Upanishads Part II

Upanishads Part II · Various

Brihadaranyaka Upanishad: III.1 — The Great Debate

Translated by F. Max Muller · 56 of 112

THIRD ADHYÂYA. FIRST BRÂHMANA 1.

Adoration to the Highest Self (Paramâtman)!

1. Ganaka Vaideha (the king of the Videhas) sacrificed with a sacrifice at which many presents were offered to the priests of (the Asvamedha). Brâhmanas of the Kurus and the Pâñkâlas had come thither, and Ganaka Vaideha wished to know, which of those Brâhmanas was the best read. So he enclosed a thousand cows, and ten pâdas (of gold) 2 were fastened to each pair of horns.

2. And Ganaka spoke to them: 'Ye venerable Brâhmanas, he who among you is the wisest, let him drive away these cows.'

Then those Brâhmanas durst not, but Yâgñavalkya said to his pupil: 'Drive them away, my dear.'

A claim made before the debateMembership note · Open in the app

He replied: 'O glory of the Sâman 3' and drove them away.

The Brâhmanas became angry and said: 'How could he call himself the wisest among us?'

Now there was Asvala, the Hotri priest of Ganaka Vaideha. He asked him: 'Are you indeed the wisest among us, O Yâgñavalkya?' He replied: 'I bow before the wisest (the best knower of Brahman), but I wish indeed to have these cows.'

Then Asvala, the Hotri priest, undertook to question him.

1. 'Yâgñavalkya, he said, 'everything here (connected with the sacrifice) is reached by death, everything is overcome by death. By what means then is the sacrificer freed beyond the reach of death?'

Yâgñavalkya said: 'By the Hotri priest, who is Agni (fire), who is speech. For speech is the Hotri of the sacrifice (or the sacrificer), and speech is Agni, and he is the Hotri. This constitutes freedom, and perfect freedom (from death).'

4. 'Yâgñavalkya,' he said, 'everything here is reached by day and night, everything is overcome by day and night. By what means then is the sacrificer freed beyond the reach of day and night?'

Yâgñavalkya said: 'By the Adhvaryu priest, who is the eye, who is Âditya (the sun) 1. For the eye is the Adhvaryu of the sacrifice, and the eye is the sun, and he is the Adhvaryu. This constitutes freedom, and perfect freedom.'

5. 'Yâgñavalkya,' he said, 'everything here is reached by the waxing and waning of the moon, everything is overcome by the waxing and waning of the moon. By what means then is the sacrificer freed beyond the reach of the waxing and waning of the moon?'

Yâgñavalkya said: 'By the Udgâtri priest, who is Vâyu (the wind), who is the breath. For the breath is the Udgâtri of the sacrifice, and the breath is the wind, and he is the Udgâtri. This constitutes freedom, and perfect freedom.'

6. 'Yâgñavalkya,' he said, 'this sky is, as it were, without an ascent (staircase.) By what approach does the sacrificer approach the Svarga world?'

Yâgñavalkya said: 'By the Brahman priest, who is the mind (manas), who is the moon. For the mind is the Brahman of the sacrifice, and the mind is the moon, and he is the Brahman. This constitutes freedom, and perfect freedom. These are the complete deliverances (from death).'

Next follow the achievements.

7. 'Yâgñavalkya,' he said, 'how many Rik verses will the Hotri priest employ to-day at this sacrifice?'

'Three,' replied Yâgñavalkya.

'And what are these three?'

'Those which are called Puronuvâkyâ, Yâgyâ, and, thirdly, Sasyâ 1.'

'What does he gain by them?'

'All whatsoever has breath.'

8. 'Yâgñavalkya,' he said, 'how many oblations (âhuti) will the Adhvaryu priest employ to-day at this sacrifice?'

'Three,' replied Yâgñavalkya.

'And what are these three?'

'Those which, when offered, flame up; those which, when offered, make an excessive noise; and those which, when offered, sink down 2.'

'What does he gain by them?'

'By those which, when offered, flame up, he gains the Deva (god) world, for the Deva world flames up, as it were. By those which, when offered, make an excessive noise, he gains the Pitri (father) world, for the Pitri world is excessively (noisy) 1. By those which, when offered, sink down, he gains the Manushya (man) world, for the Manushya world is, as it were, down below.'

9. 'Yâgñavalkya,' he said, 'with how many deities does the Brahman priest on the right protect to-day this sacrifice?'

'By one,' replied Yâgñavalkya.

'And which is it?'

'The mind alone; for the mind is endless, and the Visvedevas are endless, and he thereby gains the endless world.'

10. 'Yâgñavalkya,' he said, 'how many Stotriyâ hymns will the Udgâtri priest employ to-day at this sacrifice?'

'Three,' replied Yâgñavalkya.

'And what are these three?'

'Those which are called Puronuvâkyâ, Yâgyâ, and, thirdly, Sasyâ.'

'And what are these with regard to the body (adhyâtmam)?'

'The Puronuvâkyâ is Prâna (up-breathing), the Yâgyâ the Apâna (down-breathing), the Sasyâ the Vyâna (back-breathing).'

'What does he gain by them?'

'He gains the earth by the Puronuvâkyâ, the sky by the Yâgyâ, heaven by the Sasyâ.'

After that Asvala held his peace.

Footnotes

121:1 Mâdhyandina text, .

121:2 Palakaturbhâgah pâdah suvarnasya. Comm.

121:3 One expects iti after udaga, but Sâmasravas is applied to Yâgñavalkya, and not to the pupil. Yâgñavalkya, as the commentator observes, was properly a teacher of the Yagur-veda, but as the pupil calls him Sâmasravas, he shows that Yâgñavalkya knew all the four Vedas, because the Sâmans are taken from the Rig-veda, and the Atharva-veda is contained in the other three Vedas. Regnaud, however, refers it to the pupil, and translates, 'Ô toi qui apprends le Sâma-veda.'

122:1 One expects âdityena kakshushâ, instead of kakshushâdityena, but see § 6.

123:1 The Puronuvâkyâs are hymns employed before the actual sacrifice, the Yâgyâs accompany the sacrifice, the Sasyâs are used for the Sastra. All three are called Stotriyâs.

123:2 These oblations are explained as consisting of wood and oil, of flesh, and of milk and Soma. The first, when thrown on the fire, flame up. The second, when thrown on the fire, make a loud hissing noise. The third, consisting of milk, Soma, &c., sink down into the earth.

124:1 On account of the cries of those who wish to be delivered out of it. Comm.

Up next

Brihadaranyaka Upanishad: III.2 — Artabhaga's Questions

1. Then Gâratkârava Ârtabhâga 2 asked. 'Yâgñavalkya,' he said, 'how many Grahas are there, and how many Atigrahas 3?'

About 3 min to read

Take your library with you

Continue to the next chapter

Open the next chapter in the app. Reading is free.

Scan to open the next chapter

Every book is free to read. Downloading the app may not keep this chapter link; return here to open it after installing.

Contents

Upanishads Part II · Various

112 chapters

  1. 01Introduction (Part 1)33 min
  2. 02Introduction (Part 2)32 min
  3. 03Katha Upanishad: First Adhyaya, First Valli9 min
  4. 04Katha Upanishad: First Adhyaya, Second Valli6 min
  5. 05Katha Upanishad: First Adhyaya, Third Valli4 min
  6. 06Katha Upanishad: Second Adhyaya, Fourth Valli3 min
  7. 07Katha Upanishad: Second Adhyaya, Fifth Valli3 min
  8. 08Katha Upanishad: Second Adhyaya, Sixth Valli5 min
  9. 09Mundaka Upanishad: First Mundaka, First Khanda3 min
  10. 10Mundaka Upanishad: First Mundaka, Second Khanda5 min
  11. 11Mundaka Upanishad: Second Mundaka, First Khanda2 min
  12. 12Mundaka Upanishad: Second Mundaka, Second Khanda3 min
  13. 13Mundaka Upanishad: Third Mundaka, First Khanda3 min
  14. 14Mundaka Upanishad: Third Mundaka, Second Khanda3 min
  15. 15Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Siksha Valli, Anuvaka 11 min
  16. 16Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Siksha Valli, Anuvakas2-32 min
  17. 17Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Siksha Valli, Anuvaka 42 min
  18. 18Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Siksha Valli, Anuvaka 51 min
  19. 19Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Siksha Valli, Anuvaka 61 min
  20. 20Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Siksha Valli, Anuvaka 71 min
  21. 21Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Siksha Valli, Anuvaka 81 min
  22. 22Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Siksha Valli, Anuvaka 91 min
  23. 23Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Siksha Valli, Anuvaka 101 min
  24. 24Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Siksha Valli, Anuvaka 112 min
  25. 25Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Siksha Valli, Anuvaka 121 min
  26. 26Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Ananda Valli, Anuvaka 12 min
  27. 27Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Ananda Valli, Anuvaka 22 min
  28. 28Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Ananda Valli, Anuvaka 31 min
  29. 29Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Ananda Valli, Anuvaka 41 min
  30. 30Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Ananda Valli, Anuvaka 51 min
  31. 31Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Ananda Valli, Anuvaka 61 min
  32. 32Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Ananda Valli, Anuvaka 72 min
  33. 33Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Ananda Valli, Anuvaka 85 min
  34. 34Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Ananda Valli, Anuvaka 91 min
  35. 35Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Bhrigu Valli, Anuvaka 11 min
  36. 36Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Bhrigu Valli, Anuvaka 21 min
  37. 37Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Bhrigu Valli, Anuvaka 31 min
  38. 38Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Bhrigu Valli, Anuvaka 41 min
  39. 39Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Bhrigu Valli, Anuvaka 51 min
  40. 40Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Bhrigu Valli, Anuvaka 61 min
  41. 41Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Bhrigu Valli, Anuvaka 71 min
  42. 42Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Bhrigu Valli, Anuvaka 81 min
  43. 43Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Bhrigu Valli, Anuvaka 91 min
  44. 44Taittiriyaka Upanishad: Bhrigu Valli, Anuvaka 103 min
  45. 45Brihadaranyaka Upanishad: I.1 — The Horse Sacrifice3 min
  46. 46Brihadaranyaka Upanishad: I.2 — In the Beginning13 min
  47. 47Brihadaranyaka Upanishad: I.4 — The Self Alone9 min
  48. 48Brihadaranyaka Upanishad: I.5 — The Creation9 min
  49. 49Brihadaranyaka Upanishad: I.6 — Name, Form, and Work1 min
  50. 50Brihadaranyaka Upanishad: II.1 — Gargya and Ajatasatru8 min
  51. 51Brihadaranyaka Upanishad: II.2 — The Babe and the Chamber3 min
  52. 52Brihadaranyaka Upanishad: II.3 — Two Forms of Brahman2 min
  53. 53Brihadaranyaka Upanishad: II.4 — Yajnavalkya and Maitreyi7 min
  54. 54Brihadaranyaka Upanishad: II.5 — The Honey Doctrine7 min
  55. 55Brihadaranyaka Upanishad: II.6 — The Lineage2 min
  56. 56Brihadaranyaka Upanishad: III.1 — The Great Debate5 min left
  57. 57Brihadaranyaka Upanishad: III.2 — Artabhaga's Questions3 min
  58. 58Brihadaranyaka Upanishad: III.3 — Bhujyu's Questions2 min
  59. 59Brihadaranyaka Upanishad: III.4 — Ushasta's Questions2 min
  60. 60Brihadaranyaka Upanishad: III.5 — Kahola's Questions2 min