Hilton's Scale of Perfection and Rolle's Fire of Love

Hilton's Scale of Perfection and Rolle's Fire of Love · Walter Hilton and Richard Rolle

Rolle: Book I, Chapter XXI: That Contemplative Life is Worthier and Meedfuller Than Active: and of Both Prelacy and Preaching

Translated by Various: Hilton modernised by Dom Serenus Cressy (1659); Rolle by Richard Misyn (1435) · 82 of 117

THAT CONTEMPLATIVE LIFE IS WORTHIER AND MEEDFULLER THAN ACTIVE: AND OF BOTH PRELACY AND PREACHING

By some truly it is doubted which life is more meedful and better; contemplative or active. It seems to not a few that active is meedfuller because of the many deeds and preachings that it uses. But these err unknowingly, for they know not the virtue of contemplative. Yet there are many active better than some contemplative; but the best contemplative are higher than the best active.

Therefore we say the contemplative life is altogether the better, the sweeter, the more worthy, and the more meedful as to the true meed, that is joy of the unwrought good, because the contemplative more burningly loves God. And more grace is asked if contemplative life be led rightly, than active.

The reason of more fervent love in contemplative life than in active is because in contemplative they are in rest of mind and body, and therefore they taste the sweetness of eternal, before all mortal love. The active truly serve God in labour and outward running about, and tarry but little in inward rest, wherefore they can not be delighted save seldom and shortly; the contemplative soothly love as if they were continually within the halsing of their Beloved.

Forsooth some gainsetting say: active life is more fruitful; for it does works of mercy, it preaches and works other such deeds; wherefore it is more meritorious. I say, nay, for such works belong to accidental reward, that is, joy of the thing wrought. And so one that shall be taken into the order of angels can have some meed that he that shall be in the order of cherubim or seraphim shall not have; that is to say joy of some good deed that he did in this life, the which another--that without comparison surpasses in God's love--did not. Also ofttimes it happens that some one of less meed is good, and preaches; and another preaches not, that mickle more loves. Is not this one better because he preaches? No; but the one that loves more is higher and better, although he be less in preaching he shall have some meed, because he preached not, that the greater was not worthy of.

Therefore it is shown that man is not holier or higher for the outward works that he does. Truly God that is the Beholder of the heart rewards the will more than on the deeds. For the more burningly that a man loves, in so mickle he ascends to a higher reward.

What God is actually keeping score ofMembership note · Open in the app

Truly, in true contemplative men, there is a full sweet heat and the plenteousness of God's love abiding, from the which a joyful sound is sent into them with untrowed mirth; and this is never found in active men in this life, because they take not heed only to heavenly things, so that they might be worthy to joy in Jesu. And therefore active life is worthily put behind; and contemplative life, in this present and in the life to come is worthily preferred.

Wherefore in the litter of the true Solomon the pillars are of silver and the resting place of gold. The pillars of the chair are the strong upbearers and the good governors of holy kirk; these are of silver, for in conversation they are clear and in preaching full of sound. The gold resting place are contemplative men; on the which, being in high rest, Christ especially rests His Head, and they forsooth in Him singularly rest. These are of gold, for they are purer and dearer in honesty of living, and are redder in burning of loving and contemplating.

God forsooth has forordained His chosen to fulfill divers services. It is not given truly to ilk man to execute or fulfill all offices, but ilk man has that that is most according to his state. Wherefore the Apostle says: Unicuique nostrum data est gracia secundum mensuram donationis Christi; that is to say: To ilk one of us is grace given after the measure of Christ's gift.'

Some truly do alms of righteously gotten goods; others to their death defend the truth; others clearly and strongly preach God's word, and others show their preaching in their writing; others suffer for God great penance and wretchedness in this life; others, by the gift of contemplation, are only busy to God and set themselves straitly to love Christ. But without doubt, among all estates that are in the kirk, they that are become contemplative joy with a special gift; they are now worthy with singing to joy in God's love.

Truly if any man might get both lives, that is to say contemplative and active, and keep and fulfill them, he were full great; that he might fulfill bodily service, and nevertheless feel the heavenly sound in himself, and be melted in singing into the joy of heavenly love. I wot not if ever any mortal man had this. To me it seems impossible that both should be together.

Christ truly in this respect is not to be numbered among men, nor His blest Mother among women. For Christ had no wandering thoughts, and He was not contemplative in a common manner, as saints in this life are contemplative; truly He needed not to labour as we need, because, from the beginning of His Conceiving, He saw God.

Why Christ doesn't fit this comparisonMembership note · Open in the app

No marvel by great exercise of ghostly works there comes into us a songful joy, and we receive the sweetest sound from heaven; and so henceforward we desire to stand in rest, that with great sweetness we may joy. Therefore he that serves active life well is busy to go up to contemplative life.

He who truly is raised in the manner aforesaid with the gift of heavenly contemplation, comes not down to active; unless peradventure he be compelled to take governance of Christians; that I trow has seldom or never happened. But other contemplatives can well be chosen for that, because they are less imbued with heat of love. Forsooth lesser saints are sometimes more able than greater for the office of prelacy, because they that could not rest perfectly in inward desires shall behave themselves more accordingly about outward business.

Up next

Rolle: Book I, Chapter XXII: The Burning of Love Purges Vices and Sins: and of the Tokens of True Friendship

The burning of love truly taken into a soul purges all vices; it voids both too mickle and too little, and plants the beauty of all virtues.

About 3 min to read

Take your library with you

Continue to the next chapter

Open the next chapter in the app. Reading is free.

Scan to open the next chapter

Every book is free to read. Downloading the app may not keep this chapter link; return here to open it after installing.

Contents

Hilton's Scale of Perfection and Rolle's Fire of Love · Walter Hilton and Richard Rolle

117 chapters

  1. 01Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter I: That the inward State of the Soul should be like the outward2 min
  2. 02Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter II: Of the Active Life, and the Exercises and the Works thereof2 min
  3. 03Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter III: Of the Contemplative Life, and the Exercises and Works thereof1 min
  4. 04Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter IV: Of three Sorts that be of Contemplation and of the First of them3 min
  5. 05Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter V: Of the Second Sort of Contemplation2 min
  6. 06Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter VI: Of the Lower Degree of the Second Sort of Contemplation1 min
  7. 07Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter VII: Of the Higher Degree of the Second Sort of Contemplation2 min
  8. 08Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter VIII: Of the Third Sort of Contemplation2 min
  9. 09Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter IX: Of the Difference that is betwixt the Second and Third Sort of Contemplation3 min
  10. 10Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter X: How that Appearings or Shewings to the Corporal Senses or Feelings may be both good and evil2 min
  11. 11Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter XI: How thou shalt know whether the Showing or Apparition to the bodily Senses and Feelings be good or evil5 min
  12. 12Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter XII: How and in what things a Contemplative Man should be busied2 min
  13. 13Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter XIII: How Virtue beginneth in Reason and Will and is perfected in Love and Liking, or Affection2 min
  14. 14Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter XIV: Of the Means that bring a Soul to Contemplation13 min
  15. 15Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter XV: Of a firm and resolute Intent and Purpose necessary hereto3 min
  16. 16Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter XVI: Of a firm Faith necessary thereto, and what things we ought to believe thereby3 min
  17. 17Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter XVIII: A brief Rehearsal of what hath been said, and of an Offering31 min
  18. 18Hilton: Book I, Part II, Chapter III: That a Man should know the measure of his Gift, that he may3 min
  19. 19Hilton: Book I, Part III, Chapter I: Of the Knowledge of a Man's Soul and the Powers thereof necessary3 min
  20. 20Hilton: Book I, Part III, Chapter II: Of the Worthiness and Excellency of the Soul and how it was lost60 min
  21. 21Hilton: Book I, Part III, Chapter VII: Of Covetousness and how a Man may know how much of it is hid in his Heart18 min
  22. 22Hilton: Book I, Part III, Chapter IX: Of the Five Windows of this dark Image, and what cometh in by them, and how they are to be ordered9 min
  23. 23Hilton: Book I, Part III, Chapter X: Of another Hole or Window that is to be stopped as well as the Windows of the Senses, namely, the Imagination2 min
  24. 24Hilton: Book I, Part III, Chapter XI: A Brief Rehearsal of what hath been said in the former Chapters,3 min
  25. 25Hilton: Book I, Part III, Chapter XII: A comparing of this Image with the Image of Jesus, and how it9 min
  26. 26Hilton: Book I, Part III, Chapter XIII: How a Man shall be shapen to the Image of Jesus, and Jesus2 min
  27. 27Hilton: Book I, Part III, Chapter XIV: The Conclusion of this Book, and of the Cause why it was made,12 min
  28. 28Hilton: Book II, Part I, Chapter II: Of two Manners of reforming of this Image, one in fulness,4 min
  29. 29Hilton: Book II, Part I, Chapter III: That Reforming in part is in two manners, one in Faith, another2 min
  30. 30Hilton: Book II, Part I, Chapter IV: That through the Sacrament of Baptism (which is grounded in the Passion of Christ) this Image is reformed from Original Sin2 min
  31. 31Hilton: Book II, Part I, Chapter V: That through the Sacrament of Penance (that consisteth in8 min
  32. 32Hilton: Book II, Part I, Chapter VI: That we are to believe stedfastly the reforming of this Image,2 min
  33. 33Hilton: Book II, Part I, Chapter VII: That all the Souls that live humbly in the Faith of Holy5 min
  34. 34Hilton: Book II, Part I, Chapter VIII: That Souls reformed need ever to fight and strive against the8 min
  35. 35Hilton: Book II, Part I, Chapter IX: That this Image is both fair and foul whilst it is in this Life5 min
  36. 36Hilton: Book II, Part I, Chapter X: Of three sorts of Men, whereof some be not reformed, and some be reformed only in Faith, and some both in Faith and Feeling3 min
  37. 37Hilton: Book II, Part I, Chapter XI: How Men that abide and live in Sin, misshape themselves into the12 min
  38. 38Hilton: Book II, Part II, Chapter I: OF REFORMING IN FAITH AND FEELING ALSO: That this Reforming17 min
  39. 39Hilton: Book II, Part II, Chapter III: An Entry or good Beginning of a Spiritual Journey, showing how9 min
  40. 40Hilton: Book II, Part II, Chapter IV: Of certain Temptations and Lettings which Souls feel from their8 min
  41. 41Hilton: Book II, Part II, Chapter V: Of an evil Day and a good Night, and what they mean, and how the10 min
  42. 42Hilton: Book II, Part II, Chapter VI: How that the Desire of Jesus felt in this lightsome Darkness4 min
  43. 43Hilton: Book II, Part II, Chapter VII: How a Man shall know false Illuminations that are feigned by7 min
  44. 44Hilton: Book II, Part II, Chapter VIII: How great profit it is to the Soul to be brought through Grace11 min
  45. 45Hilton: Book II, Part II, Chapter IX: That the Working of our Lord Jesus in the Reforming of a Soul,5 min
  46. 46Hilton: Book II, Part II, Chapter X: How it falleth out sometimes that Souls that are but beginning or6 min
  47. 47Hilton: Book II, Part II, Chapter XI: After what manner a Man shall come to know his own Soul, and how11 min
  48. 48Hilton: Book II, Part III, Chapter I: In what Sense this Manner of Speaking of Reforming of a Soul in4 min
  49. 49Hilton: Book II, Part III, Chapter II: How God openeth the inward Eye of the Soul to see Him, not all6 min
  50. 50Hilton: Book II, Part III, Chapter III: How Jesus is Heaven to the Soul, and why He is called Fire5 min
  51. 51Hilton: Book II, Part III, Chapter IV: Of two manner of Loves, created and uncreated, and how we are8 min
  52. 52Hilton: Book II, Part III, Chapter V: How that some Souls love Jesus by bodily Fervours, and by their5 min
  53. 53Hilton: Book II, Part III, Chapter VI: That the Gift of Love, amongst all other Gifts of Jesus, is most6 min
  54. 54Hilton: Book II, Part III, Chapter VII: How Love through gracious Beholding of Jesus slayeth all8 min
  55. 55Hilton: Book II, Part III, Chapter VIII: How Love slayeth all stirrings of Wrath and Envy easily; [259]5 min
  56. 56Hilton: Book II, Part III, Chapter IX: How Love slayeth Covetousness, Lechery and Gluttony, and the8 min
  57. 57Hilton: Book II, Part III, Chapter X: What virtues and Graces a Soul receiveth through opening of the11 min
  58. 58Hilton: Book II, Part III, Chapter XI: How such special Grace for the Beholding of our Lord Jesus is10 min
  59. 59Hilton: Book II, Part III, Chapter XII: A Commendation of Prayer offered up to Jesus by a Contemplative9 min
  60. 60Hilton: Book II, Part III, Chapter XIII: How a Soul through the opening of the spiritual Eye receiveth9 min