Guide for the Perplexed

Guide for the Perplexed · Moses Maimonides

Part 2: Chapter XLI

Translated by M. Friedlander (1904) · 133 of 194

CHAPTER XLI I NEED not explain what a dream is, but I will explain the meaning of the term mareh, "vision," which occurs in the passage: "In a vision (be-mareh) do I make myself known unto him" (Num. xii. 6). The term signifies that which is also called mareh ha-nebuah, "prophetic vision," yad ha-shem, "the hand of God," and maḥazeh, "a vision." It is something terrible and fearful which the prophet feels while awake, as is distinctly stated by Daniel: "And I saw this great vision, and there remained no strength in me, for my comeliness was turned in me into corruption, and I retained no strength" (Dan, x. 8). He afterwards continues, "Thus was I in deep sleep on my face, and my face toward the ground" (ibid. ver. 9). But it was in a prophetic vision that the angel spoke to him and "set him upon his knees." Under such circumstances the senses cease to act, and the [Active Intellect] influences the rational faculties, and through them the imaginative faculties, which become perfect and active. Sometimes the prophecy begins with a prophetic vision, the prophet greatly trembles, and is much affected in consequence of the perfect action of the imaginative faculty: and after that the prophecy follows. This was the case with Abraham. The commencement of the prophecy is, "The word of the Lord came to Abraham in a vision" (Gen. xv. 1); after this, "a deep sleep fell upon Abraham"; and at last, "he said unto Abraham," etc. When prophets speak of the fact that they received a prophecy, they say that they received it from an angel, or from God; but even in the latter case it was likewise received through an angel. Our Sages, therefore, explain the words, "And the Lord said unto her" that He spake through an angel. You must know that whenever Scripture relates that the Lord or an angel spoke to a person, this took place in a dream or in a prophetic vision.

There are four different ways in which Scripture relates the fact that a divine communication was made to the prophet. (1) The prophet relates that he heard the words of an angel in a dream or vision; (2) He reports the words of the angel without mentioning that they were perceived in a dream or vision, assuming that it is well known that prophecy can only originate in one of the two ways, "In a vision I will make myself known unto him, in a dream I will speak unto him" (Num. xii. 6). (3) The prophet does not mention the angel at all; he says that God spoke to him, but he states that he received the message in a dream or a vision.

(4) He introduces his prophecy by stating that God spoke to him, or told him to do a certain thing, or speak certain words, but he does not explain that he received the message in a dream or vision, because he assumes that it is well known, and has been established as a principle that no prophecy or revelation originates otherwise than in a dream or vision, and through an angel. Instances of the first form are the following:--"And the angel of the Lord said unto me in a dream, Jacob" (Gen. xxxi. 11); "And an angel said unto Israel in a vision of night" (ibid. xlvi. 2); "And an angel came to Balaam by night"; "And an angel said unto Balaam" (Num. xxii. 20-72). Instances of the second form are these: "And Elohim (an angel), said unto Jacob, Rise, go up to Bethel" (Gen. xxxv.

1); "And Elohim said unto him, Thy name is Jacob," etc. (ibid. xxxv. 10); "And an angel of the Lord called unto Abraham out of heaven the second time" (ibid. xxii. 15); "And Elohim said unto Noah" (ibid. vi. 13). The following is an instance of the third form: "The word of the Lord came unto Abraham in a vision" (ibid. xv. 1). Instances of the fourth form are: "And the Lord said unto Abraham" (ibid. xviii. 13); "And the Lord said unto Jacob, Return," etc. (ibid. xxxi. 3); "And the Lord said unto Joshua" (Josh. v. 9); "And the Lord said unto Gideon" (Judges vii. 2). Most of the prophets speak in a similar manner: "And the Lord said unto me" (Deut. ii. 2); "And the word of the Lord came unto me"

(Ezek. xxx. 1); "And the word of the Lord came" (2 Sam. xxiv. 11); "And behold, the word of the Lord came unto him" (1 Kings xix. 9); "And the word of the Lord came expressly" (Ezek. i. 3); "The beginning of the word of the Lord by Hosea" (Hos. i. 2); "The hand of the Lord was upon me" (Ezek. xxxvii. 1). There are a great many instances of this class.

Every passage in Scripture introduced by any of these four forms is a prophecy proclaimed by a prophet; but the phrase, "And Elohim (an angel) came to a certain person in the dream of night," does not indicate a prophecy, and the person mentioned in that phrase is not a prophet; the phrase only informs us that the attention of the person was called by God to a certain thing, and at the same time that this happened at night. For just as God may cause a person to move in order to save or kill another person, so He may cause, according to His will, certain things to rise in man's mind in a dream by night.

We have no doubt that the Syrian Laban was a perfectly wicked man, and an idolater; likewise Abimelech, though a good man among his people, is told by Abraham concerning his land [Gerar] and his kingdom, "Surely there is no fear of God in this place" (Gen. xx. 11). And yet concerning both of them, viz., Laban and Abimelech, it is said [that an angel appeared to them in a dream]. Comp. "And Elohim (an angel) came to Abimelech in a dream by night" (ibid. ver. 3); and also, "And Elohim came to the Syrian Laban in the dream of the night" (ibid. xxxi. 24).

Note and consider the distinction between the phrases, "And Elohim came," and "Elohim said," between "in a dream by night," and "in a vision by night." In reference to Jacob it is said, "And an angel said to Israel in the visions by night" (Gen. xlvi. 2), but in reference to Laban and Abimelech, "And Elohim came," etc. Onkelos makes the distinction clear; he translates, in the last two instances, ata memar min kodam adonai, "a word came from the Lord," and not ve-itgeli, "and the Lord appeared." The phrase, "And the Lord said to a certain person," is employed even when this person was not really addressed by the Lord, and did not receive any prophecy, but was informed of a certain thing through a prophet. E.g., "And she went to inquire of the Lord" (Gen. xxv.

22); that is, according to the explanation of our Sages, she went to the college of Eber, and the latter gave her the answer; and this is expressed by the words, "And the Lord said unto her" (ibid. ver. 23). These words have also been explained thus, God spoke to her through an angel; and by "angel" Eber is meant here, for a prophet is sometimes called "angel," as will be explained; or the angel that appeared to Eber in this vision is referred to, or the object of the Midrash explanation is merely to express that wherever God is introduced as directly speaking to a person, i.e., to any of the ordinary prophets, He speaks through an angel, as has been set forth by us (chap. xxxiv.).

Up next

Part 2: Chapter XLII

CHAPTER XLII WE have already shown that the appearance or speech of an angel mentioned in Scripture took place in a vision or dream; it makes no difference whether this is expressly stated or not, as we have explained above.

About 5 min to read

Take your library with you

Listen to this chapter

Opens this chapter in the app. Tap Listen to begin. Narration requires membership.

Scan to open this chapter
Continue to the next chapter

Open the next chapter in the app. Reading is free.

Scan to open the next chapter

Every book is free to read. Downloading the app may not keep this chapter link; return here to open it after installing.

Contents

Guide for the Perplexed · Moses Maimonides

194 chapters

  1. 01Preface1 min
  2. 02Preface to Volume One of the First Edition1 min
  3. 03The Life of Moses Maimonides29 min
  4. 04The Moreh Nebuchim Literature30 min
  5. 05Analysis of the Guide for the Perplexed60 min
  6. 06Introduction2 min
  7. 07Prefatory Remarks19 min
  8. 08Directions for the Study of this Work4 min
  9. 09Introductory Remarks on Method6 min
  10. 10Part 1: Chapter I5 min
  11. 11Part 1: Chapter II6 min
  12. 12Part 1: Chapter III2 min
  13. 13Part 1: Chapter IV3 min
  14. 14Part 1: Chapter V4 min
  15. 15Part 1: Chapter VI1 min
  16. 16Part 1: Chapter VII3 min
  17. 17Part 1: Chapter VIII2 min
  18. 18Part 1: Chapter IX2 min
  19. 19Part 1: Chapter X4 min
  20. 20Part 1: Chapter XI3 min
  21. 21Part 1: Chapter XII2 min
  22. 22Part 1: Chapter XIII2 min
  23. 23Part 1: Chapter XIV1 min
  24. 24Part 1: Chapter XV2 min
  25. 25Part 1: Chapter XVI2 min
  26. 26Part 1: Chapter XVII2 min
  27. 27Part 1: Chapter XVIII4 min
  28. 28Part 1: Chapter XIX2 min
  29. 29Part 1: Chapter XX2 min
  30. 30Part 1: Chapter XXI6 min
  31. 31Part 1: Chapter XXII2 min
  32. 32Part 1: Chapter XXIII3 min
  33. 33Part 1: Chapter XXIV2 min
  34. 34Part 1: Chapter XXV2 min
  35. 35Part 1: Chapter XXVI3 min
  36. 36Part 1: Chapter XXVII4 min
  37. 37Part 1: Chapter XXVIII5 min
  38. 38Part 1: Chapter XXIX2 min
  39. 39Part 1: Chapter XXX3 min
  40. 40Part 1: Chapter XXXI4 min
  41. 41Part 1: Chapter XXXII5 min
  42. 42Part 1: Chapter XXXIII3 min
  43. 43Part 1: Chapter XXXIV12 min
  44. 44Part 1: Chapter XXXV4 min
  45. 45Part 1: Chapter XXXVI6 min
  46. 46Part 1: Chapter XXXVII4 min
  47. 47Part 1: Chapter XXXVIII1 min
  48. 48Part 1: Chapter XXXIX3 min
  49. 49Part 1: Chapter XL2 min
  50. 50Part 1: Chapter XLI3 min
  51. 51Part 1: Chapter XLII2 min
  52. 52Part 1: Chapter XLIII2 min
  53. 53Part 1: Chapter XLIV1 min
  54. 54Part 1: Chapter XLV2 min
  55. 55Part 1: Chapter XLVI12 min
  56. 56Part 1: Chapter XLVII3 min
  57. 57Part 1: Chapter XLVIII4 min
  58. 58Part 1: Chapter XLIX5 min
  59. 59Part 1: Chapter L3 min
  60. 60Part 1: Chapter LI4 min