Guide for the Perplexed

Guide for the Perplexed · Moses Maimonides

Part 1: Chapter LVI

Translated by M. Friedlander (1904) · 65 of 194

CHAPTER LVI SIMILARITY is based on a certain relation between two things: if between two things no relation can be found, there can be no similarity between them, and there is no relation between two things that have no similarity to each other; e.g., we do not say this heat is similar to that colour, or this voice is similar to that sweetness. This is self-evident. Since the existence of a relation between God and man, or between Him and other beings has been denied, similarity must likewise be denied.

You must know that two things of the same kind--i.e., whose essential properties are the same, and which are distinguished from each other by greatness and smallness, strength and weakness, etc.--are necessarily similar, though different in this one way; e.g., a grain of mustard and the sphere of the fixed stars are similar as regards the three dimensions, although the one is exceedingly great, the other exceedingly small, the property of having [three] dimensions is the same in both: or the heat of wax melted by the sun and the heat of the element of fire, are similar as regards heat: although the heat is exceedingly great in the one case, and exceedingly small in the other, the existence of that quality (heat) is the same in both.

Thus those who believe in the presence of essential attributes in God, viz., Existence, Life, Power, Wisdom, and Will, should know that these attributes, when applied to God, have not the same meaning as when applied to us, and that the difference does not only consist in magnitude, or in the degree of perfection, stability, and durability. It cannot be said, as they practically believe, that His existence is only more stable, His life more permanent, His power greater, His wisdom more perfect, and His will more general than ours, and that the same definition applies to both.

This is in no way admissible, for the expression "more than" is used in comparing two things as regards a certain attribute predicated of both of them in exactly the same sense, and consequently implies similarity [between God and His creatures]. When they ascribe to God essential attributes, these so-called essential attributes should not have any similarity to the attributes of other things, and should according to their own opinion not be included in one of the same definition, just as there is no similarity between the essence of God and that of other beings. They do not follow this principle, for they hold that one definition may include them, and that, nevertheless, there is no similarity between them.

Those who are familiar with the meaning of similarity will certainly understand that the term existence, when applied to God and to other beings, is perfectly homonymous. In like manner, the terms Wisdom, Power, Will, and Life are applied to God and to other beings by way of perfect homonymity, admitting of no comparison whatever. Nor must you think that these attributes are employed as hybrid terms; for hybrid terms are such as are applied to two things which have a similarity to each other in respect to a certain property which is in both of them an accident, not an essential, constituent element. The attributes of God, however, are not considered as accidental by any intelligent person, while all attributes applied to man are accidents, according to the Mutakallemim. I am therefore at a loss to see how they can find any similarity [between the attributes of God and those of man]; how their definitions can be identical, and their significations the same! This is a decisive proof that there is, in no way or sense, anything common to the attributes predicated of God, and those used in reference to ourselves: they have only the same names, and nothing else is common to them. Such being the case, it is not proper to believe, on account of the use of the same attributes, that there is in God something additional to His essence, in the same way as attributes are joined to our essence. This is most important for those who understand it. Keep it in memory, and study it thoroughly in order to be well prepared for that which I am going to explain to you.

Up next

Part 1: Chapter LVII

CHAPTER LVII ON attributes; remarks more recondite than the preceding. It is known that existence is an accident appertaining to all things, and therefore an element superadded to their essence.

About 4 min to read

Take your library with you

Listen to this chapter

Opens this chapter in the app. Tap Listen to begin. Narration requires membership.

Scan to open this chapter
Continue to the next chapter

Open the next chapter in the app. Reading is free.

Scan to open the next chapter

Every book is free to read. Downloading the app may not keep this chapter link; return here to open it after installing.

Contents

Guide for the Perplexed · Moses Maimonides

194 chapters

  1. 01Preface1 min
  2. 02Preface to Volume One of the First Edition1 min
  3. 03The Life of Moses Maimonides29 min
  4. 04The Moreh Nebuchim Literature30 min
  5. 05Analysis of the Guide for the Perplexed60 min
  6. 06Introduction2 min
  7. 07Prefatory Remarks19 min
  8. 08Directions for the Study of this Work4 min
  9. 09Introductory Remarks on Method6 min
  10. 10Part 1: Chapter I5 min
  11. 11Part 1: Chapter II6 min
  12. 12Part 1: Chapter III2 min
  13. 13Part 1: Chapter IV3 min
  14. 14Part 1: Chapter V4 min
  15. 15Part 1: Chapter VI1 min
  16. 16Part 1: Chapter VII3 min
  17. 17Part 1: Chapter VIII2 min
  18. 18Part 1: Chapter IX2 min
  19. 19Part 1: Chapter X4 min
  20. 20Part 1: Chapter XI3 min
  21. 21Part 1: Chapter XII2 min
  22. 22Part 1: Chapter XIII2 min
  23. 23Part 1: Chapter XIV1 min
  24. 24Part 1: Chapter XV2 min
  25. 25Part 1: Chapter XVI2 min
  26. 26Part 1: Chapter XVII2 min
  27. 27Part 1: Chapter XVIII4 min
  28. 28Part 1: Chapter XIX2 min
  29. 29Part 1: Chapter XX2 min
  30. 30Part 1: Chapter XXI6 min
  31. 31Part 1: Chapter XXII2 min
  32. 32Part 1: Chapter XXIII3 min
  33. 33Part 1: Chapter XXIV2 min
  34. 34Part 1: Chapter XXV2 min
  35. 35Part 1: Chapter XXVI3 min
  36. 36Part 1: Chapter XXVII4 min
  37. 37Part 1: Chapter XXVIII5 min
  38. 38Part 1: Chapter XXIX2 min
  39. 39Part 1: Chapter XXX3 min
  40. 40Part 1: Chapter XXXI4 min
  41. 41Part 1: Chapter XXXII5 min
  42. 42Part 1: Chapter XXXIII3 min
  43. 43Part 1: Chapter XXXIV12 min
  44. 44Part 1: Chapter XXXV4 min
  45. 45Part 1: Chapter XXXVI6 min
  46. 46Part 1: Chapter XXXVII4 min
  47. 47Part 1: Chapter XXXVIII1 min
  48. 48Part 1: Chapter XXXIX3 min
  49. 49Part 1: Chapter XL2 min
  50. 50Part 1: Chapter XLI3 min
  51. 51Part 1: Chapter XLII2 min
  52. 52Part 1: Chapter XLIII2 min
  53. 53Part 1: Chapter XLIV1 min
  54. 54Part 1: Chapter XLV2 min
  55. 55Part 1: Chapter XLVI12 min
  56. 56Part 1: Chapter XLVII3 min
  57. 57Part 1: Chapter XLVIII4 min
  58. 58Part 1: Chapter XLIX5 min
  59. 59Part 1: Chapter L3 min
  60. 60Part 1: Chapter LI4 min