will to get profess? Success in getting. And the will to avoid? Escape from what it avoids. Well, do we fulfil their profession? Tell me the truth, and if you lie, I will tell you myself. When lately your audience were slack in their attendance, and did not applaud you, you went away in low spirits. Again when you were lately praised you went round and said to every one, 'What did you think of me?'

'I thought you wonderful, master, as I live.'

'How did I give that passage?'

'Which do you mean?'

'Where I described Pan and the Nymphs.'

'Superlatively.'

And yet you tell me that in respect to that will to get and will to avoid you behave in a natural way. Go to, get some one else to believe you! Did you not lately praise So-and-so against your real opinion? Did you not flatter So-and-so, the senator's son? Did you want your children to be like that?

'Heaven forbid!'

Why then did you praise him and pay him attention?

'He is a young man of parts, and ready to listen to arguments.'

How do you know that?

'He admires me.'

Now you have stated the true reason. After all, what do you think? Do not these very admirers secretly despise you? When a man who is conscious of no good action or good thought meets a philosopher who says, 'Here is a genius, frank and unspoilt', do not you think he is bound to say to himself, 'This man wants something from me'? Tell me, what sign of genius has he displayed? Why, he has been with you all this long time, he has heard you discoursing, he has heard you lecturing. Has he grown modest? Has he returned to himself? Has he realized what misery he is in? Has he cast away his vanity? Is he looking for some one to teach him?

'He is.'

Some one to teach him how he should live? No, you fool, but how he should speak, for that is what he admires you for. Listen and hear what he says: 'This man is a perfect artist in style, his style is much finer than Dio's.' That's a different thing altogether. Does he say, 'This man has self-respect, he is trustworthy and tranquil-minded'? If he did say so, I should say, 'Since he is trustworthy, tell me what you mean by this "trustworthy" man', and if he could not answer I should add, 'First learn what your words mean, and then speak.'

If you are in this sorry state, gaping for men to praise you, and counting your audience, do you really want to do others good?

'To-day I had a much larger audience.'

'Yes, it was a large one.'

'I suppose five hundred.'

'Nonsense! put them at a thousand.'

'Dio never had so large an audience.'

'How is that?'

'Why, they have a fine turn for understanding arguments.'

'Noble teaching, master, can move even a stone.'

There you have the words of a philosopher! These are the feelings of one who is to benefit mankind, there you have a man who has listened to reason, who has read the teaching of Socrates in the spirit of Socrates, and not as so much Lysias or Isocrates! '"I have often wondered by what arguments"—no, "by what argument"—the singular is smoother than the plural.' 3-16 Did you ever read the words except as one reads paltry songs? If you had read them properly you would not have dwelt on these points of language, but would rather have studied the passage, 'Anytus and Meletus can kill me, but they cannot harm me', and this, 'My nature is such that I cannot attend to my affairs, but only to the argument which appears best to me when I reflect.' That was why no one ever heard Socrates say, 'I know and teach'; no, he sent one man here, another there; and therefore they used to come to him, asking to be introduced by him to philosophers, and he took and introduced them. No, of course, as he went with them he would say, 'Come and hear me discourse to-day in the house of Quadratus'!

What am I to hear from you? Do you want to display to me your fine composition? Man, you compose well enough, and what good does it do you?

'Do praise me, I beg.'

What do you mean by praise?

'Say "Bravo!" to me, or "Marvellous!"'

Very well, I say it; but if praise is what philosophers put in the category of the good, what praise can I give you? If correct speaking is a good thing, teach me that, and I will praise you.

'What? are you bound to dislike listening to fine oratory?'

Heaven forbid! I do not dislike listening to a harp-player, but am I therefore bound to stand and play the harp? Hear what Socrates says,

'It would not be seemly for me, sir, at this time of life, to come before you like a youth framing fine phrases.' [Plato, Apology, 17c] 'Like a youth', he says. Yes, it is indeed a pretty art, to select fine phrases and put them together, and then come forward and read them or recite them with ability, and as one reads to add, 'There are not many that can understand what I say, as sure as you hope to live.'

Does the philosopher invite men to a lecture? Does he not draw to him those who are going to get good from him, as the sun draws sustenance to itself? No physician worth the name invites men to come and be healed by him, though I hear that in Rome to-day physicians do invite them; in my day physicians were called in by their patients.

'I bid you to come and hear that you are in a bad way, that you attend to everything rather than what you should attend to, and that you do not know what is good and what is evil, and are unhappy and miserable.'

A fine invitation!

Surely, unless the philosopher's words force home this lesson, they are dead and so is he. Rufus was wont to say, 'If you find leisure to praise me, my words are spoken in vain.' Wherefore he spoke in such fashion that each of us as he sat there thought he was himself accused: such was his grip of men's doings, so vividly did he set each man's ills before his eyes. The philosopher's school, sirs, is a physician's consulting-room. You must leave it in pain, not in pleasure; for you come to it in disorder, one with a shoulder put out, another with an ulcer, another with fistula, another with headache. And then you would have me sit there and utter fine little thoughts and phrases, that you may leave me with praise on your lips, and carrying away, one his shoulder, one his head, one his ulcer, one his fistula, exactly in the state he brought them to me. Is it for this you say that young men are to go abroad and leave their parents and friends and kinsmen and property, that they may say, 'Ye gods!' to you when you deliver your phrases? Was this what Socrates did, or Zeno, or Cleanthes?

You ask, 'Is there not the hortatory style?'

Yes—no one denies it—just as there is the style for proof and the style for teaching. Who has ever named a fourth style along with them, the ostentatious? What is the hortatory style? The power of showing to one and to many what a sordid struggle they are plunged in, and how they pay regard to everything rather than to what they want. For they want what tends to happiness, but they seek it in the wrong place. Is it for this that you must set up a thousand benches and invite men to come and hear you, and then mount the rostrum in a fine robe or an elegant cloak and describe the death of Achilles? Cease, by all your gods, to dishonour noble words and subjects, so far as in you lies.

Nothing is more effective in exhortation than when the speaker makes plain to his hearers that he has need of them. Tell me, in all your readings or discourses, did you ever make one of your audience anxious about himself or rouse him to a sense of his position? Did you ever send one away saying, 'The philosopher has got a good grip of me: I must act so no more'? Why, even if your fame is at its height, he only says to some one, 'A pretty description that about Xerxes!' while another puts in, 'No, the battle of Thermopylae.' Is this what a philosopher's lecture comes to?

Up next

Book III, Chapter XXIV: That We Ought Not to Spend Our Feelings on Things Beyond Our Power

CHAPTER XXIV THAT WE OUGHT NOT TO SPEND OUR FEELINGS ON THINGS BEYOND OUR POWER If a thing goes against another's nature, you must not take it as evil for you; for you are born not to share humiliation or evil fortune, but to share good fortune.

About 24 min to read

Take your library with you

Listen to this chapter

Opens this chapter in the app. Tap Listen to begin. Narration requires membership.

Scan to open this chapter
Continue to the next chapter

Open the next chapter in the app. Reading is free.

Scan to open the next chapter

Every book is free to read. Downloading the app may not keep this chapter link; return here to open it after installing.

Contents

Discourses of Epictetus · Epictetus

102 chapters

  1. 01ARRIAN'S DISCOURSES OF EPICTETUS2 min
  2. 02Book I, Chapter I: On Things in Our Power and Things Not in Our Power6 min
  3. 03Book I, Chapter II: How One May Be True to One's Character in Everything6 min
  4. 04Book I, Chapter III: What Conclusions May Be Drawn from the Fact That God Is Father of Men2 min
  5. 05Book I, Chapter IV: On Progress, or Moral Advance6 min
  6. 06Book I, Chapter V: Against Followers of the Academy2 min
  7. 07Book I, Chapter VI: On Providence7 min
  8. 08Book I, Chapter VII: On the Use of Variable Premisses and Hypothetical Arguments and the Like5 min
  9. 09Book I, Chapter VIII: That Faculties Are Fraught with Danger for the Uneducated3 min
  10. 10Book I, Chapter IX: How One May Draw Conclusions from the Fact That We Are God's Kinsmen6 min
  11. 11Book I, Chapter X: To Those Who Have Spent Their Energies on Advancement in Rome3 min
  12. 12Book I, Chapter XI: On Family Affection7 min
  13. 13Book I, Chapter XII: On Contentment6 min
  14. 14Book I, Chapter XIII: How One May Act in All Things So as to Please the Gods2 min
  15. 15Book I, Chapter XIV: That God Beholds All Men3 min
  16. 16Book I, Chapter XV: What Philosophy Professes2 min
  17. 17Book I, Chapter XVI: On Providence4 min
  18. 18Book I, Chapter XVII: That the Processes of Logic Are Necessary5 min
  19. 19Book I, Chapter XVIII: That We Should Not Be Angry at Men's Errors5 min
  20. 20Book I, Chapter XIX: How One Should Behave Towards Tyrants5 min
  21. 21Book I, Chapter XX: How Reason Has the Faculty of Taking Cognizance of Itself3 min
  22. 22Book I, Chapter XXI: To Those Who Wish to Be Admired1 min
  23. 23Book I, Chapter XXII: On Primary Conceptions4 min
  24. 24Book I, Chapter XXIII: Against Epicurus2 min
  25. 25Book I, Chapter XXIV: How One Should Contend Against Difficulties4 min
  26. 26Book I, Chapter XXV: On the Same Theme5 min
  27. 27Book I, Chapter XXVI: What Is the Law of Life4 min
  28. 28Book I, Chapter XXVII: On the Ways in Which Impressions Come to Us: and the Aids We Must Provide for Ourselves to Deal with Them4 min
  29. 29Book I, Chapter XXVIII: That We Must Not Be Angry with Men: and Concerning What Things Are Small and What Are Great Among Men6 min
  30. 30Book I, Chapter XXIX: On Constancy12 min
  31. 31Book I, Chapter XXX: What a Man Should Have Ready to Hand in the Crises of Life2 min
  32. 32Notes to Book I2 min
  33. 33Book II, Chapter I: That There Is No Conflict Between Confidence and Caution8 min
  34. 34Book II, Chapter II: On Peace of Mind5 min
  35. 35Book II, Chapter III: To Those Who Commend Persons to Philosophers2 min
  36. 36Book II, Chapter IV: To the Man Caught in Adultery3 min
  37. 37Book II, Chapter V: How a Careful Life Is Compatible with a Noble Spirit6 min
  38. 38Book II, Chapter VI: On What Is Meant by 'indifferent' Things5 min
  39. 39Book II, Chapter VII: How to Consult Diviners3 min
  40. 40Book II, Chapter VIII: What Is the True Nature of the Good6 min
  41. 41Book II, Chapter IX: That We Adopt the Profession of the Philosopher When We Cannot Fulfil That of a Man4 min
  42. 42Book II, Chapter X: How the Acts Appropriate to Man Are to Be Discovered from the Names He Bears5 min
  43. 43Book II, Chapter XI: What Is the Beginning of Philosophy4 min
  44. 44Book II, Chapter XII: On the Art of Discussion5 min
  45. 45Book II, Chapter XIII: Concerning Anxiety6 min
  46. 46Book II, Chapter XIV: On Naso6 min
  47. 47Book II, Chapter XV: On Those Who Cling Stubbornly to Their Judgements4 min
  48. 48Book II, Chapter XVI: That We Do Not Practise Applying Our Judgements About Things Good and Evil9 min
  49. 49Book II, Chapter XVII: How We Must Adjust Our Primary Conceptions to Particular Things8 min
  50. 50Book II, Chapter XVIII: How We Must Struggle Against Impressions5 min
  51. 51Book II, Chapter XIX: To Those Who Take Up the Principles of the Philosophers Only to Discuss Them7 min
  52. 52Book II, Chapter XX: Against Followers of Epicurus and of the Academy8 min
  53. 53Book II, Chapter XXI: Concerning Inconsistency of Mind5 min
  54. 54Book II, Chapter XXII: On Friendship8 min
  55. 55Book II, Chapter XXIII: On the Faculty of Expression10 min
  56. 56Book II, Chapter XXIV: To One Whom He Did Not Think Worthy6 min
  57. 57Book II, Chapter XXV: How the Art of Reasoning Is Necessary1 min
  58. 58Book II, Chapter XXVI: What Is the Distinctive Character of Error2 min
  59. 59Notes to Book II1 min
  60. 60Book III, Chapter I: On Adornment10 min