Hilton's Scale of Perfection and Rolle's Fire of Love

Hilton's Scale of Perfection and Rolle's Fire of Love · Walter Hilton and Richard Rolle

Rolle: Book II, Chapter I: Why the Perfect Contemplatives Take No Heed to Outward Song, and of Their Error that Reprove Them: and How to Profit in Contemplation

Translated by Various: Hilton modernised by Dom Serenus Cressy (1659); Rolle by Richard Misyn (1435) · 92 of 117

WHY THE PERFECT CONTEMPLATIVES TAKE NO HEED TO OUTWARD SONG, AND OF THEIR ERROR THAT REPROVE THEM: AND HOW TO PROFIT IN CONTEMPLATION

Because in the kirk of God there are singers ordained in their degree, and set to praise God and to stir the people to devotion, some have come to me asking why I would not sing as other men when they have ofttimes seen me in the solemn masses. They weened forsooth I had done wrong, for ilk man, they say, is bound to sing bodily before his Maker, and yield music with his outward voice. I answered not thereof; for they knew not how I gave forth melody and a sweet voice to my Maker, but, because they could not understand by what way, they weened that no man might have ghostly song.

Truly it is fondness to trow that a man, and especially he that is perfectly given to God's service, should not have a special gift from His love that many other men have not; but many trow this because in themselves they find none such. Therefore I have thought to show some manner of answer, and not fully give stead to the reprovers. How longs the life of other men to them whose manners, as they wot, in many things surpass their life, and are far higher in things that are unseen? Whether it is lawful to God to do what He will; or their sight is wicked and God is good? Nor will they bring God's rule under their measure, for are not all men God's? And whom He will, He takes; and whom He will, He forsakes; and to whom He will and when He will, He gives what pleases Him, to show the greatness of His Goodness?

Therefore I trow they grumble and backbite because they would that others higher in devotion come down to them, and conform themselves in all things to their lowers, for they ween they be higher when they are far lower in merit. Therefore my soul has found boldness to open my music a little that is come to me by burning love; in which I sing before Jesu and sound notes of the greatest sweetness. Also the more they have stood up against me, because I fled the outward songs that are wont in the kirks, and the sweetness of the organ that is heard gladly by the people, only abiding among these either when the need of hearing mass--which elsewhere I could not hear--or the solemnity of the day asked it on account of the backbiting of the people.

Truly I have desired to sit alone that I might take heed to Christ alone that had given to me ghostly song, in the which I might offer Him praises and prayers. They that reproved me trowed not this, and therefore they would have brought me to their manner; but I could not leave the grace of Christ and consent to fond men that knew me not within. Therefore I let them speak, and I did that that was to do after the state in the which God had set me.

Rolle's three-stage account of holy warmthMembership note · Open in the app

For this shall I say, thanking Christ's glory, that henceforward I no more fear others who be thus fond, nor that presume to deem proudly; for that I have done is not from feigning simulation, and being taken by imagination, as some say of me; and many therewith are beguiled that ween they have that they never received. But in truth an unseen joy has come to me and I have verily waxed warm within me with the fire of love; the which has taken my heart from these low things, so that, singing in Jesu, full far have I flown from outward melody to full inward.

Whence I have hated filth, and cast out vanity of words, and have not taken meats in superfluity, nor have striven unwisely to govern myself; although it were said of me I was given to rich houses, and to be fed well and live in pleasures. But by God's working I had set my soul otherwise, so that I savoured things heavenly rather than sweetness of meats; and for this cause I have loved a certain wilderness, and I chose to live away from men, only speeding the needs of the body, and so soothly I received solace of Him that I loved.

A teenage hermit's flight from OxfordMembership note · Open in the app

It is not to be trowed that in the beginning of his turning a man may run to the height of contemplative life or feel the sweetness thereof, when it is well known that contemplation is gotten in great time and with great labour, and is not given anon to every man, although it be had with all joy when it is gotten. Truly it is not in man's power to receive it, nor no man's labour however great is worthy it; but of the goodliness of God it is given to true lovers that have desired to love Christ above man's hoping.

Yet many after penance have fallen from innocence, afterwards gliding into idleness and to the abomination of sinners, because they were not burning in charity; seldom and so thinly have they the sweetness of contemplation that they are too weak to stand when they are tempted; or else, being weary and loathing ghostly food, they desire worldly comfort among sinners.

Truly to despise this world and desire the heavenly kingdom and desire Christ's love is full good; and, hating sin, to read busily or meditate on holy books. A devout soul being used and taught in these has a ready defence against the fiend's darts. It is truly to the devil's confusion when we spread God's word against all his temptations. Forsooth the sufferers, and bearers in patience of the burden and heat of temptation, suffer not themselves to be led into the love of deceitful sweetness; and after many tears and busy prayers they shall be enflamed with eternal love, and shall feel heat abiding in themselves withouten end, for in their meditation the fire shall wax warm.

Up next

Rolle: Book II, Chapter II: The Teaching of Contemplative Life in Praying, Meditating, Fasting, and Waking: and of the Proud Contemplative: and of True and Very Ghostly Song

Therefore one chosen and alway desiring love turns himself into his love; for he has neither worldly substance nor desires to have, but following Christ by wilful poverty lives content and paid by the alms of other men, whiles his conscience is clear and made sweet with heavenly savour.

About 5 min to read

Take your library with you

Continue to the next chapter

Open the next chapter in the app. Reading is free.

Scan to open the next chapter

Every book is free to read. Downloading the app may not keep this chapter link; return here to open it after installing.

Contents

Hilton's Scale of Perfection and Rolle's Fire of Love · Walter Hilton and Richard Rolle

117 chapters

  1. 01Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter I: That the inward State of the Soul should be like the outward2 min
  2. 02Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter II: Of the Active Life, and the Exercises and the Works thereof2 min
  3. 03Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter III: Of the Contemplative Life, and the Exercises and Works thereof1 min
  4. 04Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter IV: Of three Sorts that be of Contemplation and of the First of them3 min
  5. 05Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter V: Of the Second Sort of Contemplation2 min
  6. 06Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter VI: Of the Lower Degree of the Second Sort of Contemplation1 min
  7. 07Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter VII: Of the Higher Degree of the Second Sort of Contemplation2 min
  8. 08Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter VIII: Of the Third Sort of Contemplation2 min
  9. 09Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter IX: Of the Difference that is betwixt the Second and Third Sort of Contemplation3 min
  10. 10Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter X: How that Appearings or Shewings to the Corporal Senses or Feelings may be both good and evil2 min
  11. 11Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter XI: How thou shalt know whether the Showing or Apparition to the bodily Senses and Feelings be good or evil5 min
  12. 12Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter XII: How and in what things a Contemplative Man should be busied2 min
  13. 13Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter XIII: How Virtue beginneth in Reason and Will and is perfected in Love and Liking, or Affection2 min
  14. 14Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter XIV: Of the Means that bring a Soul to Contemplation13 min
  15. 15Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter XV: Of a firm and resolute Intent and Purpose necessary hereto3 min
  16. 16Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter XVI: Of a firm Faith necessary thereto, and what things we ought to believe thereby3 min
  17. 17Hilton: Book I, Part I, Chapter XVIII: A brief Rehearsal of what hath been said, and of an Offering31 min
  18. 18Hilton: Book I, Part II, Chapter III: That a Man should know the measure of his Gift, that he may3 min
  19. 19Hilton: Book I, Part III, Chapter I: Of the Knowledge of a Man's Soul and the Powers thereof necessary3 min
  20. 20Hilton: Book I, Part III, Chapter II: Of the Worthiness and Excellency of the Soul and how it was lost60 min
  21. 21Hilton: Book I, Part III, Chapter VII: Of Covetousness and how a Man may know how much of it is hid in his Heart18 min
  22. 22Hilton: Book I, Part III, Chapter IX: Of the Five Windows of this dark Image, and what cometh in by them, and how they are to be ordered9 min
  23. 23Hilton: Book I, Part III, Chapter X: Of another Hole or Window that is to be stopped as well as the Windows of the Senses, namely, the Imagination2 min
  24. 24Hilton: Book I, Part III, Chapter XI: A Brief Rehearsal of what hath been said in the former Chapters,3 min
  25. 25Hilton: Book I, Part III, Chapter XII: A comparing of this Image with the Image of Jesus, and how it9 min
  26. 26Hilton: Book I, Part III, Chapter XIII: How a Man shall be shapen to the Image of Jesus, and Jesus2 min
  27. 27Hilton: Book I, Part III, Chapter XIV: The Conclusion of this Book, and of the Cause why it was made,12 min
  28. 28Hilton: Book II, Part I, Chapter II: Of two Manners of reforming of this Image, one in fulness,4 min
  29. 29Hilton: Book II, Part I, Chapter III: That Reforming in part is in two manners, one in Faith, another2 min
  30. 30Hilton: Book II, Part I, Chapter IV: That through the Sacrament of Baptism (which is grounded in the Passion of Christ) this Image is reformed from Original Sin2 min
  31. 31Hilton: Book II, Part I, Chapter V: That through the Sacrament of Penance (that consisteth in8 min
  32. 32Hilton: Book II, Part I, Chapter VI: That we are to believe stedfastly the reforming of this Image,2 min
  33. 33Hilton: Book II, Part I, Chapter VII: That all the Souls that live humbly in the Faith of Holy5 min
  34. 34Hilton: Book II, Part I, Chapter VIII: That Souls reformed need ever to fight and strive against the8 min
  35. 35Hilton: Book II, Part I, Chapter IX: That this Image is both fair and foul whilst it is in this Life5 min
  36. 36Hilton: Book II, Part I, Chapter X: Of three sorts of Men, whereof some be not reformed, and some be reformed only in Faith, and some both in Faith and Feeling3 min
  37. 37Hilton: Book II, Part I, Chapter XI: How Men that abide and live in Sin, misshape themselves into the12 min
  38. 38Hilton: Book II, Part II, Chapter I: OF REFORMING IN FAITH AND FEELING ALSO: That this Reforming17 min
  39. 39Hilton: Book II, Part II, Chapter III: An Entry or good Beginning of a Spiritual Journey, showing how9 min
  40. 40Hilton: Book II, Part II, Chapter IV: Of certain Temptations and Lettings which Souls feel from their8 min
  41. 41Hilton: Book II, Part II, Chapter V: Of an evil Day and a good Night, and what they mean, and how the10 min
  42. 42Hilton: Book II, Part II, Chapter VI: How that the Desire of Jesus felt in this lightsome Darkness4 min
  43. 43Hilton: Book II, Part II, Chapter VII: How a Man shall know false Illuminations that are feigned by7 min
  44. 44Hilton: Book II, Part II, Chapter VIII: How great profit it is to the Soul to be brought through Grace11 min
  45. 45Hilton: Book II, Part II, Chapter IX: That the Working of our Lord Jesus in the Reforming of a Soul,5 min
  46. 46Hilton: Book II, Part II, Chapter X: How it falleth out sometimes that Souls that are but beginning or6 min
  47. 47Hilton: Book II, Part II, Chapter XI: After what manner a Man shall come to know his own Soul, and how11 min
  48. 48Hilton: Book II, Part III, Chapter I: In what Sense this Manner of Speaking of Reforming of a Soul in4 min
  49. 49Hilton: Book II, Part III, Chapter II: How God openeth the inward Eye of the Soul to see Him, not all6 min
  50. 50Hilton: Book II, Part III, Chapter III: How Jesus is Heaven to the Soul, and why He is called Fire5 min
  51. 51Hilton: Book II, Part III, Chapter IV: Of two manner of Loves, created and uncreated, and how we are8 min
  52. 52Hilton: Book II, Part III, Chapter V: How that some Souls love Jesus by bodily Fervours, and by their5 min
  53. 53Hilton: Book II, Part III, Chapter VI: That the Gift of Love, amongst all other Gifts of Jesus, is most6 min
  54. 54Hilton: Book II, Part III, Chapter VII: How Love through gracious Beholding of Jesus slayeth all8 min
  55. 55Hilton: Book II, Part III, Chapter VIII: How Love slayeth all stirrings of Wrath and Envy easily; [259]5 min
  56. 56Hilton: Book II, Part III, Chapter IX: How Love slayeth Covetousness, Lechery and Gluttony, and the8 min
  57. 57Hilton: Book II, Part III, Chapter X: What virtues and Graces a Soul receiveth through opening of the11 min
  58. 58Hilton: Book II, Part III, Chapter XI: How such special Grace for the Beholding of our Lord Jesus is10 min
  59. 59Hilton: Book II, Part III, Chapter XII: A Commendation of Prayer offered up to Jesus by a Contemplative9 min
  60. 60Hilton: Book II, Part III, Chapter XIII: How a Soul through the opening of the spiritual Eye receiveth9 min