Fragments of a Faith Forgotten

Fragments of a Faith Forgotten · G.R.S. Mead

The Simonians

14 of 68

THE "SIMONIANS."

The Origin of the Name.THERE is no reason to suppose that the Gnostics whom the Church Fathers call "Simonians" would have themselves answered to the name, or have recognized the line of descent imagined for them by their opponents as founded on any basis in fact. As early as Justin Martyr (c. 150 A.D.), "Simon" assumed a prominence out of all proportion to his place in history. Evidently Justin regarded him with great detestation, and accused the Romans of worshipping him as a god, on the strength of an inscription on a statue at Rome. Justin gives the inscription as "Simoni Deo Sancto"--"To Simon, the holy God." But (alas! for the reputation of Justin's accuracy when engaged in controversy) archæology has discovered the statue--and finds it dedicated to a Sabine deity, "Semo Sancus"! Justin's assertion, however, was received without question by subsequent hæresiologists, as all such assertions were in that uncritical age.

The Statue and a Further ConjectureMembership note · Open in the app

Now it is very probable that Justin, in his innumerable controversies in defence of his particular view of Christianity, was met with some argument in which Simon was quoted as an example. It may have been that Justin argued that the miracles of Jesus proved all that Justin claimed on His behalf, and was met by the counter-argument that Simon also was a great wonder-worker, and made great claims, so that miracles did not prove Justin's contentions. Thus it may have been that Justin grew to detest the memory of Simon, and saw him and his supporters everywhere, even at Rome in a statue to a Sabine godling.

It may well have been that some wonder-worker called Simon may have astonished people in Samaria with his psychological tricks, and that stories were still in Justin's time told of him among the people. But what did most to stereotype the legend that Simon was the first heretic, was the insertion of his name in one of the stories included in the subsequently canonical Acts of the Apostles. This took place later than Justin, and so we have the first moments in the evolution of the legend of the origin of heresy (and therefore, according to the Fathers, of Gnosticism). What then is told us about "Simon" and the "Simonians," is only of interest for a recovery of some of the ideas which the subsequently Catholic party was striving to controvert; it has no value as history.

Up next

Dositheus

About 3 min to read

Take your library with you

Continue to the next chapter

Open the next chapter in the app. Reading is free.

Scan to open the next chapter

Every book is free to read. Downloading the app may not keep this chapter link; return here to open it after installing.

Contents

Fragments of a Faith Forgotten · G.R.S. Mead

68 chapters

  1. 01Prolegomena31 min
  2. 02Preliminary Considerations9 min
  3. 03Greece24 min
  4. 04Egypt10 min
  5. 05Philo on the Contemplative Life24 min
  6. 06Jewry11 min
  7. 07Alexandria29 min
  8. 08The Evolution of Catholic Christianity5 min
  9. 09The Ebionites5 min
  10. 10The Essenes6 min
  11. 11The Tendencies of Gnosticism8 min
  12. 12The Literature and Sources of Gnosticism12 min
  13. 13Some Gnostic Fragments Recovered from the Polemical Writings of the Church Fathers4 min
  14. 14The Simonians2 min left
  15. 15Dositheus3 min
  16. 16Simon Magus12 min
  17. 17Menander3 min
  18. 18Saturninus4 min
  19. 19The Ophites9 min
  20. 20An Anonymous System from Irenæus6 min
  21. 21An Early Ophite System6 min
  22. 22The Naasseni10 min
  23. 23The Peratæ8 min
  24. 24The Sethians5 min
  25. 25The Docetæ6 min
  26. 26Monoïmus3 min
  27. 27The So-Called Cainites6 min
  28. 28The Carpocratians5 min
  29. 29Epiphanes4 min
  30. 30Cerinthus3 min
  31. 31Nicolaus2 min
  32. 32Cerdo2 min
  33. 33Marcion11 min
  34. 34Apelles3 min
  35. 35The Basilidian Gnosis36 min
  36. 36The Valentinian Movement11 min
  37. 37Valentinus6 min
  38. 38i. From a Letter2 min
  39. 39ii. From a Letter2 min
  40. 40iii. From the Letter to Agathōpus2 min
  41. 41iv. From a Homily1 min
  42. 42v. A few Sentences preserved in the Controversial Matter of Clement...2 min
  43. 43vi. From the Letter on the Community of Friends1 min
  44. 44vii. A very doubtful Fragment from Eulogius of Alexandria writing at the end of the Sixth Century1 min
  45. 45viii. The Myth which Valentinus made1 min
  46. 46ix. From a Psalm5 min
  47. 47Some Outlines of Æonology29 min
  48. 48Hippolytus’ account of One of the Variants of the Sophia-Mythus25 min
  49. 49The Number-Symbolism of Marcus30 min
  50. 50Ptolemy9 min
  51. 51Heracleōn2 min
  52. 52Bardesanes16 min
  53. 53The Hymn of the Robe of Glory10 min
  54. 54Some Traces of the Gnosis in the Uncanonical Acts4 min
  55. 55From the Acts of Thomas9 min
  56. 56From the Acts of John22 min
  57. 57From the Acts of Andrew2 min
  58. 58From the Travels of Peter5 min
  59. 59The Askew and Bruce Codices7 min
  60. 60Summary of the Contents of the So-Called Pistis Sophia Treatise59 min