Vedanta-Sutras Part I

Vedanta-Sutras Part I · Badarayana

Adhyaya II: Pada I: Sutras 22-26

Translated by George Thibaut · 85 of 103

For we know that no free person will build a prison for himself, and take up his abode in it. Nor would a being, itself absolutely stainless, look on this altogether unclean body as forming part of its Self. It would, moreover, free itself, according to its liking, of the consequences of those of its former actions which result in pain, and would enjoy the consequences of those actions only which are rewarded by pleasure. Further, it would remember that it had created this manifold world; for every person who has produced some clearly appearing effect remembers that he has been the cause of it. And as the magician easily retracts, whenever he likes, the magical illusion which he had emitted, so the embodied soul also would be able to reabsorb this world into itself. The fact is, however, that the embodied soul cannot reabsorb its own body even. As we therefore see that 'what would be beneficial is not done,' the hypothesis of the world having proceeded from an intelligent cause is unacceptable.

22. But the separate (Brahman, i.e. the Brahman separate from the individual souls) (is the creator); (the existence of which separate Brahman we learn) from the declaration of difference.

The word 'but' discards the pûrvapaksha.--We rather declare that that omniscient, omnipotent Brahman, whose essence is eternal pure cognition and freedom, and which is additional to, i. e. different from the embodied Self, is the creative principle of the world. The faults specified above, such as doing what is not beneficial, and the like, do not attach to that Brahman; for as eternal freedom is its characteristic nature, there is nothing either beneficial to be done by it or non-beneficial to be avoided by it. Nor is there any impediment to its knowledge and power; for it is omniscient and omnipotent. The embodied Self, on the other hand, is of a different nature, and to it the mentioned faults adhere. But then we do not declare it to be the creator of the world, on account of 'the declaration of difference.' For scriptural passages (such as, 'Verily, the Self is to be seen, to be heard, to be perceived, to be marked,' Bri. Up. II, 4, 5; 'The Self we must search out, we must try to understand,' Kh. Up. VIII, 7, 1; 'Then he becomes united with the True,' Kh. Up. VI, 8, 1; 'This embodied Self mounted by the intelligent Self,' Bri. Up.

When scripture distinguishes two selvesMembership note · Open in the app

IV, 3, 35) declare differences founded on the relations of agent, object, and so on, and thereby show Brahman to be different from the individual soul.--And if it be objected that there are other passages declaratory of non-difference (for instance, 'That art thou'), and that difference and non-difference cannot co-exist because contradictory, we reply that the possibility of the co-existence of the two is shown by the parallel instance of the universal ether and the ether limited by a jar.--Moreover, as soon as, in consequence of the declaration of non-difference contained in such passages as 'that art thou.' the consciousness of non-difference arises in us, the transmigratory state of the individual soul and the creative quality of Brahman vanish at once, the whole phenomenon of plurality, which springs from wrong knowledge, being sublated by perfect knowledge, and what becomes then of the creation and the faults of not doing what is beneficial, and the like?

For that this entire apparent world, in which good and evil actions are done, &c., is a mere illusion, owing to the non-discrimination of (the Self's) limiting adjuncts, viz. a body, and so on, which spring from name and form the presentations of Nescience, and does in reality not exist at all, we have explained more than once. The illusion is analogous to the mistaken notion we entertain as to the dying, being born, being hurt, &c. of ourselves (our Selfs; while in reality the body only dies, is born, &c.).

And with regard to the state in which the appearance of plurality is not yet sublated, it follows from passages declaratory of such difference (as, for instance, 'That we must search for,' &c.) that Brahman is superior to the individual soul; whereby the possibility of faults adhering to it is excluded.

23. And because the case is analogous to that of stones, &c. (the objections raised) cannot be established.

As among minerals, which are all mere modifications of earth, nevertheless great variety is observed, some being precious gems, such as diamonds, lapis lazuli, &c., others, such as crystals and the like, being of medium value, and others again stones only fit to be flung at dogs or crows; and as from seeds which are placed in one and the same ground various plants are seen to spring, such as sandalwood and cucumbers, which show the greatest difference in their leaves, blossoms, fruits, fragrancy, juice, &c.; and as one and the same food produces various effects, such as blood and hair; so the one Brahman also may contain in itself the distinction of the individual Selfs and the highest Self, and may produce various effects. Hence the objections imagined by others (against the doctrine of Brahman being the cause of the world) cannot be maintained.--Further 1 arguments are furnished by the fact of all effect having, as Scripture declares, their origin in speech only, and by the analogous instance of the variety of dream phantoms (while the dreaming person remains one).

Footnotes 346:1 Which arguments, the commentators say, are hinted at by the 'and' of the Sûtra.

24. If you object on the ground of the observation of the employment (of instruments); (we say), No; because as milk (transforms itself, so Brahman does).

Your assertion that the intelligent Brahman alone, without a second, is the cause of the world cannot be maintained, on account of the observation of employment (of instruments). For in ordinary life we see that potters, weavers, and other handicraftsmen produce jars, cloth, and the like, after having put themselves in possession of the means thereto by providing themselves with various implements, such as clay, staffs, wheels, string, &c.; Brahman, on the other hand, you conceive to be without any help; how then can it act as a creator without providing itself with instruments to work with? We therefore maintain that Brahman is not the cause of the world.

This objection is not valid, because causation is possible in consequence of a peculiar constitution of the causal substance, as in the case of milk. Just as milk and water turn into curds and ice respectively, without any extraneous means, so it is in the case of Brahman also. And if you object to this analogy for the reason that milk, in order to turn into curds, does require an extraneous agent, viz. heat, we reply that milk by itself also undergoes a certain amount of definite change, and that its turning is merely accelerated by heat. If milk did not possess that capability of itself, heat could not compel it to turn; for we see that air or ether, for instance, is not compelled by the action of heat to turn into sour milk. By the co-operation of auxiliary means the milk's capability of turning into sour milk is merely completed. The absolutely complete power of Brahman, on the other hand, does not require to be supplemented by any extraneous help. Thus Scripture also declares, 'There is no effect and no instrument known of him, no one is seen like unto him or better; his high power is revealed as manifold, as inherent, acting as force and knowledge' (Sve. Up. VI, 8). Therefore Brahman, although one only, is, owing to its manifold powers, able to transform itself into manifold effects; just as milk is.

25. And (the case of Brahman is) like that of gods and other beings in ordinary experience.

Well, let it be admitted that milk and other non-intelligent things have the power of turning themselves into sour milk, &c. without any extraneous means, since it is thus observed. But we observe, on the other hand, that intelligent agents, as, for instance, potters, proceed to their several work only after having provided themselves with a complete set of instruments. How then can it be supposed that Brahman, which is likewise of an intelligent nature, should proceed without any auxiliary?

We reply, 'Like gods and others.' As gods, fathers, rishis, and other beings of great power, who are all of intelligent nature, are seen to create many and various objects, such as palaces, chariots, &c., without availing themselves of any extraneous means, by their mere intention, which is effective in consequence of those beings' peculiar power--a fact vouchsafed by mantras, arthavâdas, itihâsas, and purânas;--and as the spider emits out of itself the threads of its web; and as the female crane conceives without a male; and as the lotus wanders from one pond to another without any means of conveyance; so the intelligent Brahman also may be assumed to create the world by itself without extraneous means.

Perhaps our opponent will argue against all this in the following style.--The gods and other beings, whom you have quoted as parallel instances, are really of a nature different from that of Brahman. For the material causes operative in the production of palaces and other material things are the bodies of the gods, and not their intelligent Selfs. And the web of the spider is produced from its saliva which, owing to the spider's devouring small insects, acquires a certain degree of consistency. And the female crane conceives from hearing the sound of thunder. And the lotus flower indeed derives from its indwelling intelligent principle the impulse of movement, but is not able actually to move in so far as it is a merely intelligent being 1; it rather wanders from pond to pond by means of its non-intelligent body, just as the creeper climbs up the tree.--Hence all these illustrative examples cannot be applied to the case of Brahman.

To this we reply, that we meant to show merely that the case of Brahman is different from that of potters and similar agents. For while potters, &c., on the one side, and gods, &c., on the other side, possess the common attribute of intelligence, potters require for their work extraneous means (i.e. means lying outside their bodies) and gods do not. Hence Brahman also, although intelligent, is assumed to require no extraneous means. So much only we wanted to show by the parallel instance of the gods, &c. Our intention is to point out that a peculiarly conditioned capability which is observed in some one case (as in that of the potter) is not necessarily to be assumed in all other cases also.

Footnotes 348:1 The right reading appears to be 'svayam eva ketanâ' as found in some MSS. Other MSS. read ketanah.

26. Either the consequence of the entire (Brahman undergoing change) has to be accepted, or else a violation of the texts declaring Brahman to be without parts.

Hitherto we have established so much that Brahman, intelligent, one, without a second, modifying itself without the employment of any extraneous means, is the cause of the world.--Now, another objection is raised for the purpose of throwing additional light on the point under discussion.--The consequence of the Vedânta doctrine, it is said, will be that we must assume the entire Brahman to undergo the change into its effects, because it is not composed of parts. If Brahman, like earth and other matter, consisted of parts, we might assume that a part of it undergoes the change, while the other part remains as it is. But Scripture distinctly declares Brahman to be devoid of parts. Compare, 'He who is without parts, without actions, tranquil, without fault, without taint' (Sve. Up.

Up next

Adhyaya II: Pada I: Sutras 27-31

VI, 19); 'That heavenly person is without body, he is both without and within, not produced' (Mu.

About 9 min to read

Take your library with you

Continue to the next chapter

Open the next chapter in the app. Reading is free.

Scan to open the next chapter

Every book is free to read. Downloading the app may not keep this chapter link; return here to open it after installing.

Contents

Vedanta-Sutras Part I · Badarayana

103 chapters

  1. 01Introduction (Part 1)11 min
  2. 02Introduction (Part 2)11 min
  3. 03Introduction (Part 3)11 min
  4. 04Introduction (Part 4)10 min
  5. 05Introduction (Part 5)11 min
  6. 06Introduction (Part 6)10 min
  7. 07Introduction (Part 7)11 min
  8. 08Introduction (Part 8)10 min
  9. 09Introduction (Part 9)11 min
  10. 10Introduction (Part 10)11 min
  11. 11Introduction (Part 11)11 min
  12. 12Introduction (Part 12)11 min
  13. 13Introduction (Part 13)10 min
  14. 14Introduction (Part 14)11 min
  15. 15Introduction (Part 15)11 min
  16. 16Introduction (Part 16)11 min
  17. 17Introduction (Part 17)11 min
  18. 18Introduction (Part 18)10 min
  19. 19Introduction (Part 19)4 min
  20. 20Adhyaya I: Pada I: Sutra 19 min
  21. 21Adhyaya I: Pada I (Part 2)9 min
  22. 22Adhyaya I: Pada I (Part 3)9 min
  23. 23Adhyaya I: Pada I: Sutra 49 min
  24. 24Adhyaya I: Pada I (Part 5)9 min
  25. 25Adhyaya I: Pada I (Part 6)9 min
  26. 26Adhyaya I: Pada I (Part 7)9 min
  27. 27Adhyaya I: Pada I (Part 8)9 min
  28. 28Adhyaya I: Pada I: Sutra 59 min
  29. 29Adhyaya I: Pada I: Sutra 68 min
  30. 30Adhyaya I: Pada I: Sutras 8-109 min
  31. 31Adhyaya I: Pada I: Sutra 118 min
  32. 32Adhyaya I: Pada I: Sutras 13-199 min
  33. 33Adhyaya I: Pada I (Part 14)9 min
  34. 34Adhyaya I: Pada I: Sutras 20-229 min
  35. 35Adhyaya I: Pada I: Sutra 239 min
  36. 36Adhyaya I: Pada I: Sutra 249 min
  37. 37Adhyaya I: Pada I: Sutras 25-289 min
  38. 38Adhyaya I: Pada I: Sutras 29-318 min
  39. 39Adhyaya I: Pada I (Part 20)7 min
  40. 40Adhyaya I: Pada II: Sutras 2-59 min
  41. 41Adhyaya I: Pada II: Sutras 6-1110 min
  42. 42Adhyaya I: Pada II: Sutra 1210 min
  43. 43Adhyaya I: Pada II: Sutras 13-1610 min
  44. 44Adhyaya I: Pada II: Sutras 18-209 min
  45. 45Adhyaya I: Pada II: Sutras 21-229 min
  46. 46Adhyaya I: Pada II: Sutras 23-2410 min
  47. 47Adhyaya I: Pada II: Sutras 26-299 min
  48. 48Adhyaya I: Pada II: Sutras 30-325 min
  49. 49Adhyaya I: Pada III: Sutras 1-710 min
  50. 50Adhyaya I: Pada III: Sutra 89 min
  51. 51Adhyaya I: Pada III: Sutras 9-119 min
  52. 52Adhyaya I: Pada III: Sutras 12-149 min
  53. 53Adhyaya I: Pada III: Sutra 169 min
  54. 54Adhyaya I: Pada III: Sutras 17-1910 min
  55. 55Adhyaya I: Pada III: Sutras 20-219 min
  56. 56Adhyaya I: Pada III: Sutras 22-258 min
  57. 57Adhyaya I: Pada III: Sutras 26-289 min
  58. 58Adhyaya I: Pada III (Part 10)8 min
  59. 59Adhyaya I: Pada III: Sutras 29-309 min
  60. 60Adhyaya I: Pada III: Sutras 31-329 min