Creative Evolution

Creative Evolution · Henri Bergson

III · Footnotes

Translated by Arthur Mitchell (1911) · 36 of 50

FOOTNOTES:

[Footnote 78: We have developed this point in Matière et mémoire, chaps. ii. and iii., notably pp. 78-80 and 169-186.]

[Footnote 79: Faraday, A Speculation concerning Electric Conduction (Philosophical Magazine, 3d. series, vol. xxiv.).]

[Footnote 80: Our comparison does no more than develop the content of the term [Greek: logos], as Plotinus understands it. For while the [Greek: logos] of this philosopher is a generating and informing power, an aspect or a fragment of the [Greek: psychê], on the other hand Plotinus sometimes speaks of it as of a discourse. More generally, the relation that we establish in the present chapter between "extension" and "detension" resembles in some aspects that which Plotinus supposes (some developments of which must have inspired M. Ravaisson) when he makes extension not indeed an inversion of original Being, but an enfeeblement of its essence, one of the last stages of the procession, (see in particular, Enn. IV. iii. 9-11, and III. vi. 17-18). Yet ancient philosophy did not see what consequences would result from this for mathematics, for Plotinus, like Plato, erected mathematical essences into absolute realities. Above all, it suffered itself to be deceived by the purely superficial analogy of duration with extension. It treated the one as it treated the other, regarding change as a degradation of immutability, the sensible as a fall from the intelligible. Whence, as we shall show in the next chapter, a philosophy which fails to recognize the real function and scope of the intellect.]

[Footnote 81: Bastian, The Brain as an Organ of the Mind, pp. 214-16.]

[Footnote 82: We have dwelt on this point in a former work. See the Essai sur les données immédiates de la conscience, Paris, 1889, pp. 155-160.]

[Footnote 83: Op. cit. chaps. i. and ii. passim.]

[Footnote 84: Cf. especially the profound studies of M. Ed. Le Roy in the Revue de métaph. et de morale.]

[Footnote 85: Matière et mémoire, chapters iii. and iv.]

[Footnote 86: See in particular, Phys., iv. 215 a 2; v. 230 b 12; viii. 255 a 2; and De Caelo, iv. 1-5; ii. 296 b 27; iv. 308 a 34.]

[Footnote 87: De Caelo, iv. 310 a 34 [Greek: to d' eis ton autou topon pherethai hekaoton to eis to autou eidos esti pheresthai].]

[Footnote 88: On these differences of quality see the work of Duhem, L'Évolution de la mécanique, Paris, 1905, pp. 197 ff.]

[Footnote 89: Boltzmann, Vorlesungen über Gastheorie, Leipzig, 1898, pp. 253 ff.]

[Footnote 90: In a book rich in facts and in ideas (La Dissolution opposée a l'évolution, Paris, 1899), M. André Lalande shows us everything going towards death, in spite of the momentary resistance which organisms seem to oppose.--But, even from the side of unorganized matter, have we the right to extend to the entire universe considerations drawn from the present state of our solar system? Beside the worlds which are dying, there are without doubt worlds that are being born. On the other hand, in the organized world, the death of individuals does not seem at all like a diminution of "life in general," or like a necessity which life submits to reluctantly. As has been more than once remarked, life has never made an effort to prolong indefinitely the existence of the individual, although on so many other points it has made so many successful efforts. Everything is as if this death had been willed, or at least accepted, for the greater progress of life in general.]

[Footnote 91: We have dwelt on this point in an article entitled "Introduction à la métaphysique" (Revue de métaphysique et de morale, January, 1903, pp. 1-25).]

[Footnote 92: Cf. a paper written (in Russian) by Serkovski, and reviewed in the Année biologique, 1898, p. 317.]

[Footnote 93: Ed. Perrier, Les Colonies animales, Paris, 1897 (2nd edition).]

[Footnote 94: Delage, L'Hérédité, 2nd edition, Paris, 1903, p. 97. Cf. by the same author, "La Conception polyzoïque des êtres" (Revue scientifique, 1896, pp. 641-653).]

[Footnote 95: This is the theory maintained by Kunstler, Delage, Sedgwick, Labbé, etc. Its development, with bibliographical references, will be found in the work of Busquet, Les êtres vivants, Paris, 1899.]

Up next

IV · The Idea of Nothing

It remains for us to examine in themselves two theoretical illusions which we have frequently met with before, but whose consequences rather than principle have hitherto concerned us.

About 11 min to read

Take your library with you

Continue to the next chapter

Open the next chapter in the app. Reading is free.

Scan to open the next chapter

Every book is free to read. Downloading the app may not keep this chapter link; return here to open it after installing.

Contents

Creative Evolution · Henri Bergson

50 chapters

  1. 01I · Of Duration in General10 min
  2. 02I · Unorganized Bodies and Abstract Time11 min
  3. 03I · Organized Bodies and Real Duration12 min
  4. 04I · Of Transformism12 min
  5. 05I · Mechanism and the Whole of Life10 min
  6. 06I · Radical Finalism7 min
  7. 07I · Beyond Mechanism and Finalism14 min
  8. 08I · The Quest of a Criterion13 min
  9. 09I · The Eye: Darwin and De Vries11 min
  10. 10I · Identical Organs by Different Means9 min
  11. 11I · Neo-Lamarckism and Orthogenesis15 min
  12. 12I · The Vital Impetus14 min
  13. 13I · Footnotes6 min
  14. 14II · The Evolutionary Process and Adaptation11 min
  15. 15II · The Animal and the Plant12 min
  16. 16II · Torpor, Intelligence, and Instinct10 min
  17. 17II · Energy and the Nervous System7 min
  18. 18II · The Divergent Lines of Animal Life12 min
  19. 19II · Instinct and Intelligence15 min
  20. 20II · Two Modes of Knowledge13 min
  21. 21II · Intelligence and Inert Matter16 min
  22. 22II · The Nature of Instinct15 min
  23. 23II · Intuition, Consciousness, and the Place of Man13 min
  24. 24II · Footnotes4 min
  25. 25III · Knowledge and Life: The Method of Philosophy12 min
  26. 26III · Beyond the Pure Intellect9 min
  27. 27III · The Genesis of Matter and Space13 min
  28. 28III · Geometry and Deduction7 min
  29. 29III · Induction and Physical Laws9 min
  30. 30III · Two Kinds of Order11 min
  31. 31III · Order and the Idea of Disorder14 min
  32. 32III · Tension and Extension12 min
  33. 33III · Creation and the Genesis of Matter9 min
  34. 34III · The Impetus of Life and Creation14 min
  35. 35III · Consciousness, Mankind, and the Spirit15 min
  36. 36III · Footnotes4 min left
  37. 37IV · The Idea of Nothing11 min
  38. 38IV · Negation and Affirmation15 min
  39. 39IV · The Illusion of the Void13 min
  40. 40IV · Form and Becoming8 min
  41. 41IV · The Cinematographical Method7 min
  42. 42IV · Zeno's Arrow and the Eleatics11 min
  43. 43IV · The Philosophy of Forms10 min
  44. 44IV · Plato and Aristotle on Change9 min
  45. 45IV · Becoming in Modern Science11 min
  46. 46IV · Two Views of Time15 min
  47. 47IV · Descartes, Spinoza, and Leibniz12 min
  48. 48IV · The Criticism of Kant13 min
  49. 49IV · The Evolutionism of Spencer10 min
  50. 50Translator's Footnotes3 min