All the Works of Epictetus

All the Works of Epictetus · Epictetus

Book I, Chapter 28

Translated by Elizabeth Carter · 30 of 100

1. What is the Cause of Assent to any thing?

Its appearing to be true.

It is not possible, therefore, to assent to what appears to be not true.

Why?

Because it is the very Nature of the Understanding to agree to Truth; to be dissatisfied with Falshood; and to suspend its Belief, in doubtful Cases.

What is the Proof of this?

Persuade yourself, if you can, that it is now Night.

Impossible.

Unpersuade yourself that it is Day.

Impossible.

Persuade yourself, that the Stars are, or are not, even.

Impossible.

2. When any one, then, assents to what is false, be assured, that he doth not wilfully assent to it, as false (for, as Plato affirms, the Soul is never voluntarily deprived of Truth): but what is false, appears to him to be true. Well, then: Have we, in Actions, any thing correspondent to True and False, in Propositions?

Try telling yourself it's night right nowMembership note · Open in the app

Duty, and contrary to Duty: Advantageous, and Disadvantageous: Suitable and Unable; and the like.

A Person then, cannot think a Thing advantageous to him, and not chuse it.

He cannot. But how says Medea?

" I know what Evils wait my dreadful Purpose; But vanquish'd Reason yields to powerful Rage. "

Why Medea's excuse doesn't satisfy himMembership note · Open in the app

Because she thought, that very Indulgence of her Rage, and the punishing her Husband, more advantageous than the Preservation of her Children.

Yes: but she is deceived.

Shew clearly to her, that she is deceived, and she will forbear: but, till you have shewn it, what is the to follow, but what appears to herself?

Nothing.

Why, then, are you angry with her, that the unhappy Woman is deceived, in the most important Points; and instead of a human Creature, becomes a Viper? Why do not you rather, as we pity the Blind and Lame, so likewise pity those who are blinded and lamed, in their superior Faculties? Whoever, therefore, duly remembers, that the Appearance of Things to the Mind is the Standard of every Action to Man: that this is either right or wrong: and, if right, he is without Fault; if wrong, he himself bears the Punishment: for that one Man cannot be the Person deceived, and another the Sufferer: will not be outrageous and angry at any one; will not revile, or reproach, or hate, quarrel with, any one.

Extending pity to a blinded mindMembership note · Open in the app

3. So then, Have all the great and dreadful Deeds, that have been done in the World, no other Original than Appearance?

Absolutely, no other. The Iliad consists of nothing but the Appearances [of Things to the Mind]; and the Use of those Appearances. It appeared [right] to Paris, to carry off the Wife of Menelaus. It appeared [right] to Helen, to follow him. If, then, it had appeared [right] to Menelaus, to persuade himself, that it was an Advantage to be robbed of such a Wife, what would have happened? Not only the Iliad had been loft, but the Odyssey too.

Do these great Events then, depend on so small a Cause?

What are these Events, which you call great?

Wars, and Seditions; the Destruction of Numbers of Men; and the Overthrow of Cities.

And what great Matter is there in all this? Nothing. What great Matter is there in the Death of Numbers of Oxen, Numbers of Sheep, or in the burning or pulling down Numbers of Nests of Storks or Swallows?

Are these like Cases, then?

Perfectly like. The Bodies of Men are destroyed, and the Bodies of Sheep and Oxen. The Houses of Men are burnt, and the Nests of Storks. What is there great or dreadful in all this? Pray, shew me what Difference there is between the House of a Man, and the Nest of a Stork, so far as it is a Ha bitation, excepting that Houses are built with Beams, and Tiles, and Bricks; and Nests, with Sticks and Clay?

What, then, is a Stork and a Man a like Thing? What do you mean?

With regard to Body, extremely like.

Is there no Difference, then, between a Man and a Stork?

Yes, surely: but not in these Things.

In what then?

Enquire; and you will find, that the Difference consists in something else. See whether it be not, in acting with Discernment: whether it be not, in a social Disposition; in Fidelity, Honour, Steadiness, Judgment.

4. Where then, is the great Good or Evil of Man?

Where his Difference is. If this is preserved, and remains well fortified, and neither Honour, Fidelity, or Judgment, is destroyed, then he himself is preserved likewise: but, when any of these is lost and demolished, he himself is lost also. In this do all great Events consist. Paris, they say, was undone, because the Greeks invaded Troy, and laid it waste; and his Family were slain in Battle. By no means: for no one is undone by an Action, not his own. All that was only laying waste the Nests of Storks. But his true Undoing was, when he lost the modest, the faithful, the hospitable, and the decent Character. When was Achilles undone? When Patroclus died? By no means. But when he gave himself up to Rage; when he wept over a Girl; when he forgot, that he came there, not to get Mistresses, but to fight. This is human Undoing; this is the Siege; this the Overthrow; when right Principles are ruined; when these are destroyed.

The moment Paris was actually ruinedMembership note · Open in the app

But, when Wives and Children are led away Captives, and the Men themselves killed, are not these, Evils?

Whence do you conclude them such? Pray inform me, in my Turn.

Nay: but whence do you affirm, that they are not Evils?

5. Let us recur to the Rules. Produce the Preconceptions. One cannot sufficiently wonder at what happens, in this Respect. When we would judge of Light and Heavy, we do not judge by Guess: when of Strait and Crooked, not by Guess: and, in general, when it concerns us to know the Truth of any Particular, no one of us will do any thing, by Guess, But, where the first and principal Cause is concerned, of acting either right or wrong; of being prosperous or unprosperous, happy or unhappy; there only do we act rashly, and by Guess. No-where any thing like a Balance; no-where any thing like a Rule: but some Fancy strikes me, and I instantly act conformably to it. For am I better than Agamemnon or Achilles; that they, by following their Fancies, should do and suffer so many Things, and Fancy not suffice me? And what Tragedy hath any other Original? The Atreus of Euripides, what is it? Fancy. The Oedipus of Sophocles? Fancy. The Phœnix? The Hippolytus? All Fancy. To what Character, then, doth it belong, think you, to take no care of this Point? What are they called who follow every Fancy?

No scale for the choice that mattersMembership note · Open in the app

Madmen.

Do we, then, behave any otherwise?

Up next

Book I, Chapter 29

1. The Essence of Good and Evil, is a certain Disposition of the Choice.

About 11 min to read

Take your library with you

Listen to this chapter

Opens this chapter in the app. Tap Listen to begin. Narration requires membership.

Scan to open this chapter
Continue to the next chapter

Open the next chapter in the app. Reading is free.

Scan to open the next chapter

Every book is free to read. Downloading the app may not keep this chapter link; return here to open it after installing.

Contents

All the Works of Epictetus · Epictetus

100 chapters

  1. 01Introduction32 min
  2. 02Preface: Arrian to Lucius Gellius2 min
  3. 03Book I, Chapter 15 min
  4. 04Book I, Chapter 26 min
  5. 05Book I, Chapter 32 min
  6. 06Book I, Chapter 45 min
  7. 07Book I, Chapter 52 min
  8. 08Book I, Chapter 67 min
  9. 09Book I, Chapter 75 min
  10. 10Book I, Chapter 83 min
  11. 11Book I, Chapter 96 min
  12. 12Book I, Chapter 103 min
  13. 13Book I, Chapter 117 min
  14. 14Book I, Chapter 126 min
  15. 15Book I, Chapter 131 min
  16. 16Book I, Chapter 143 min
  17. 17Book I, Chapter 152 min
  18. 18Book I, Chapter 164 min
  19. 19Book I, Chapter 175 min
  20. 20Book I, Chapter 185 min
  21. 21Book I, Chapter 195 min
  22. 22Book I, Chapter 203 min
  23. 23Book I, Chapter 211 min
  24. 24Book I, Chapter 224 min
  25. 25Book I, Chapter 232 min
  26. 26Book I, Chapter 244 min
  27. 27Book I, Chapter 255 min
  28. 28Book I, Chapter 263 min
  29. 29Book I, Chapter 274 min
  30. 30Book I, Chapter 285 min left
  31. 31Book I, Chapter 2911 min
  32. 32Book I, Chapter 302 min
  33. 33Book II, Chapter 17 min
  34. 34Book II, Chapter 24 min
  35. 35Book II, Chapter 32 min
  36. 36Book II, Chapter 43 min
  37. 37Book II, Chapter 56 min
  38. 38Book II, Chapter 65 min
  39. 39Book II, Chapter 73 min
  40. 40Book II, Chapter 85 min
  41. 41Book II, Chapter 94 min
  42. 42Book II, Chapter 105 min
  43. 43Book II, Chapter 114 min
  44. 44Book II, Chapter 124 min
  45. 45Book II, Chapter 136 min
  46. 46Book II, Chapter 146 min
  47. 47Book II, Chapter 154 min
  48. 48Book II, Chapter 169 min
  49. 49Book II, Chapter 177 min
  50. 50Book II, Chapter 185 min
  51. 51Book II, Chapter 197 min
  52. 52Book II, Chapter 208 min
  53. 53Book II, Chapter 215 min
  54. 54Book II, Chapter 227 min
  55. 55Book II, Chapter 239 min
  56. 56Book II, Chapter 246 min
  57. 57Book II, Chapter 251 min
  58. 58Book II, Chapter 262 min
  59. 59Book III, Chapter 19 min
  60. 60Book III, Chapter 24 min