All the Works of Epictetus

All the Works of Epictetus · Epictetus

Book II, Chapter 24

Translated by Elizabeth Carter · 56 of 100

1. When a certain Person said to him; "I have often come to you, with a Desire of hearing you; and you have never given me any Answer; but now, if possible, I intreat you to say something to me:" Do you think, replied Epictetus, that, as in other Things, so in Speaking, there is an Art, by which he, who understands it, speaks skilfully, and he, who doth not, unskilfully?

I do think so.

He then, who, by speaking, both benefits himself, and is able to benefit others, must speak, skilfully; but he who rather hurts, and is hurt, must be unskilful in this Art of speaking. For you may find some Speakers hurt, and others benefited. And are all Hearers benefited by what they hear? Or will you find some benefited, and some hurt?

Both.

Then those who hear skilfully are benefited, and those who hear unskilfully, hurt.

Granted.

Is there an Art of Hearing, then, as well as of Speaking?

It seems so.

If you please, consider it thus too. To whom, do you think, the Practice of Music belongs?

To a Musician.

To whom the proper Formation of a Statue?

To a Statuary.

And do not you imagine some Art necessary, to view a Statue skilfully?

I do.

If, therefore, to speak properly belongs to one who is skilful, do not you see, that to hear with Benefit belongs likewise to one who is skilful? For the present, however, if you please, let us say no more of doing Things perfectly, and with Benefit, since we are both far enough, from any thing of that Kind: but this seems to be universally confessed, that he, who would hear Philosophers, needs some Kind of Exercise in Hearing. Is it not so? Tell me then, on what I shall speak to you? On what Subject are you able to hear me?

On Good and Evil.

The Good and Evil of what? Of a Horse?

No.

Of an Ox.

No.

What then, of a Man?

Yes.

Do we know, then, what Man is? What is his Nature; what our Idea of him is; and how far our Ears are open in respect to this Matter. Nay, do you understand what Nature is; or are you able, and in what Degree, to comprehend me, when I come to say; "But I must use Demonstration to you?" "How should you? Do you comprehend what Demonstration is; or, how a Thing is demonstrated; or by what Methods; or, what resembles a Demonstration, and yet is not a Demonstration? Do you know what True, or False is? What is consequent to a Thing, and what contradictory? Or unsuitable, or dissonant? But I must excite you to Philosophy. How shall I show you that Contradiction, among the Generality of Mankind, by which they differ, concerning Good and Evil, Profitable and Unprofitable, when you know not what Contradiction means? Show me then, what I shall gain, by discoursing with you? Excite an Inclination in me, as a proper Pasture excites an Inclination to eating, in a Sheep: for if you offer him a Stone, or a Piece of Bread, he will not be excited. Thus we too have certain natural Inclinations to speaking, when the Hearer appears to be somebody; when he gives us Encouragement: but if he sits by, like a Stone, or a Tuft of Grass, how can he excite any Desire in a Man? Doth a Vine say to an Husbandman, "Take care of me?" No: but invites him to take care of it, by showing him, that, if he doth, it will reward him for his Care. Who is there, whom engaging sprightly Children do not invite to play, and creep, and prattle, with them? But who was ever taken with an Inclination to divert himself, or bray, with an Ass? for, be the Creature ever so little, it is still a little Ass.

What a good listener offers a teacherMembership note · Open in the app

2. Why do you say nothing to me, then?

I have only this to say to you: That, whoever is ignorant what he is, and wherefore he was born, and in what kind of a World, and in what Society; what Things are good, and what evil; what fair, and what base: who understands neither Discourse, nor Demonstration; nor what is true, nor what is false; nor is able to disginguish between them: such a one will neither exert his Desires, nor Aversions, nor Pursuits, conformably to Nature: he will neither intend, nor assent, nor deny, nor suspend, his Judgment, conformably to Nature: but will wander up and down, intirely deaf and blind, supposing himself to be somebody; while he is in reality, nobody. Is there any thing new, in all this? Is not this Ignorance the Cause of all the Errors that have happened, from the very Original of Mankind? Why did Agamemnon and Achilles differ? Was it not for want of knowing what is advantageous, what disadvantageous? Doth not one of them say, It is advantageous to restore Chryseis to her Father; the other, That it is not? Doth not one say, That he ought to take away the Prize of the other; the other, that he ought not? Did they not, by these means, forget who they were, and for what Purpose they had come there? Why, what did you come for, Man: to gain a Mistress, or to fight? —— "To fight." —— With whom? With the Trojans, or Greeks? —— "With the Trojans." —— Leaving Hector, then, do you draw your Sword upon your own King? And do you, good Sir, forgetting the Duties of a King,

Achilles, Agamemnon, and what they forgotMembership note · Open in the app

Intrusted with a Nation, and its Cares,

go to squabbling, about a Girl, with the bravest of your Allies; whom you ought, by every Method, to conciliate and preserve? And will you be inferior to a subtle Priest, who pays his Court, with the utmost Care, to you fine Gladiators? —— You see the Effects, which Ignorance of what is advantageous, produces. —— "But I am rich [you may say], as well as other People." —— What, richer than Agamemnon? —— "But I am handsome too." —— What, handsomer than Achilles? —— "But I have fine Hair too." —— Had not Achilles finer and brighter? Yet he neither combed it nicely, nor curled it. —— "But I am strong too." —— Can you lift such a Stone then, as Hector, or Ajax? —— "But I am of a noble Family too." —— Is your Mother a Goddess, or your Father descended from Jupiter? And what Good did all this do Achilles, when he sat crying for a Girl? —— "But I am an Orator." —— And was not he? Do not you see how he treated the most eloquent of the Greeks, Phœnix and Ulysses? How he struck them dumb? This is all I have to say to you; and even this, against my Inclination.

Why so?

Because you have given me no Encouragement. For what can I see in you, to encourage me, as spirited Horses do their Riders? Your Person? That you disfigure. Your Dress? That is effeminate. Your Behaviour? Your Look? Absolutely nothing. When you would hear a Philosopher, do not say to him, "You tell me nothing;" but only show yourself worthy, or fit, to hear; and you will find, how you will move him to speak.

Making yourself fit to be taughtMembership note · Open in the app

Up next

Book II, Chapter 25

WHEN one of the Company said to him, "Convince me that Logic is necessary;" Would you have me demonstrate it to you, says he?

About 1 min to read

Take your library with you

Listen to this chapter

Opens this chapter in the app. Tap Listen to begin. Narration requires membership.

Scan to open this chapter
Continue to the next chapter

Open the next chapter in the app. Reading is free.

Scan to open the next chapter

Every book is free to read. Downloading the app may not keep this chapter link; return here to open it after installing.

Contents

All the Works of Epictetus · Epictetus

100 chapters

  1. 01Introduction32 min
  2. 02Preface: Arrian to Lucius Gellius2 min
  3. 03Book I, Chapter 15 min
  4. 04Book I, Chapter 26 min
  5. 05Book I, Chapter 32 min
  6. 06Book I, Chapter 45 min
  7. 07Book I, Chapter 52 min
  8. 08Book I, Chapter 67 min
  9. 09Book I, Chapter 75 min
  10. 10Book I, Chapter 83 min
  11. 11Book I, Chapter 96 min
  12. 12Book I, Chapter 103 min
  13. 13Book I, Chapter 117 min
  14. 14Book I, Chapter 126 min
  15. 15Book I, Chapter 131 min
  16. 16Book I, Chapter 143 min
  17. 17Book I, Chapter 152 min
  18. 18Book I, Chapter 164 min
  19. 19Book I, Chapter 175 min
  20. 20Book I, Chapter 185 min
  21. 21Book I, Chapter 195 min
  22. 22Book I, Chapter 203 min
  23. 23Book I, Chapter 211 min
  24. 24Book I, Chapter 224 min
  25. 25Book I, Chapter 232 min
  26. 26Book I, Chapter 244 min
  27. 27Book I, Chapter 255 min
  28. 28Book I, Chapter 263 min
  29. 29Book I, Chapter 274 min
  30. 30Book I, Chapter 285 min
  31. 31Book I, Chapter 2911 min
  32. 32Book I, Chapter 302 min
  33. 33Book II, Chapter 17 min
  34. 34Book II, Chapter 24 min
  35. 35Book II, Chapter 32 min
  36. 36Book II, Chapter 43 min
  37. 37Book II, Chapter 56 min
  38. 38Book II, Chapter 65 min
  39. 39Book II, Chapter 73 min
  40. 40Book II, Chapter 85 min
  41. 41Book II, Chapter 94 min
  42. 42Book II, Chapter 105 min
  43. 43Book II, Chapter 114 min
  44. 44Book II, Chapter 124 min
  45. 45Book II, Chapter 136 min
  46. 46Book II, Chapter 146 min
  47. 47Book II, Chapter 154 min
  48. 48Book II, Chapter 169 min
  49. 49Book II, Chapter 177 min
  50. 50Book II, Chapter 185 min
  51. 51Book II, Chapter 197 min
  52. 52Book II, Chapter 208 min
  53. 53Book II, Chapter 215 min
  54. 54Book II, Chapter 227 min
  55. 55Book II, Chapter 239 min
  56. 56Book II, Chapter 246 min left
  57. 57Book II, Chapter 251 min
  58. 58Book II, Chapter 262 min
  59. 59Book III, Chapter 19 min
  60. 60Book III, Chapter 24 min