All the Works of Epictetus

All the Works of Epictetus · Epictetus

Book I, Chapter 17

Translated by Elizabeth Carter · 19 of 100

1. Since it is Reason which sets in order and finishes all other Things, it ought not itself to be left in Disorder. But by what shall it be set in Order?

Evidently, either by itself, or by something else.

Well: either that too is Reason, or there is something else superior to Reason (which is impossible): and, if it be Reason, what, again, shall set that in Order? For, if Reason can set itself in Order in one Case, it can in another and, if we will still require any thing further, it will be infinite, and without End.

But, the more urgent Necessity is to cure [our Opinions, Passions], and the like.

Would you hear about these, therefore? Well: hear. But then, if you should say to me, "I cannot tell whether your Arguments are true or false;" and if I should happen to express myself doubtfully, and you should say, "distinguish [which Sense you mean]," I will bear with you no longer; but will retort your own Words upon you; the more urgent Necessity is, &c. Therefore, I suppose, the Art of Reasoning is first settled: just as, before the Measuring of Corn, we settle the Measure. For, unless we first determine what a Bushel, and what a Balance, is, how shall we be able to measure or weigh? Thus, in the present Case: unless we have first learnt, and accurately examined, that which is the Criterion of other Things, and by which other Things are learnt, how shall we be able accurately to learn any thing else? And how is it possible? Well: a Bushel, however, is only Wood, a Thing of no Value [in itself]: but it measures Corn. And Logic [you say] is of no Value in itself. That we will consider hereafter. Let us, for the present, then, make the Concession. It is enough that it distinguishes and examines, and, as one may say, measures and weighs all other Things. Who says this? Is it only Chrysippus, and Zeno, and Cleanthes? And doth not Antisthenes say it? And who is it, then, who has written, That the Beginning of a right Education is the Examination of Words? Doth not Socrates say it? Of whom, then, doth Xenophon write, That he began by the Examination of Words; what each signified.

2. Is this, then, the great and admirable Thing, to understand or interpret Chrysippus?

Who says that it is? But what, then, is the admirable Thing?

To understand the Will of Nature.

An interpreter for the interpreter's interpreterMembership note · Open in the app

Well then: do you apprehend it of yourself? In that Case, what Need have you for any one else? For, if it be true, that Men never err but involuntarily; and you have learnt the Truth, you must necessarily act right.

But, indeed, I do not apprehend the Will of Nature.

Who, then, shall interpret that?

They say, Chrysippus. I go and inquire what this Interpreter of Nature says. I begin not to understand his Meaning. I seek one to interpret that. Here explain how this is expressed, and as if it were put into Latin. How, then, doth a supercilious Self-opinion belong to the Interpreter!

Indeed, it doth not justly belong to Chrysippus himself, if he only interprets the Will of Nature, and doth not follow it: and much less to his Interpreter. For we have no need of Chrysippus, on his own Account; but that, by his Means, we may apprehend the Will of Nature: nor do we need a Diviner on his own Account; but that, by his Assistance, we hope to understand future Events, and what is signified by the Gods: nor the Entrails of the Victims, on their own Account; but, on the Account of what is signified by them: neither is it the Raven, or the Crow, that we admire; but the God, who delivers his Significations by their Means. I come, therefore, to the Diviner and Interpreter of these Things; and say, "Inspect the Entrails for me: what is signified to me?" Having taken, and laid them open, he thus interprets them. You have a Choice, Man, incapable of being restrained or compelled. 'This is written here in the Entrails. I will show you this first, in the Faculty of Assent. Can any one restrain you from assenting to Truth? —— "No one." —— Can any one compel you to admit a Falshood? —— "No one." —— You see, then, that you have in this Topic a Choice incapable of being restrained, or compelled, or hindered. Well: is it any otherwise with regard to Pursuit and Desire? What can conquer one Pursuit? —— "Another Pursuit." —— "What, Desire and Aversion? "Another Desire and another Aversion." If you set Death before me (say you) you compel me. No: not what is set before you doth it: but your Principle, that it is better to do such or such a thing, than to die. Here, again, you see it is your own Principle which compels you: that is, Choice compels Choice. For, if God hath constituted that Portion which he hath separated from his own Essence, and given to us, capable of being restrained or compelled, either by himself, or by any other, he would not have been God; nor have taken care of us, in a due manner.

What the entrails were made to sayMembership note · Open in the app

3. These Things, says the Diviner, I find in the Victims. These Things are signified to you. If you please, you are free. If you please, you will have no one to complain of; no one to accuse. All will be equally according to your own Mind, and to the Mind of God.

4. For the Sake of this Oracle, I go to the Diviner and the Philosopher: admiring not him merely on the Account of his Interpretation, but the Things which he interprets.

Up next

Book I, Chapter 18

About 5 min to read

Take your library with you

Listen to this chapter

Opens this chapter in the app. Tap Listen to begin. Narration requires membership.

Scan to open this chapter
Continue to the next chapter

Open the next chapter in the app. Reading is free.

Scan to open the next chapter

Every book is free to read. Downloading the app may not keep this chapter link; return here to open it after installing.

Contents

All the Works of Epictetus · Epictetus

100 chapters

  1. 01Introduction32 min
  2. 02Preface: Arrian to Lucius Gellius2 min
  3. 03Book I, Chapter 15 min
  4. 04Book I, Chapter 26 min
  5. 05Book I, Chapter 32 min
  6. 06Book I, Chapter 45 min
  7. 07Book I, Chapter 52 min
  8. 08Book I, Chapter 67 min
  9. 09Book I, Chapter 75 min
  10. 10Book I, Chapter 83 min
  11. 11Book I, Chapter 96 min
  12. 12Book I, Chapter 103 min
  13. 13Book I, Chapter 117 min
  14. 14Book I, Chapter 126 min
  15. 15Book I, Chapter 131 min
  16. 16Book I, Chapter 143 min
  17. 17Book I, Chapter 152 min
  18. 18Book I, Chapter 164 min
  19. 19Book I, Chapter 175 min left
  20. 20Book I, Chapter 185 min
  21. 21Book I, Chapter 195 min
  22. 22Book I, Chapter 203 min
  23. 23Book I, Chapter 211 min
  24. 24Book I, Chapter 224 min
  25. 25Book I, Chapter 232 min
  26. 26Book I, Chapter 244 min
  27. 27Book I, Chapter 255 min
  28. 28Book I, Chapter 263 min
  29. 29Book I, Chapter 274 min
  30. 30Book I, Chapter 285 min
  31. 31Book I, Chapter 2911 min
  32. 32Book I, Chapter 302 min
  33. 33Book II, Chapter 17 min
  34. 34Book II, Chapter 24 min
  35. 35Book II, Chapter 32 min
  36. 36Book II, Chapter 43 min
  37. 37Book II, Chapter 56 min
  38. 38Book II, Chapter 65 min
  39. 39Book II, Chapter 73 min
  40. 40Book II, Chapter 85 min
  41. 41Book II, Chapter 94 min
  42. 42Book II, Chapter 105 min
  43. 43Book II, Chapter 114 min
  44. 44Book II, Chapter 124 min
  45. 45Book II, Chapter 136 min
  46. 46Book II, Chapter 146 min
  47. 47Book II, Chapter 154 min
  48. 48Book II, Chapter 169 min
  49. 49Book II, Chapter 177 min
  50. 50Book II, Chapter 185 min
  51. 51Book II, Chapter 197 min
  52. 52Book II, Chapter 208 min
  53. 53Book II, Chapter 215 min
  54. 54Book II, Chapter 227 min
  55. 55Book II, Chapter 239 min
  56. 56Book II, Chapter 246 min
  57. 57Book II, Chapter 251 min
  58. 58Book II, Chapter 262 min
  59. 59Book III, Chapter 19 min
  60. 60Book III, Chapter 24 min