Fragments of a Faith Forgotten

Fragments of a Faith Forgotten · G.R.S. Mead

The So-Called Cainites

27 of 68

The Obscurity of the Subject.BEFORE returning again towards the time of the origins along another line of tradition, of which one or two obscure indications still remain--the Carpocrates-Cerinthus trace--we will briefly refer to the obscure chaos of tendencies classed together under the term "Cainite" and its variants. Our sources of information are scanty, and (if we exclude the mere mention of the name) are confined to Irenæus and Epiphanius; the latter, moreover, copies from Irenæus, and with the exception of his own reflections and lucubrations, has only a scrap or two of fresh information to add.

This line of tradition is again generally classed as "Ophite," and as usual we find that its adherents called themselves simply Gnostics. They were distinguished by the honour they paid to Cain and Judas; which fact, taken by itself, was sufficient to overwhelm them with the execrations of the orthodox, who ascribed the perpetration of every iniquity to them. Thus we find that Epiphanius, who wrote two hundred years after Irenæus, embroiders considerably on the account of the Bishop of Lyons, even where he is in other respects simply copying from his predecessor. We will now proceed to see the reason why these Gnostics entertained an apparently so strange belief.

If the reader will bear in mind the systems of Justinus and of the Sethians, he will be in a better position to comprehend what follows. The main features of the system of these Gnostics, then, is as follows.

The creator of the world was not the God over all; the absolute power from above was stronger than the weaker (ἡστέρα--hystera) power of generation, which was symbolized as the power of the impure world-womb, containing heaven and earth within it--the sensible world. But this sensible world was, as it were, an after-birth (ὕστερα--hystera), compared with the true birth from the virgin spiritual womb, the ideal world of the æons above. Epiphanius has made a great muddle of this part of the system; it is evidently consanguineous with the Valentinian "deficiency" (ὑστέρημα--hysterēma), or "abortion," the sensible world, without or external to the ideal fullness or perfection (πλήρωμα--plērōma), or world of the æons.

The inferior power, therefore, was the God of generation, the superior the God of enlightenment The Enemies of Yahweh the Friends of God. and wisdom. The Old Testament idea of God went no further than obedience to the commands of the inferior power. Those who had obeyed its behests were regarded as the worthies of old by the followers of the External Law, who, seeing no further, had in their traditions vilified all who refused to follow this law, the commands of the inferior power of generation. Thus Abel and Jacob and Lot and Moses were praised by the followers of the law of generation; whereas in reality it was the opponents of these who ought to be praised, as followers of the Higher Law who despised the laws of the powers of generation, and were thus protected by Wisdom and taken to herself, to the æon above. They therefore claimed that Cain and Esau, and the inhabitants of the Cities of the Plain, and Coran, Dathan and Abiram, were types of those individuals or nations who had followed a higher law, and who, apparently, were calumniated by the followers of Yahweh.

We can here see very plainly the traces of the same antitheses as those worked out by Justinus; the influence of the psychic powers or angels being traceable along the Abel line of descent, and that of the spiritual powers along the Cain line. Abel was the offerer of blood-sacrifices, while Cain offered the fruits of the field. This antithetical device, in one form or other, was common enough--as for instance, the later Ebionite antitheses of superior and inferior men (Isaac-Ishmael, Jacob-Esau, Moses-Aaron), or the Marcionite antitheses of the God of freedom and the God of the law, the God of the Christ and the Yahweh of the Old Testament--but the school whose tenets we are describing, seem, in their contempt for Yahweh, to have pushed their theories to the most extravagant conclusion of any. This is especially brought out in their ideas of New Testament history, which, in spite of their strangeness, may nevertheless contain a small trace of the true tradition of the cause of Jesus’ death.

Judas.This Gnostic circle had a number of writings, chief amongst which were two small summaries of instruction, one called The Gospel of Judas, and the other The Ascent of Paul. To take the latter first; The Ascent of Paul purported to, contain the record of the ineffable things which Paul is reported to have seen when he ascended into the third heaven. Whether this was the same as The Apocalypse of Paul referred to by Augustine is uncertain; in any case it is lost. A more orthodox version of one of the documents of the same cycle has come down to us in The Vision of Paul, a translation of which may be read in the last volume of the Ante-Nicene Christian Library (1897). If we can rely on this title, for which Epiphanius alone is responsible, the school of the Cainites is consequently post-Pauline.

But the strangest and, from one point of view, the most interesting development of their theory, was the view they took of Judas. The "Poor Men's" (Ebionite) tradition had consistently handed over Judas to universal execration; there was, however, apparently another tradition, presumably Essene in the first place, which took a different view of the matter. Obscure traces of this seem to be preserved in the unintelligent Irenæus-Epiphanius account of the Cainite doctrines.

This circle of students looked upon Judas as a man far advanced in the discipline of the Gnosis, and one who had a very clear idea of the true. God as distinguished from the God of generation; he consequently taught a complete divorcement from the things of the world and thus from the inferior power, which had made the heaven, the world and the flesh. Man was to ascend to the highest region through the crucifixion of the Christ. The Christ was the spirit which came down from above, in order that the stronger power of the spiritual world might be perfected in man; and so Jesus triumphed over the weaker power of generation at the expense of his body, which he handed over to death, one of the manifestations of the God of generation. This was the christological doctrine of the school, and it was apparently, judging from the "he says" of Epiphanius, taken from The Gospel of Judas.

A Scrap of History.But besides this general mystical teaching, there was also a historical tradition: that Jesus, after becoming the Christ and teaching the higher doctrine, fell away, in their opinion, and endeavoured to overset the law and corrupt the holy doctrine, and therefore Judas had him handed over to the authorities. That is to say, those to whom Jesus originally taught the higher doctrine considered that his too open preaching to the people was a divulging of the Mysteries, and so finally brought about his condemnation for blasphemy by the orthodox Jewish authorities.

Yet another more mystical tradition, preserved in one of their books, declared that, on the contrary, the Christ had not made a mistake, but that all had been done according to the heavenly wisdom. For the world-rulers knew that if the Christ were betrayed to the cross, that is to say, were incarnated, the inferior power would be drained out of them and they would ascend to the spiritual æon. Now Judas knew this, and, in his great faith, used every means to bring about His betrayal, and in this way the salvation of the world. These Gnostics consequently praised Judas as being one of the main factors in the scheme of salvation; without him the mystic "salvation of the cross" would not have been consummated, nor the consequent revelation of the realms above.

The Cainite circle, therefore, from their doctrines appear to have been rigid ascetics. But, says Epiphanius, embroidering on Irenæus, they were very dreadful people, and, like Carpocrates, taught that a man could not be saved without going through every kind of experience. We will therefore now take a brief glance at the views of the Carpocratians.

Up next

The Carpocratians

OUR main source of information is Irenæus; Tertullian, Hippolytus and Epiphanius simply copy their predecessor.

About 5 min to read

Take your library with you

Continue to the next chapter

Open the next chapter in the app. Reading is free.

Scan to open the next chapter

Every book is free to read. Downloading the app may not keep this chapter link; return here to open it after installing.

Contents

Fragments of a Faith Forgotten · G.R.S. Mead

68 chapters

  1. 01Prolegomena31 min
  2. 02Preliminary Considerations9 min
  3. 03Greece24 min
  4. 04Egypt10 min
  5. 05Philo on the Contemplative Life24 min
  6. 06Jewry11 min
  7. 07Alexandria29 min
  8. 08The Evolution of Catholic Christianity5 min
  9. 09The Ebionites5 min
  10. 10The Essenes6 min
  11. 11The Tendencies of Gnosticism8 min
  12. 12The Literature and Sources of Gnosticism12 min
  13. 13Some Gnostic Fragments Recovered from the Polemical Writings of the Church Fathers4 min
  14. 14The Simonians2 min
  15. 15Dositheus3 min
  16. 16Simon Magus12 min
  17. 17Menander3 min
  18. 18Saturninus4 min
  19. 19The Ophites9 min
  20. 20An Anonymous System from Irenæus6 min
  21. 21An Early Ophite System6 min
  22. 22The Naasseni10 min
  23. 23The Peratæ8 min
  24. 24The Sethians5 min
  25. 25The Docetæ6 min
  26. 26Monoïmus3 min
  27. 27The So-Called Cainites6 min left
  28. 28The Carpocratians5 min
  29. 29Epiphanes4 min
  30. 30Cerinthus3 min
  31. 31Nicolaus2 min
  32. 32Cerdo2 min
  33. 33Marcion11 min
  34. 34Apelles3 min
  35. 35The Basilidian Gnosis36 min
  36. 36The Valentinian Movement11 min
  37. 37Valentinus6 min
  38. 38i. From a Letter2 min
  39. 39ii. From a Letter2 min
  40. 40iii. From the Letter to Agathōpus2 min
  41. 41iv. From a Homily1 min
  42. 42v. A few Sentences preserved in the Controversial Matter of Clement...2 min
  43. 43vi. From the Letter on the Community of Friends1 min
  44. 44vii. A very doubtful Fragment from Eulogius of Alexandria writing at the end of the Sixth Century1 min
  45. 45viii. The Myth which Valentinus made1 min
  46. 46ix. From a Psalm5 min
  47. 47Some Outlines of Æonology29 min
  48. 48Hippolytus’ account of One of the Variants of the Sophia-Mythus25 min
  49. 49The Number-Symbolism of Marcus30 min
  50. 50Ptolemy9 min
  51. 51Heracleōn2 min
  52. 52Bardesanes16 min
  53. 53The Hymn of the Robe of Glory10 min
  54. 54Some Traces of the Gnosis in the Uncanonical Acts4 min
  55. 55From the Acts of Thomas9 min
  56. 56From the Acts of John22 min
  57. 57From the Acts of Andrew2 min
  58. 58From the Travels of Peter5 min
  59. 59The Askew and Bruce Codices7 min
  60. 60Summary of the Contents of the So-Called Pistis Sophia Treatise59 min