Plutarch's Lives

Plutarch's Lives · Plutarch

Comparison of Tiberius and Caius Gracchus with Agis and Kleomenes

Translated by Aubrey Stewart and George Long (1880) · 55 of 68

I. Now that we have completed the narrative of these men's lives, it remains for us to compare them with one another. As for the Gracchi, not even their bitterest enemies could deny that they were the most virtuous of all the Romans, or that they were excellently well nurtured and educated; while Agis and Kleomenes appear to have excelled them in strength of mind, because they both, after having been brought up in the same fashion by which their elders had been corrupted, became the restorers of temperance and simplicity of life. Furthermore, the Gracchi, who lived at a period when Rome was at the height of its greatness and renown, felt ashamed to fall short of the glorious achievements of their forefathers; while the virtuous impulses of the others were not checked by their fathers having pursued the opposite course of policy, or by the miserable and distracted condition of their country. The greatest proof of the unselfishness and indifference to money of the Gracchi is that they filled various offices in the state, and yet kept their hands clean from dishonest gains; while it would be an insult to Agis to praise him for not having taken other men's money, as he gave up to his countrymen his own private property, which alone was worth six hundred talents. If then he thought it discreditable for him to be richer than any of his countrymen, even though his riches were lawfully acquired, what must have been his abhorrence of those who obtain money wrongfully.

II. There was also a great difference in the boldness and extent of their schemes of reform. The Gracchi were chiefly engaged in the construction of roads and the founding of cities, and Tiberius's most important measure of reform was the division of the public lands among the people, while the best act of his brother Caius was the establishment of a mixed tribunal by adding to the three hundred Senators three hundred Roman Knights. The revolution effected by Agis and Kleomenes was of quite a different kind. They thought, in Plato's words, that to proceed by slow degrees was merely cutting off the heads of the hydra,[124] and therefore they by one comprehensive measure swept away all abuses at once: although it would be nearer the truth to say that they swept all abuses out of the state by restoring to it its original constitution. It may also be observed that the reforms of the Gracchi were opposed by some of the most powerful men in Rome, whereas the legislation which was begun by Agis, and completed by Kleomenes, followed a famous and ancient precedent, the rhetras on sobriety and equality which had been communicated to their ancestors by Lykurgus with the sanction of the Pythian Apollo. It is also most important to notice that the reforms of the Gracchi made Rome no greater than she was before, while the acts of Kleomenes enabled him in a short time to make Sparta mistress of the whole of Peloponnesus, and to engage in a contest with the most powerful man of his time, with the object of ridding Greece from Illyrian and Gaulish mercenary troops, and of renewing its ancient glories under the rule of the Herakleidæ.

Cutting the hydra back to its rootsMembership note · Open in the app

III. I think too that the deaths of these men show a certain difference in their courage. The Gracchi fought with their countrymen, and were slain by them while flying, while of the other two, Agis may almost be said to have died voluntarily, because he would not put a citizen to death, while Kleomenes, when insulted and ill-treated, fiercely attempted to avenge himself, and as circumstances prevented his succeeding, bravely killed himself. It may be said on the other side that Agis never distinguished himself in the field, and we may set against the many brilliant victories of Kleomenes the scaling of the wall of Carthage by Tiberius Gracchus, no slight achievement, and the peace which he made with the Numantines, by which he saved the lives of twenty thousand Roman soldiers, who could not otherwise have hoped to survive; while Caius, in several campaigns both in Italy and Sardinia, showed great military skill; so that they both might have rivalled the fame of the greatest generals of Rome, had they not been cut off so soon.

IV. In political matters Agis appears to have shown weakness, as he allowed Agesilaus to cheat the citizens out of their promised redistribution of lands, and in a feeble and vacillating manner announced his intention and then abandoned it. The cause of his irresolution was his extreme youth; while Kleomenes on the other hand effected his revolution with too great promptitude and daring, putting the Ephors to death without a trial, when it would have been easy for him to have won them over to his side, and banishing many of the citizens. It is not the part either of a wise physician or of a good politician to use the knife except in the last extremity, but it shows a want of skill in both, and in the latter case it is unjust as well as cruel. Of the Gracchi, neither would begin a civil war, and Caius is said not even to have defended himself when struck, but though forward enough in battle he was loth to fight in a party quarrel; for he appeared in public unarmed, and retired when fighting began, and evidently took more pains not to do any harm than not to suffer any. For this reason we must regard the flight of both the Gracchi as a proof, not of cowardice, but of caution; for they must either have retreated when attacked or have retaliated upon their opponents.

The political surgeon and the knifeMembership note · Open in the app

V. The heaviest charge that can be brought against Tiberius is that he deposed his colleague from the tribuneship, and afterwards sought a second tribuneship for himself. As for the murder of Antyllius, Caius Gracchus was most falsely and unjustly accused of it, for he did not wish him to die, and was grieved at his death. Again Kleomenes, not to speak of his massacre of the Ephors, set all the slaves at liberty, and practically made himself despot of the kingdom, although for form's sake he associated his brother with him, who was of the same family. And when Archidamus, who was the next heir to the throne of the other royal house, was persuaded by him to return from Messene to Sparta, as Kleomenes did not avenge his death, he caused men to suspect that he himself had some share in it. Yet Lykurgus, whom he affected to imitate, abdicated the throne of his own free will in favour of his nephew Charilaus, and fearing that if the child died by any mischance he might be thought guilty of having caused its death, he travelled abroad for a long time and did not return until Charilaus had begotten a son to succeed him. However, no Greek can bear comparison with Lykurgus; yet we have proved that Kleomenes effected greater reforms, and showed less respect to the laws than any of the others. Both the Greeks have been blamed for having from the very outset aimed at being nothing more than warlike despots; while the worst enemies of the Romans only charge them with an immoderate ambition, and admit that they became so excited by the contest with their political opponents that the natural heat of their temper drove them in spite of themselves like a baleful gust of wind to advocate extreme measures. What indeed can be more just or honourable than the objects with which they started; for their troubles were brought upon them by the opposition which the rich offered to their laws, so that the one was forced to fight to save his own life, while the other endeavoured to avenge his brother, who was slain without law or justice? From what has been said the reader can himself form an opinion about their respective merits, but if I must say what I think of each, I should give the highest place in respect of virtue to Tiberius Gracchus; I think that the young Agis committed the fewest crimes; while in daring and action Caius fell far short of Kleomenes.

Up next

Life of Demosthenes

I. The writer of the Ode to Alkibiades on the occasion of his winning the chariot-race at Olympia, whether he was Euripides, as is commonly supposed, or some other poet, my friend Sossius tells us that the first thing necessary for a perfectly happy man is that he should be born a citizen of some famous city.

About 43 min to read

Take your library with you

Listen to this chapter

Opens this chapter in the app. Tap Listen to begin. Narration requires membership.

Scan to open this chapter
Continue to the next chapter

Open the next chapter in the app. Reading is free.

Scan to open the next chapter

Every book is free to read. Downloading the app may not keep this chapter link; return here to open it after installing.

Contents

Plutarch's Lives · Plutarch

68 chapters

  1. 01Life of Plutarch14 min
  2. 02Life of Theseus48 min
  3. 03Life of Romulus56 min
  4. 04Comparison of Theseus and Romulus7 min
  5. 05Life of Lykurgus54 min
  6. 06Life of Numa42 min
  7. 07Comparison of Numa with Lykurgus10 min
  8. 08Life of Solon51 min
  9. 09Life of Poplicola35 min
  10. 10Comparison of Solon and Poplicola6 min
  11. 11Life of Themistokles48 min
  12. 12Life of Camillus65 min
  13. 13Life of Perikles60 min
  14. 14Life of Fabius Maximus46 min
  15. 15Comparison of Perikles and Fabius Maximus5 min
  16. 16Life of Alkibiades65 min
  17. 17Life of Caius Marcius Coriolanus56 min
  18. 18Comparison of Alkibiades and Coriolanus8 min
  19. 19Life of Timoleon55 min
  20. 20Life of Aemilius56 min
  21. 21Comparison of Paulus Aemilius and Timoleon4 min
  22. 22Life of Pelopidas55 min
  23. 23Life of Marcellus50 min
  24. 24Life of Aristeides52 min
  25. 25Life of Marcus Cato52 min
  26. 26Comparison of Aristeides and Cato10 min
  27. 27Life of Philopœmen32 min
  28. 28Life of Titus Flamininus35 min
  29. 29Comparison of Philopœmen and Titus4 min
  30. 30Life of Pyrrhus68 min
  31. 31Life of Caius Marius85 min
  32. 32Life of Lysander52 min
  33. 33Life of Sulla75 min
  34. 34Comparison of Lysander and Sulla8 min
  35. 35Life of Kimon36 min
  36. 36Life of Lucullus92 min
  37. 37Comparison of Kimon and Lucullus7 min
  38. 38Life of Nikias58 min
  39. 39Life of Crassus70 min
  40. 40Comparison of Nikias and Crassus8 min
  41. 41Life of Sertorius46 min
  42. 42Life of Eumenes33 min
  43. 43Comparison of Sertorius and Eumenes3 min
  44. 44Life of Agesilaus68 min
  45. 45Life of Pompeius134 min
  46. 46Comparison of Agesilaus and Pompeius8 min
  47. 47Life of Alexander129 min
  48. 48Life of C. Cæsar165 min
  49. 49Life of Phokion54 min
  50. 50Life of Cato111 min
  51. 51Life of Agis29 min
  52. 52Life of Kleomenes55 min
  53. 53Life of Tiberius Gracchus32 min
  54. 54Life of Caius Gracchus27 min
  55. 55Comparison of Tiberius and Caius Gracchus with Agis and Kleomenes7 min left
  56. 56Life of Demosthenes43 min
  57. 57Life of Cicero75 min
  58. 58Comparison of Demosthenes and Cicero6 min
  59. 59Life of Demetrius78 min
  60. 60Life of Antonius121 min