Thrice-Greatest Hermes, Vol. 2

Thrice-Greatest Hermes, Vol. 2 · G.R.S. Mead

Commentary: V. (VI.) Though Unmanifest God is Most Manifest

Translated by G.R.S. Mead · 11 of 51

THE TITLE

The redactor of our Corpus must have taken this sermon from some collection of “Those to Tat,” for it begins “καὶ τόνδε σοι τὸν λόγον.” One other sermon at least, then, must have preceded it; but whether it was our C. H., iv. (v.), “The Cup,” or the lost C. H. (ii.), “The General Sermon,” it is impossible to say.

The sermon bears no title proper, and the enunciation of the subject, which stands in its place, is derived from the second sentence of the treatise itself, and has plainly been superscribed by some later Byzantine editor.

MĀYĀ

The opening paragraphs of this fine tractate are very difficult to render into English in any way that can preserve the subtle shades of meaning of the Greek. As this subtle word-play has been entirely missed by all previous translators, I have made a rough attempt to preserve it by using the somewhat clumsy term “manifest.” The word-play in Greek may be seen from the following list of the original terms taken in the order of their occurrence: ἀφανές, φανερώτατον, ἐμφανές, φαινόμενον, ἐφάνη, ἀφανές, φανῆναι, φανερά, ἀφανής, φανερῶν, φανεροῦται, φαντασίᾳ, φαντασιῶν, φαντασία, ἀφαντασίαστος καὶ ἀφανής, φαντασιῶν, φαίνεται, φανῆναι. These all occur in § 1 and the first two lines of § 2.

I have translated φαντασία by “thinking-manifest,” seeing that it is the power by which an object is made apparent or manifest. The doctrine is the same as that of the Vedānta philosophy, the Māyā of the Vedāntavādins. Māyā is generally translated “illusion,” but this is not a good equivalent, for it comes from the root ma, to make or measure. The Logos is called in the Vedānta, Māyin (masc.), the Maker, Measurer, or Creator, and His Power, or Shakti, is Māyā (fem.). It is the Power of the Divine Thought, and so far from being illusion in any ordinary sense of the word, is very real for us, and is only non-real as compared to the Logos Himself, the One Reality in the highest philosophical sense of the term.

The idea is magnificently summed up for us in a logos of Phōsilampēs, quoted by the redactor of the Untitled Apocalypse of the Codex Brucianus, which runs as follows:

“Through Him is that-which-really-is and that-which-really-is-not, through which the Hidden-which-really-is and the Manifest-which-really-is-not exists.”

Also compare Hippolytus’ summary of the “Simonian” Gnosis:

“Of this Twofold Nature he calls the one side the Hidden and the other the Manifest, saying that the concealed [parts] of the Fire are hidden in the manifest, and the manifest produced by the concealed. . . .

“And the manifest side of the Fire has all things in itself which a man can perceive of things visible, or which he unconsciously fails to perceive. Whereas the hidden side is everything that we can conceive as intelligible, . . . or which a man fails to conceive.”

2. “The Lord begrudgeth not Himself to any thing.” Compare this with C. H., iv. (v.) 3: “Not that He grudgeth any, for grudging cometh not from Him”; and compare both with the saying of Plato in the Timæus (29 E):

A Saying Shared with PlatoMembership note · Open in the app

“He was Good, and to the Good there can never at any time be any grudging of aught.”

THE HIGHER PANTHEISM OR PANMONISM

10. With the soul-satisfying pantheism of § 10 we may with interest compare the address to the Logos in The Martyrdom of Peter, which still retains many Gnostic elements.

Mead’s Parallel in the Acts of PeterMembership note · Open in the app

“Thou that art to be understood by spirit alone! Thou art my father, Thou my mother, Thou my brother, Thou my friend, Thou my servant, Thou my master. Thou art the all, and all is in Thee. Yea, all that is, is Thou; and there is nothing else that is but Thee alone!”

HYMN TO ALL-GOD

The treatise ends with one of the most magnificent Hymns to God ever written in any language—a hymn which some foolish copyist has spoilt by tagging on to it the gloss of a reader noted on the margin of the MS. from which our scribe copied.

Mead’s Suspected Marginal GlossMembership note · Open in the app

With the sentence: “All are in Thee, all are from Thee,” compare the Naassene Hymn (quoted in Hippolytus’ Introduction, in “The Myth of Man”):

“‘From Thee’ is Father, and ‘Through Thee,’ Mother,—the two Immortal Names, Parents of Æons, O Thou who hast the Heaven for Thy City, O Man of Mighty Names!”

Footnotes

107:1 Perhaps a by-name of Basilides; see F. F. F., p. 554.

108:1 Hipp., Philos., vi. 9; see my Simon Magus (London, 1892), p. 13.

108:2 Lipsius (R. A.) and Bonnet (M.), Acta Apostolorum Apocrypha (Leipzig, 1891), i. 98.

Up next

VI. (VII.) In God Alone is Good and Elsewhere Nowhere

1. Good, O Asclepius, is in none else save God alone; nay, rather, Good is God Himself eternally.

About 5 min to read

Take your library with you

Listen to this chapter

Opens this chapter in the app. Tap Listen to begin. Narration requires membership.

Scan to open this chapter
Continue to the next chapter

Open the next chapter in the app. Reading is free.

Scan to open the next chapter

Every book is free to read. Downloading the app may not keep this chapter link; return here to open it after installing.

Contents

Thrice-Greatest Hermes, Vol. 2 · G.R.S. Mead

51 chapters

  1. 01I. Pœmandres, the Shepherd of Men18 min
  2. 02Commentary: I. Pœmandres, the Shepherd of Men47 min
  3. 03(II.) The General Sermon1 min
  4. 04II. (III.) To Asclepius10 min
  5. 05Commentary: II. (III.) To Asclepius7 min
  6. 06III. (IV.) The Sacred Sermon3 min
  7. 07Commentary: III. (IV.) The Sacred Sermon8 min
  8. 08IV. (V.) The Cup or Monad8 min
  9. 09Commentary: IV. (V.) The Cup or Monad9 min
  10. 10V. (VI.) Though Unmanifest God is Most Manifest8 min
  11. 11Commentary: V. (VI.) Though Unmanifest God is Most Manifest4 min left
  12. 12VI. (VII.) In God Alone is Good and Elsewhere Nowhere5 min
  13. 13Commentary: VI. (VII.) In God Alone is Good and Elsewhere Nowhere6 min
  14. 14VII. (VIII.) The Greatest Ill Among Men is Ignorance of God2 min
  15. 15Commentary: VII. (VIII.) The Greatest Ill Among Men is Ignorance of God2 min
  16. 16VIII. (IX.) That No One of Existing Things doth Perish, but Men in Error Speak of Their Changes as Destructions and as Deaths4 min
  17. 17Commentary: VIII. (IX.) That No One of Existing Things doth Perish, but Men in Error Speak of Their Changes as Destructions and as Deaths2 min
  18. 18IX. (X.) On Thought and Sense7 min
  19. 19Commentary: IX. (X.) On Thought and Sense6 min
  20. 20X. (XI.) The Key18 min
  21. 21Commentary: X. (XI.) The Key20 min
  22. 22XI. (XII.) Mind Unto Hermes15 min
  23. 23Commentary: XI. (XII.) Mind Unto Hermes11 min
  24. 24XII. (XIII.) About the Common Mind13 min
  25. 25Commentary: XII. (XIII.) About the Common Mind8 min
  26. 26XIII. (XIV.) The Secret Sermon on the Mountain15 min
  27. 27Commentary: XIII. (XIV.) The Secret Sermon on the Mountain28 min
  28. 28XIV. (XV.) A Letter to Asclepius7 min
  29. 29Commentary: XIV. (XV.) A Letter to Asclepius3 min
  30. 30(XVI.) The Definitions of Asclepius unto King Ammon11 min
  31. 31Commentary: (XVI.) The Definitions of Asclepius unto King Ammon10 min
  32. 32(XVII.) Of Asclepius to the King2 min
  33. 33Commentary: (XVII.) Of Asclepius to the King2 min
  34. 34(XVIII.) The Encomium of Kings10 min
  35. 35Commentary: (XVIII.) The Encomium of Kings7 min
  36. 36Part I5 min
  37. 37Part II4 min
  38. 38Part III5 min
  39. 39Part IV4 min
  40. 40Part V3 min
  41. 41Part VI8 min
  42. 42Part VII7 min
  43. 43Part VIII10 min
  44. 44Part IX11 min
  45. 45Part X10 min
  46. 46Part XI6 min
  47. 47Part XII6 min
  48. 48Part XIII5 min
  49. 49Part XIV3 min
  50. 50Part XV3 min
  51. 51Commentary: The Perfect Sermon17 min