Guide for the Perplexed

Guide for the Perplexed · Moses Maimonides

Part 2: Chapter XXVI

Translated by M. Friedlander (1904) · 118 of 194

CHAPTER XXVI IN the famous chapters known as the Chapters of Rabbi Eliezer, I find R. Eliezer the Great saying something more extraordinary than I have ever seen in the utterances of any believer in the Law of Moses. I mean the following passage: "Whence were the heavens created? He took part of the light of His garment, stretched it like a cloth, and thus the heavens were extending continually, as it is said: He covereth Himself with light as with a garment, He stretcheth the heavens like a curtain" (Ps. civ. 2). "Whence was the earth created? He took of the snow under the throne of glory, and threw it; according to the words: He saith to the snow, Be thou earth" (Job xxxvii. 6). These are the words given there; and I, in my surprise, ask, What was the belief of this sage?

did he think that nothing can be produced from nothing, and that a substance must have existed of which the things were formed? and did he for this reason ask whence were the heavens and the earth created? What has he gained by the answer? We might ask him, Whence was the light of His garment created? or the snow under the throne of His glory? or the throne of glory itself? If the terms "the light of His garment" and "the throne of glory" mean something eternal, they must be rejected; the words would imply an admission of the Eternity of the Universe, though only in the form taught by Plato. The creation of the throne of glory is mentioned by our Sages, though in a strange way: for they say that it has been created before the creation of the Universe.

Reading a strange midrash charitablyMembership note · Open in the app

Scripture, however, does not mention the creation of the throne, except in the words of David, "The Lord hath established his throne in the heavens" (Ps. ciii. 19), which words admit of figurative interpretation; but the eternity of the throne is distinctly described, "Thou, O Lord, dwellest for ever, thy throne for ever and ever" (Lam. v. 19). Now, if R. Eliezer had believed that the throne was eternal, so that the word "throne" expressed an attribute of God, and not something created, how could anything be produced of a mere attribute? Stranger still is his expression "of the light of His garment."

In short, it is a passage that greatly confuses the notions of all intelligent and religious persons. I am unable to explain it sufficiently. I quoted it in order that you may not be misled by it. One important thing R. Eliezer taught us here, that the substance of the heavens is different from that of the earth: that there are two different substances: the one is described as belonging to God, being the light of His garment, on account of its superiority; and the other, the earthly substance, which is distant from His splendour and light, as being the snow under the throne of His glory. This led me to explain the words, "And under his feet as the work of the whiteness of the sapphire" (Exod. xxiv.

10), as expressing that the nobles of the children of Israel comprehended in a prophetical vision the nature of the earthly materia prima. For, according to Onkelos, the pronoun in the phrase, "His feet," refers to "throne," as I have shown: this indicates that the whiteness under the throne signifies the earthly substance. R. Eliezer has thus repeated the same idea, and told us that there are two substances--a higher one, and a lower one; and that there is not one substance common to all things. This is an important subject, and we must not think light of the opinion which the wisest men in Israel have held on this point. It concerns an important point in explaining the existence of the Universe, and one of the mysteries of the Law. In Bereshit Rabba (chap.

xii.) the following passage occurs: "R. Eliezer says, The things in the heavens have been created of the heavens, the things on earth of the earth." Consider how ingeniously this sage stated that all things on earth have one common substance; the heavens and the things in them have one substance, different from the first. He also explains in the Chapters [of R. Eliezer], in addition to the preceding things, the superiority of the heavenly substance, and its proximity to God; and, on the other hand, the inferiority of the earthly substance and its position. Note it.

Up next

Part 2: Chapter XXVII

CHAPTER XXVII WE have already stated that the belief in the Creation is a fundamental principle of our religion: but we do not consider it a principle of our faith that the Universe will again be reduced to nothing.

About 3 min to read

Take your library with you

Listen to this chapter

Opens this chapter in the app. Tap Listen to begin. Narration requires membership.

Scan to open this chapter
Continue to the next chapter

Open the next chapter in the app. Reading is free.

Scan to open the next chapter

Every book is free to read. Downloading the app may not keep this chapter link; return here to open it after installing.

Contents

Guide for the Perplexed · Moses Maimonides

194 chapters

  1. 01Preface1 min
  2. 02Preface to Volume One of the First Edition1 min
  3. 03The Life of Moses Maimonides29 min
  4. 04The Moreh Nebuchim Literature30 min
  5. 05Analysis of the Guide for the Perplexed60 min
  6. 06Introduction2 min
  7. 07Prefatory Remarks19 min
  8. 08Directions for the Study of this Work4 min
  9. 09Introductory Remarks on Method6 min
  10. 10Part 1: Chapter I5 min
  11. 11Part 1: Chapter II6 min
  12. 12Part 1: Chapter III2 min
  13. 13Part 1: Chapter IV3 min
  14. 14Part 1: Chapter V4 min
  15. 15Part 1: Chapter VI1 min
  16. 16Part 1: Chapter VII3 min
  17. 17Part 1: Chapter VIII2 min
  18. 18Part 1: Chapter IX2 min
  19. 19Part 1: Chapter X4 min
  20. 20Part 1: Chapter XI3 min
  21. 21Part 1: Chapter XII2 min
  22. 22Part 1: Chapter XIII2 min
  23. 23Part 1: Chapter XIV1 min
  24. 24Part 1: Chapter XV2 min
  25. 25Part 1: Chapter XVI2 min
  26. 26Part 1: Chapter XVII2 min
  27. 27Part 1: Chapter XVIII4 min
  28. 28Part 1: Chapter XIX2 min
  29. 29Part 1: Chapter XX2 min
  30. 30Part 1: Chapter XXI6 min
  31. 31Part 1: Chapter XXII2 min
  32. 32Part 1: Chapter XXIII3 min
  33. 33Part 1: Chapter XXIV2 min
  34. 34Part 1: Chapter XXV2 min
  35. 35Part 1: Chapter XXVI3 min
  36. 36Part 1: Chapter XXVII4 min
  37. 37Part 1: Chapter XXVIII5 min
  38. 38Part 1: Chapter XXIX2 min
  39. 39Part 1: Chapter XXX3 min
  40. 40Part 1: Chapter XXXI4 min
  41. 41Part 1: Chapter XXXII5 min
  42. 42Part 1: Chapter XXXIII3 min
  43. 43Part 1: Chapter XXXIV12 min
  44. 44Part 1: Chapter XXXV4 min
  45. 45Part 1: Chapter XXXVI6 min
  46. 46Part 1: Chapter XXXVII4 min
  47. 47Part 1: Chapter XXXVIII1 min
  48. 48Part 1: Chapter XXXIX3 min
  49. 49Part 1: Chapter XL2 min
  50. 50Part 1: Chapter XLI3 min
  51. 51Part 1: Chapter XLII2 min
  52. 52Part 1: Chapter XLIII2 min
  53. 53Part 1: Chapter XLIV1 min
  54. 54Part 1: Chapter XLV2 min
  55. 55Part 1: Chapter XLVI12 min
  56. 56Part 1: Chapter XLVII3 min
  57. 57Part 1: Chapter XLVIII4 min
  58. 58Part 1: Chapter XLIX5 min
  59. 59Part 1: Chapter L3 min
  60. 60Part 1: Chapter LI4 min