Nicomachean Ethics

Nicomachean Ethics · Aristotle

Book VIII: Chapter 7.

Translated by W.D. Ross (1908) · 88 of 116

Chapter 7. In unequal friendships a proportion must be maintained. But there is another kind of friendship, viz. that which involves an inequality between the parties, e.g. that of father to son and in general of elder to younger, that of man to wife and in general that of ruler to subject. And these friendships differ also from each other; for it is not the same that exists between parents and children and between rulers and subjects, nor is even that of father to son the same as that of son to father, nor that of husband to wife the same as that of wife to husband. For the virtue and the function of each of these is different, and so are the reasons for which they love; the love and the friendship are therefore different also. Each party, then, neither gets the same from the other, nor ought to seek it; but when children render to parents what they ought to render to those who brought them into the world, and parents render what they should to their children, the friendship of such persons will be abiding and excellent. In all friendships implying inequality the love also should be proportional, i.e. the better should be more loved than he loves, and so should the more useful, and similarly in each of the other cases; for when the love is in proportion to the merit of the parties, then in a sense arises equality, which is certainly held to be characteristic of friendship.

But equality does not seem to take the same form in acts of justice and in friendship; for in acts of justice what is equal in the primary sense is that which is in proportion to merit, while quantitative equality is secondary, but in friendship quantitative equality is primary and proportion to merit secondary. This becomes clear if there is a great interval in respect of virtue or vice or wealth or anything else between the parties; for then they are no longer friends, and do not even expect to be so. And this is most manifest in the case of the gods; for they surpass us most decisively in all good things.

But it is clear also in the case of kings; for with them, too, men who are much their inferiors do not expect to be friends; nor do men of no account expect to be friends with the best or wisest men. In such cases it is not possible to define exactly up to what point friends can remain friends; for much can be taken away and friendship remain, but when one party is removed to a great distance, as God is, the possibility of friendship ceases. This is in fact the origin of the question whether friends really wish for their friends the greatest goods, e.g. that of being gods; since in that case their friends will no longer be friends to them, and therefore will not be good things for them (for friends are good things).

The answer is that if we were right in saying that friend wishes good to friend for his sake, his friend must remain the sort of being he is, whatever that may be; therefore it is for him oily so long as he remains a man that he will wish the greatest goods. But perhaps not all the greatest goods; for it is for himself most of all that each man wishes what is good.

Up next

Book VIII: Chapter 8.

Chapter 8. Loving is more of the essence of friendship than being loved.

About 3 min to read

Take your library with you

Listen to this chapter

Opens this chapter in the app. Tap Listen to begin. Narration requires membership.

Scan to open this chapter
Continue to the next chapter

Open the next chapter in the app. Reading is free.

Scan to open the next chapter

Every book is free to read. Downloading the app may not keep this chapter link; return here to open it after installing.

Contents

Nicomachean Ethics · Aristotle

116 chapters

  1. 01Book I: The Good for Man2 min
  2. 02Book I: Chapter 2.2 min
  3. 03Book I: Chapter 3.2 min
  4. 04Book I: Chapter 4.3 min
  5. 05Book I: Chapter 5.2 min
  6. 06Book I: Chapter 6.5 min
  7. 07Book I: Chapter 7.7 min
  8. 08Book I: Chapter 8.4 min
  9. 09Book I: Chapter 9.3 min
  10. 10Book I: Chapter 10.5 min
  11. 11Book I: Chapter 11.2 min
  12. 12Book I: Chapter 12.2 min
  13. 13Book I: Chapter 13.5 min
  14. 14Book II: Moral Virtue3 min
  15. 15Book II: Chapter 2.3 min
  16. 16Book II: Chapter 3.3 min
  17. 17Book II: Chapter 4.3 min
  18. 18Book II: Chapter 5.2 min
  19. 19Book II: Chapter 6.5 min
  20. 20Book II: Chapter 7.5 min
  21. 21Book II: Chapter 8.3 min
  22. 22Book II: Chapter 9.3 min
  23. 23Book III: Moral Virtue8 min
  24. 24Book III: Chapter 2.4 min
  25. 25Book III: Chapter 3.5 min
  26. 26Book III: Chapter 4.2 min
  27. 27Book III: Chapter 5.7 min
  28. 28Book III: Chapter 6.3 min
  29. 29Book III: Chapter 7.4 min
  30. 30Book III: Chapter 8.5 min
  31. 31Book III: Chapter 9.2 min
  32. 32Book III: Chapter 10.4 min
  33. 33Book III: Chapter 11.3 min
  34. 34Book III: Chapter 12.3 min
  35. 35Book IV: Moral Virtue11 min
  36. 36Book IV: Chapter 2.6 min
  37. 37Book IV: Chapter 3.9 min
  38. 38Book IV: Chapter 4.2 min
  39. 39Book IV: Chapter 5.4 min
  40. 40Book IV: Chapter 6.3 min
  41. 41Book IV: Chapter 7.4 min
  42. 42Book IV: Chapter 8.3 min
  43. 43Book IV: Chapter 9.2 min
  44. 44Book V: Moral Virtue5 min
  45. 45Book V: Chapter 2.4 min
  46. 46Book V: Chapter 3.4 min
  47. 47Book V: Chapter 4.4 min
  48. 48Book V: Chapter 5.6 min
  49. 49Book V: Chapter 6.3 min
  50. 50Book V: Chapter 7.3 min
  51. 51Book V: Chapter 8.4 min
  52. 52Book V: Chapter 9.6 min
  53. 53Book V: Chapter 10.3 min
  54. 54Book V: Chapter 11.4 min
  55. 55Book VI: Intellectual Virtue3 min
  56. 56Book VI: Chapter 2.2 min
  57. 57Book VI: Chapter 3.2 min
  58. 58Book VI: Chapter 4.2 min
  59. 59Book VI: Chapter 5.3 min
  60. 60Book VI: Chapter 6.1 min