Thrice-Greatest Hermes, Vol. 2

Thrice-Greatest Hermes, Vol. 2 · G.R.S. Mead

Commentary: IX. (X.) On Thought and Sense

Translated by G.R.S. Mead · 19 of 51

TITLE AND ORDERING

This treatise bears a double title:—“On Thought and Sense,” and “That the Beautiful and Good is in God only.” The former heading is clearly taken from the concluding words: “Let so much then suffice on thought-and-sense”; whereas the introductory sentence speaks of the Sermon on Sense only. The latter heading seems to be a thoughtless repetition of the title of C. H., vi. (vii.).

The opening words: “I gave the Perfect Sermon yesterday, Asclepius,” inform us not only that we have to do with an Asclepius Dialogue, but also that our sermon followed directly on the “Perfect Sermon,” a Latin version of which has fortunately been preserved to us.

It is, therefore, of very great interest to find that Lactantius, in quoting a sentence from our treatise (§ 4)—“Devotion is God-gnosis”—continues with the words: “Asclepius, his hearer, has also explained the same idea at greater length in the Perfect Sermon.”

Lactantius had, therefore, a collection before him in which these two sermons stood in close connection.

Reitzenstein (p. 195) thinks that our sermon must be an extract from a longer one, because he cannot bring himself to believe that so short a treatise could have been found in immediate connection (as the opening words suggest) with so lengthy and detailed a tractate as the “Perfect Sermon.” This may be so; and yet the formal beginning and ending of our sermon would seem to suggest that we are dealing with a complete tractate and not with an extract.

“SENSE-AND-THOUGHT”

The doctrine that in men “sense-and-thought” together constitutes human “sense” throws some light on the meaning of the term “sense” as used elsewhere in the Trismegistic literature, where we should expect to find “mind” employed, and that, too, in the sense of the higher mind.

Normal human “thought,” then, is, so to say, sensible, entirely bound up in sense-impressions; it is the mind alone that can soar beyond the senses, for it alone can be “illumined by God’s Light” (§ 3).

The mind is, as it were, a womb or woman, that can be impregnated either by the “Seeds of God” or by the “Daimonial Energy”; she thus conceives and brings forth virtues or vices.

All of this is precisely the same doctrine as Philo preaches, as may be seen by the passages we have quoted in the “Prolegomena” on the subject of the “Sacred Marriage.”

THOSE IN GNOSIS

The Seeds of God are Virtue and Self-control and Devotion or Piety; and Devotion in its true sense is God-gnosis, or Knowledge of God. The Gnostics, then, “they who are in Gnosis”—a curious expression—because of their natural divorcement from the “world,” “please not the many, nor the many them.”

“They are thought mad and laughed at; they’re hated and despised, and sometimes even put to death.”

Mark the impersonal note, the calm laying down of the causes of misunderstanding between the “many” and the “few’’; and compare this with the more personal note of the saying underlying the following Synoptic accommodations:

“Blessed are ye when men hate you and excommunicate you, and revile and expel your Name as evil, for the Son of Man’s sake” (Luke vi. 22).

“Blessed are ye when men revile you and persecute you and say all evil against you, lying, for My sake” (Matt. v. 11).

It is clear, at least it seems so to me, that “Luke” has kept closer to the original, and that that original was addressed not only to the members of a community, but to those who had been cast forth from some other community “for the sake of the Son of Man”—that is, because of the immediate inspiration of the Logos, which doubtless did not pay sufficient attention to the prejudices of the “many” of that community.

“Matthew,” on the contrary, seems to have adapted the Saying for general purposes and the necessities of the Cult of Jesus.

THE TRUE GNOSTIC

Excellent also is the doctrine that the true “Gnostic,” the man who is consciously growing into the stature of the Christ, the true “Devotee of God,” “will bear with all,” for he is beginning to know the Reason of things.

“For such an one all things, e’en though they be for others bad, are for him good; deliberately he doth refer them all unto the Gnosis.”

He sees the Good, he sees God, in all things. He is the true Alchemist. For “thing most marvellous, ’tis he alone who maketh bad things good”; by spiritual alchemy he transmutes the evil of the world to good; he drains the “cup of bitterness” unto the dregs, and transmutes it into the pure Water of Life.

In every Man, then, there are two “men,” the material (or hylic) and the substantial (or spiritual, οὐσιώδης).

Evil, however, is not a permanent thing; it is but the process of “becoming good,” the productive side of things (§ 5).

THE GOAL OF THE GNOSIS

It is difficult to bring out the delicacy of the wording of the original in translation. First God’s ultimate intention is stated to be the making of all things like unto (ὅμοια) Himself; the world-process is to be ultimately consummated in the Great Sameness of Union with Him. But meantime while this making, creating or becoming, or transformation, is going on, the imperfections cannot produce, that is, become creators in their turn; they are unproductive (ἄφορα). That which is the instrument or organ of God’s making is the Cosmic Course (φορά). We are finally (§ 7) told that the differences of bodies are conditioned by the speed of this Cosmic Course; therefore the opposite poles, Other and Same, are both ultimately referable to Cosmos, the Likeness of God.

The end to be achieved is to develop the “sense-and-thought” of the Cosmos, the One Sense, not manifold, but simple. This is the deliberate working with the Will of God, the Cosmic Will, the perpetual renewing of all things (ἀνανέωσις).

The Cosmos, then, as the Logos of God, is the Good Gardener of Life; it is both the place of Life and its Creator—that is to say, both female and male, both Mother and Father.

THE POSSIBILITY OF KNOWING GOD

But the Cosmos is not apart from God, nor even in God; God does not have Cosmos as a possession, but is Cosmos and all therein (§ 9). Cosmos is Son of God, His Very Self (§ 8).

Therefore we can learn to know somewhat of the nature of God by sense and thought, for, “God is not, as some suppose, beyond the reach of sense and thought” (ἀναισθητὸς καὶ ἀνόητος); that is, God does not entirely transcend sense and thought, for God is all things.

“As some suppose” doubtless refers again to the “blasphemers” of § 4—that is, the apparently dualistic doctrine set forth in C. H., vi. (vii.).

And so, finally, we learn that Faith, in the true sense, is a certitude of the mind, or of true manhood. “To understand is to believe” (§ 10). Gnosis and not belief is the Fair Faith.

Compare with this the “Perfect Sermon,” x. 1:

“The reason for a thesis such as this, O my Asclepius, I would that thou should’st grasp, not only with the keen attention of thy soul, but also with its living power as well.

“For ’tis a reason that most men cannot believe; the Perfect and the True are to be grasped by the more holy minds.”

Footnotes

136:1 For it would, of course, be absurd to suppose that the “Perfect Sermon” could in any way be thought to indicate C. H., vi. (vii.), the last Asclepius Dialogue in our Corpus; especially when our sermon (§ 4) directly combats the teaching of C. H., vi.

136:2 Div. Institt., ii. 15 (Ed. Fritz., i. 106); cf. also v. 14.

138:1 R. (p. 213, 1) brings this passage of our sermon into connection with some assumed persecution of the Pœmandres communities in the course of the fourth century; but I cannot myself see the slightest ground for such an assumption.

140:1 Reitzenstein (p. 171, 2) compares this doctrine of the insensibility and incognizability of God with the Sabæan Gnosis.

Up next

X. (XI.) The Key

1. Hermes. My yesterday’s discourse (logos) I did devote to thee, Asclepius, and so ’tis [only] right I should devote to-day’s to Tat; and this the more because ’tis the abridgment of the General Sermons (Logoi) which he has had addressed to him.

About 18 min to read

Take your library with you

Listen to this chapter

Opens this chapter in the app. Tap Listen to begin. Narration requires membership.

Scan to open this chapter
Continue to the next chapter

Open the next chapter in the app. Reading is free.

Scan to open the next chapter

Every book is free to read. Downloading the app may not keep this chapter link; return here to open it after installing.

Contents

Thrice-Greatest Hermes, Vol. 2 · G.R.S. Mead

51 chapters

  1. 01I. Pœmandres, the Shepherd of Men18 min
  2. 02Commentary: I. Pœmandres, the Shepherd of Men47 min
  3. 03(II.) The General Sermon1 min
  4. 04II. (III.) To Asclepius10 min
  5. 05Commentary: II. (III.) To Asclepius7 min
  6. 06III. (IV.) The Sacred Sermon3 min
  7. 07Commentary: III. (IV.) The Sacred Sermon8 min
  8. 08IV. (V.) The Cup or Monad8 min
  9. 09Commentary: IV. (V.) The Cup or Monad9 min
  10. 10V. (VI.) Though Unmanifest God is Most Manifest8 min
  11. 11Commentary: V. (VI.) Though Unmanifest God is Most Manifest4 min
  12. 12VI. (VII.) In God Alone is Good and Elsewhere Nowhere5 min
  13. 13Commentary: VI. (VII.) In God Alone is Good and Elsewhere Nowhere6 min
  14. 14VII. (VIII.) The Greatest Ill Among Men is Ignorance of God2 min
  15. 15Commentary: VII. (VIII.) The Greatest Ill Among Men is Ignorance of God2 min
  16. 16VIII. (IX.) That No One of Existing Things doth Perish, but Men in Error Speak of Their Changes as Destructions and as Deaths4 min
  17. 17Commentary: VIII. (IX.) That No One of Existing Things doth Perish, but Men in Error Speak of Their Changes as Destructions and as Deaths2 min
  18. 18IX. (X.) On Thought and Sense7 min
  19. 19Commentary: IX. (X.) On Thought and Sense6 min left
  20. 20X. (XI.) The Key18 min
  21. 21Commentary: X. (XI.) The Key20 min
  22. 22XI. (XII.) Mind Unto Hermes15 min
  23. 23Commentary: XI. (XII.) Mind Unto Hermes11 min
  24. 24XII. (XIII.) About the Common Mind13 min
  25. 25Commentary: XII. (XIII.) About the Common Mind8 min
  26. 26XIII. (XIV.) The Secret Sermon on the Mountain15 min
  27. 27Commentary: XIII. (XIV.) The Secret Sermon on the Mountain28 min
  28. 28XIV. (XV.) A Letter to Asclepius7 min
  29. 29Commentary: XIV. (XV.) A Letter to Asclepius3 min
  30. 30(XVI.) The Definitions of Asclepius unto King Ammon11 min
  31. 31Commentary: (XVI.) The Definitions of Asclepius unto King Ammon10 min
  32. 32(XVII.) Of Asclepius to the King2 min
  33. 33Commentary: (XVII.) Of Asclepius to the King2 min
  34. 34(XVIII.) The Encomium of Kings10 min
  35. 35Commentary: (XVIII.) The Encomium of Kings7 min
  36. 36Part I5 min
  37. 37Part II4 min
  38. 38Part III5 min
  39. 39Part IV4 min
  40. 40Part V3 min
  41. 41Part VI8 min
  42. 42Part VII7 min
  43. 43Part VIII10 min
  44. 44Part IX11 min
  45. 45Part X10 min
  46. 46Part XI6 min
  47. 47Part XII6 min
  48. 48Part XIII5 min
  49. 49Part XIV3 min
  50. 50Part XV3 min
  51. 51Commentary: The Perfect Sermon17 min