Guide for the Perplexed

Guide for the Perplexed · Moses Maimonides

Part 3: Chapter XL

Translated by M. Friedlander (1904) · 181 of 194

CHAPTER XL THE precepts of the fifth class, enumerated in the Section--"On Damages" (Sepher neziḳin), aim at the removal of wrong and the prevention of injury. As we are strongly recommended to prevent damage, we are responsible for every damage caused by our property or through our work in so far as it is in our power to take care and to guard it from becoming injurious. We are, therefore, responsible for all damage caused by our cattle; we must guard them. The same is the case with fire and pits; they are made by man, and he can be careful that they do not cause damage. I will point out the equity of the various laws in this respect.

No compensation is enforced for damage caused by the mouth or the foot of an animal in a public thoroughfare; because this cannot be guarded against, and the damage caused there is not very large. Those who place their things in a public place are themselves guilty of neglect, and expose their property to injury. But compensation is given for damage caused to the property of a person in his own field by the tooth or the foot of an animal. It is different in the case of damage caused by the horn of animals or the like. The animal can be guarded everywhere land prevented from causing injury], whilst those who pass public thoroughfares cannot sufficiently take care against accidents of this kind.

In this case the law is the same for all places: but there is a difference whether the owner of the animal has been warned concerning it or not (mu‘ad or tam). If the animal has not been in the habit of causing damage, the owner need only pay half the damage; but damage caused by an animal which has been in the habit of doing so, and has been known as savage, must be paid in full. The compensation for a slave is uniformly estimated at half the value fixed for a free man. For in the law concerning the valuation of man you find the highest valuation at sixty shekels, whilst the money to be paid for a slave is fixed at thirty shekels silver. The killing of an animal that has killed a human being (Exod. xxi.

28, 29) is not a punishment to the animal, as the dissenters insinuate against us, but it is a fine imposed on the owner of that animal. For the same reason the use of its flesh is prohibited. The owner of an animal will, therefore, take the greatest possible care in guarding it; he will know that if any person is killed by the animal, whether that person be grown up or young, free or in bondage, he forfeits at least the animal; and in case he has already received a warning concerning it, he will have to pay a ransom in addition to the loss of the animal. This is also the reason why a beast is killed that has been used by a human being for an immoral purpose (Lev. xx.

15, 16); its owner will be more careful as regards his beast, will guard it, and never lose sight of it, just as he watches his household: for people fear the loss of their property as much as that of their own life: some even more, but most people hold both in the same estimation. Comp. "and to take us for bondmen, and our asses" (Gen. xliii. 18).

This class includes also the duty of killing him who pursues another person; that is to say, if a person is about to commit a crime we may prevent it by killing him. Only in two cases is this permitted; viz., when a person runs after another in order to murder him, or in order to commit fornication: because in these two cases the crime, once committed; cannot be remedied. In the case of other sins, punished with death by the court of law, such as idolatry and profanation of the Sabbath, by which the sinner does no harm to another person, and which concern only his own principles, no person may be killed for the mere intention, if he has not carried it out.

It is known that desire is denounced because it leads to coveting, and the latter is prohibited because it leads to robbery, as has been said by our Sages.

The object of the law of restoring lost property to its owner (Deut. xxii. 1-3) is obvious. In the first instance, it is in itself a good feature in man's character. Secondly, its benefit is mutual; for if a person does not return the lost property of his fellow-man, nobody will restore to him what he may lose, just as those who do not honour their parents cannot expect to be honoured by their children.

A person who killed another person unknowingly must go into exile (Exod. xii. 13: Num. xxxv. 11-28); because the anger of "the avenger of the blood" (Num. xxxv. 19) cools down while the cause of the mischief is out of sight. The chance of returning from the exile depends on the death of [the high-priest], the most honoured of men, and the friend of all Israel. By his death the relative of the slain person becomes reconciled (ibid. ver. 25); for it is a natural phenomenon that we find consolation in our misfortune when the same misfortune or a greater one has befallen another person. Amongst us no death causes more grief than that of the high-priest.

The beneficial character of the law concerning "the breaking of the neck of a heifer" (Deut. xii. 1-8) is evident. For it is the city that is nearest to the slain person that brings the heifer, and in most cases the murderer comes from that place. The elders of the place call upon God as their witness, according to the interpretation of our Sages, that they have always kept the roads in good condition, have protected them, and have directed every one that asked his way; that the person has not been killed because they were careless in these general provisions, and they do not know who has slain him.

As a rule the investigation, the procession of the elders, the measuring, and the taking of the heifer, make people talk about it, and by making the event public, the murderer may be found out, and he who knows of him, or has heard of him, or has discovered him by any due, will now name the person that is the murderer, and as soon as a man, or even a woman or handmaid, rises up and names a certain person as having committed the murder, the heifer is not killed. It is well known that it is considered great wickedness and guilt on the part of a person who knows the murderer, and is silent about him whilst the elders call upon God as witness that they know nothing about the murderer. Even a woman will, therefore, communicate whatever knowledge she has of him.

When the murderer is discovered, the benefit of the law is apparent. If the court of justice cannot sentence him to death, the king may find him guilty, who has the power to sentence to death on circumstantial evidence; and if the ling does not put him to death, the avenger of blood may scheme and plan his death, and at last kill him. We have thus shown the use of the law concerning the breaking of the neck of the heifer in discovering the murderer. Force is added to the law by the rule that the place in which the neck of the heifer is broken should never be cultivated or sown. The owner of the land will therefore use all means in his power to search and to find the murderer, in order that the heifer be not killed and his land be not made useless to him.

Up next

Part 3: Chapter XLI

CHAPTER XLI THE precepts of the sixth class comprise the different ways of punishing the sinner.

About 19 min to read

Take your library with you

Listen to this chapter

Opens this chapter in the app. Tap Listen to begin. Narration requires membership.

Scan to open this chapter
Continue to the next chapter

Open the next chapter in the app. Reading is free.

Scan to open the next chapter

Every book is free to read. Downloading the app may not keep this chapter link; return here to open it after installing.

Contents

Guide for the Perplexed · Moses Maimonides

194 chapters

  1. 01Preface1 min
  2. 02Preface to Volume One of the First Edition1 min
  3. 03The Life of Moses Maimonides29 min
  4. 04The Moreh Nebuchim Literature30 min
  5. 05Analysis of the Guide for the Perplexed60 min
  6. 06Introduction2 min
  7. 07Prefatory Remarks19 min
  8. 08Directions for the Study of this Work4 min
  9. 09Introductory Remarks on Method6 min
  10. 10Part 1: Chapter I5 min
  11. 11Part 1: Chapter II6 min
  12. 12Part 1: Chapter III2 min
  13. 13Part 1: Chapter IV3 min
  14. 14Part 1: Chapter V4 min
  15. 15Part 1: Chapter VI1 min
  16. 16Part 1: Chapter VII3 min
  17. 17Part 1: Chapter VIII2 min
  18. 18Part 1: Chapter IX2 min
  19. 19Part 1: Chapter X4 min
  20. 20Part 1: Chapter XI3 min
  21. 21Part 1: Chapter XII2 min
  22. 22Part 1: Chapter XIII2 min
  23. 23Part 1: Chapter XIV1 min
  24. 24Part 1: Chapter XV2 min
  25. 25Part 1: Chapter XVI2 min
  26. 26Part 1: Chapter XVII2 min
  27. 27Part 1: Chapter XVIII4 min
  28. 28Part 1: Chapter XIX2 min
  29. 29Part 1: Chapter XX2 min
  30. 30Part 1: Chapter XXI6 min
  31. 31Part 1: Chapter XXII2 min
  32. 32Part 1: Chapter XXIII3 min
  33. 33Part 1: Chapter XXIV2 min
  34. 34Part 1: Chapter XXV2 min
  35. 35Part 1: Chapter XXVI3 min
  36. 36Part 1: Chapter XXVII4 min
  37. 37Part 1: Chapter XXVIII5 min
  38. 38Part 1: Chapter XXIX2 min
  39. 39Part 1: Chapter XXX3 min
  40. 40Part 1: Chapter XXXI4 min
  41. 41Part 1: Chapter XXXII5 min
  42. 42Part 1: Chapter XXXIII3 min
  43. 43Part 1: Chapter XXXIV12 min
  44. 44Part 1: Chapter XXXV4 min
  45. 45Part 1: Chapter XXXVI6 min
  46. 46Part 1: Chapter XXXVII4 min
  47. 47Part 1: Chapter XXXVIII1 min
  48. 48Part 1: Chapter XXXIX3 min
  49. 49Part 1: Chapter XL2 min
  50. 50Part 1: Chapter XLI3 min
  51. 51Part 1: Chapter XLII2 min
  52. 52Part 1: Chapter XLIII2 min
  53. 53Part 1: Chapter XLIV1 min
  54. 54Part 1: Chapter XLV2 min
  55. 55Part 1: Chapter XLVI12 min
  56. 56Part 1: Chapter XLVII3 min
  57. 57Part 1: Chapter XLVIII4 min
  58. 58Part 1: Chapter XLIX5 min
  59. 59Part 1: Chapter L3 min
  60. 60Part 1: Chapter LI4 min